Watch / Mergers & Acquisitions
Does the Woodside-Santos merger make sense?
Does the Woodside-Santos merger make sense?
About this video
Romano Sala Tenna from Katana Asset Management shares his views on the proposed merger between Santos and Woodside, stating that it makes sense from the perspective of Santos, which he believes is undervalued. He does, however, caution about potential regulatory approval issues around gas supply, as these two entities would control a large portion of the market. Despite this, he sees no insurmountable issues should the merger take place, envisaging a globally-relevant entity within the top ten.
Romano believes it's crucial for fossil fuel companies to become larger as they transition economically to decarbonisation, necessitating substantial balance sheets and funding. He asserts that an amplified portfolio approach will enable these companies to manage their assets more effectively and negotiate with governments and jurisdictions. Romano’s opinion of Santos and Woodside extends to other companies such as Corona, which he describes as “diabolically cheap”, anticipating a future re-rating once their recent capital raise has been absorbed.
Turning his attention to the financial services sector, Romano professes his view on Perpetual’s assets, describing them as Tier 1 class and prime targets for companies like Soul Patts. He also mentions a potential interest in the underperforming intellectual property services group, IPH, despite their share price downturn. Acknowledging the sticking points for a smaller entity like IPH, he believes the strong business model and long-standing client relationships could offer a lucrative opportunity for investors.
Find the full unedited transcript of this interview below:
Let's stick with the takeover talk. Sol Patterson continues to show interest in perpetual why Santos is engaged with preliminary discussions with Woodside to merge those two companies. Alright, Romano Sala joins us. Tenna, I should say, from Katana Asset Management. Uh, Romano, thanks so much for joining us. All right. Let's start with a couple of takeover plays then. First to will the Santos Woodside, uh, possible merger. They're what? Um, they're in preliminary talks. Where do you see that going? And what are the potential obstacles?
0:35
Yeah. So from our end, we're a Santos shareholder. We're not in Woodside at the moment. And we're in Santos because we think it's undervalued. And there's been a lot of talk about does the deal make sense or not. Look we think it does make sense. It's not great synergies. There's a lot of adjacencies though in terms of the assets that they both have. Um, and so, you know, from a Santos point of view, we see that business is being fundamentally undervalued. So if you know from a Woodside shareholder point of view, they can they can pick up that those assets at a reasonable price. It works for them and also helps the Santos shareholders get a rerating sooner rather than later. Obviously the bigger issue there is to do with, um, with the regulatory approvals around gas supply, you know, in our numbers, it's something like between 40 and 47%. For example, the of the WA market, uh, would be controlled by those two entities. So there are going to be some issues around how they manage that, where they have to divest assets, where they have some very strict and onerous operating conditions and pricing conditions on, on gas supply,
1:35
etc.. Um, but I don't think there's anything that's insurmountable.
1:40
Should this actually eventuate? What, um. What would that merge company look like, do you think? Particularly on a global stage?
1:49
Yeah very clearly top ten. And we can see in the two large, um, transactions we've seen in the last month in the US there. You know, the move is for these fossil fuel companies to get large, and they need to do that for a number of reasons. One is because they need to be able to, um, transition in economically to, to decarbonize. And to do that, they need big, big balance sheets, big, um, dollars to be able to spend on, on that wave of renewables and the like there. Um, so that's, that's really critical to, to those businesses there. Um, and then, you know, I think, I think also from, um, from the point of view of a, you know, the shareholders, it enables the companies to really cherry pick the assets, for example, we're seeing at the moment. You know, Bruce, we had some good news today on the drilling side. But there's still, you know, issues around the pipeline and so forth. I think what it means is it gives the big fossil fuel companies the capacity to actually, um, properly manage their, um, their portfolios. And they can they can push back
2:49
on governments that are uh, and uh, jurisdictions that aren't, you know, enabling them to properly develop assets. So it just gives them a much broader portfolio approach globally.
3:01
Now let's stick in that spice, because I gather that you've got an interesting croon at the moment. What are you saying here?
3:08
Yeah. Look, Corona is just diabolically cheap. It really is. I mean, on, you know, on any numbers we look at on our own internal model or on consensus forecasts across the various platforms, you know, Iris Bloomberg, whatever. It's on a PE of something like three times earnings. Now they've done a, you know, a a larger capital raise and people expected. And so we have got indigestion at the moment. But once that works its way through it is the the pretty much the only pure play oil company left on the ASX. It's the fourth largest oil and gas company. Uh, but the only large, you know, the largest pure play. So, you know, on those sorts of multiples, once we see that, that, um, capital raise work its way through the, the system, I suspect at a more positive oil price, which will happen at some point, I expect to see quite a substantial rerating. Citi just put out an updated note in the last couple of days there, with a 350 price target versus a sort of, you know, one 195 last price there. So, you know, we do see very large
4:08
upside from there. And we think it's not a bad time. So you're looking at that given where the oil price is to we think the oil price is is at or close to a a short term bottom. So a bit of more positive sentiment I think you could see that Rerate and Raimondo, as we mentioned at the top there, that other takeover that's in play at the moment with soul, Patts and Perpetual. How do you see that playing out?
4:29
Yeah, look, we're fortunate enough to be a shareholder in perpetual as well, probably, um, you know, a bit of good timing there as much as anything else. But the reason we're a shareholder is because they are tier one assets. You know, there's no doubt their trust business is the best in Australia by a country mile and is a, you know, really wonderful assets just, you know, clipping the ticket and you realize income streams for the ultra long term. So it's not surprising that that soul packs is after that part of the business. The wealth management is best in breed as well. And we actually really think that their funds management business is is quite stellar across the board. You know, I think they combine two very good businesses. Perpetual and Penny were both really good managers. And I think they're just starting to get some of the synergies out of that. So I think, you know, soul patch timing is very opportunistic. Needless to say, I think there's a lot more to play out in this. I'd be surprised if there's not a lot of other parties out there who will form joint ventures to bid for these assets. As we saw previously with Regal and Private Equity, I think that it makes a lot. There are literally tier one
5:29
assets. They don't come around too often. And, uh, and, and they try to get very cheap multiples. So I think this is just it's very early stages has a long way to play out. Um, still in a space of wealth management premium. Um, I know that to your, uh, interested in picking that up at the moment. What are you seeing?
5:50
We started buying two weeks ago. We're probably be lucky to get on the timing there, because we have been have been on our radar for quite a while, and we almost pulled the trigger previously. Look, we really like the business. We've done a lot of channel checks. Still got some more to do, but you know, it's only the I think the ninth or 10th largest, um, uh, platform by size. But it's it's consistent in the top four, although they ranked 3 or 4 in terms of new inflows. So it says they're doing something very right. The channel checks that we sort of have undertaken indicate that, you know, in that high net worth, sort of sophisticated investor space, uh, they are sort of best in breed. And I think that's a really rapidly growing area. And there's so many groups that want to get access to that space for a whole variety of reasons, you know, for vertical integration and so forth. So I think, you know, their latest declining share down of $0.38 is, in our view, a really good buying opportunity. You know, we have to remember two years ago. So in November 2021 um, you know net worth sort of lobbed a $1.50,
6:50
um,
6:51
bid, uh, on that company at $0.38. Now, it's a better business now than it was then. I very much out of favor. Yes. Um, but also, you know, the balance sheet is absolutely pristine. Large net cash holding are for selling their offshore business, uh, doing a very aggressive buyback. They bought back 10% of their stock in, you know, last 3 to 4 weeks, which gives me a lot of confidence again. So a lot of things lining up. The one thing that's working against it, of course, is it is small. It's, you know, sub 200 million. So we don't do much in that space. But occasionally when we see something we really like, we do sort of, um, head down that low. Let's rent it out with, um, Iph in the intellectual property Services group. Uh, look, certainly over the past 12 months, its share price has come off significantly. So are you seeing a buying opportunity then?
7:40
Yeah, again, I mean, you know, we track these companies. We like to track companies over over decades. Um, I know it sounds like long term time frames, but, you know, we haven't been in a shareholder in IP for probably 6 or 7 years, but we've always kept an open file on it because it is a very high calibre business. Uh, we're a little bit, you know, stuck as to explaining why. Why the share price is here, which always does concern us. We always worry about things we don't know and understand, but it is a high caliber business is trading on sort of just over 14 times earnings, which is probably about 50% below its long term average price earnings ratings. Most consensus forecasts are close to the $10 valuation versus, you know, the $6.50 value price is trading at today. We do like what they're doing offshore in Canada. They're going to get to 30% market share. And they'll look to to sort of head south from there in terms of jurisdictions. But you know, they are globally. Building out a really fantastic business is indispensable. And the thing we like the most about is their
8:40
very long term, you know, customer timeframes. If you employ one of the IP businesses to do your, um, intellectual property work, your patent work, then you'll probably keep them on the tap for the next 20 or 30 years, because you want to make sure that if there are problems down the track, that you've got the right people there to to handle those problems. So really sticky business, great long term client relationships. And we like the way they're building that out.