Will the US election slow the market?
Will the US election slow the market?
About this video
Key insights:
Potential 'soft landing' scenario for the US economy
China's economic struggles and potential impacts on global trade
Potential effect on the stock market with the upcoming US elections
Jesse Moors from Spatium Capital shares his views on the US economy, suggesting a possible 'soft landing', despite the potential delay of rate cuts until 2025. Jesse highlights the market's anticipation of these cuts, discussing concerns about the US Federal Reserve's lack of action potentially impacting consumer confidence and causing exuberance to subside. While discussing the possibility of a soft landing is not a certainty, he implies an emerging probability for its achievement, given the slight decrease in inflation observed in Europe and the US.
Jesse then discussed concern about China's economic struggles, suggesting that the country's exporting disinflation could impact global trade relationships. He cautions against the possible consequences of significantly discounted Chinese products inundating the market, particularly about existing trade relationships with the US. Jesse points to a potential impact on global supply chains, with key ports worldwide already strained, and mentions the geopolitical issues exacerbating the situation.
Lastly, with the US elections on the horizon, Jesse explores the potential effect on market performance, indicating that historically, the stock market fares marginally better under a Democrat administration. However, he concludes that predicting market performance based on the political party or the president alone often leads to inconclusive findings. He advises focusing on other metrics for market analysis rather than trying to identify patterns from specific subsets of data.
Below is the full unedited transcript of this interview:
0:00
To discuss more on the potential soft landing scenario, as well as the much anticipated US elections. Which president has been best for the stock market? Let's move on to my next guest for the hour, Jesse Moors from Spatium Capital, who joins me now. Jesse, great to catch up. Thank you for joining us today.
0:19
Thanks for having us, Danielle. Okay. Really interesting this whole soft landing scenario, because the chief economist at Apollo has possibly put, let's say, a thorn in the soft landing scenario for the US. And he was quoted on Friday as saying, looks like the US economy is actually gathering a little bit more momentum after that dovish tone set by Powell at the back end of last year. Sticky inflation seems to be coming back and he's looking at a no landing with possibly those rate cuts actually being deferred to 2025. Within that context how are you guys seeing things at the moment.
1:02
I think that's a pretty reasonable consensus at this point, Danielle, that possibly not, um, the first cut in 2025. It's looking like we might still get one for 2024 in the US, but the market exuberance without getting significant rate cuts this year definitely seems to have come out. I mean, we saw futures markets are priced in about 85 basis points now worth of cuts in the US by the year end. It was previously about 140 before that. So that's quite a significant dip from where expectations were heading into the new year globally at least for for the major markets, Europe, US. Um, it is looking like that there is a strong or not strong rather but but an emerging chance that the soft landing is achieved. I mean we saw inflation's down in France and Germany as well over the month of February. A little bit of a scare in the US where they were up about 0.4% on their core core inflation reading. But then that's coupled with the fact that we had a quite a strong reading in the ISM
2:02
manufacturers index, 15 month high, which is obviously quite important for the, the, the proxy of manufacturers and how they're feeling about the economy. But then, like you and I discussed in, in early February that the jobs report adding some 353,000 jobs. Now, even though we discussed that some of that data is probably not as clear as it looks, it seems like the US has taken that in its stride and considered it to be quite a positive thing for the economy, so chances of the soft landing are still probably a 6040 at this stage in favor of the soft landing. It's definitely not a sure thing or a guarantee. Uh, we also see saw as well, some downwards pressure on commodities throughout January, except for oil, of course, and that's hurting us here a bit more domestically as well with with Aussie Smalls being about 25, 26%, uh, exposed to resources and minerals. So yeah, definitely not out of the woods yet, but some, some positive signs are coming. Uh, not the same level of exuberance that we probably saw at the end of last year, though. Yeah. Do you think markets would be a little bit
3:02
more than a little bit disappointed if the fed actually does kick those rate cuts out to 2025. Because you've just discussed that. Yes. They've been pricing out those crazy six cuts. But the market really hasn't got its head around no cuts.
3:21
I think that's a really fair statement to make, Danielle, and would tend to agree. I think that the fed needs to have an indication, or rather show an indication to to markets and broadly just consumer confidence that there is a cut on the horizon for 2024. Um, going too soon here could be dangerous as well, especially as we've seen that tick up in inflation. We've also got some interesting dynamics which we'll touch on in a second as well, with the deflationary environment in China and what that looks like for an impact as an impact to the global economy. So the Fed's probably watching some of these external influences closely as well. We would think at this stage, because there's just still a number of things that they're the unknown unknowns, as they say, that could rattle that soft landing. So going too soon, it could be as detrimental as, uh, as leaving it too late at this stage. Yeah. Now, your next point, Jesse, is really interesting. Um, possible deflation out of China. And it comes as there's a very big article I read in the Wall Street
4:20
Journal about just this point. China really looking to, I suppose, increase their exports, um, because they, you know, the demand isn't there locally and also therefore exporting disinflation with we're seeing with electric vehicles. So what's your take on the potential for China to be an exporter of this disinflation or deflation?
4:47
Yeah, it's quite extraordinary, isn't it? We. We wouldn't have thought that the world's, uh, once proxy for global growth is now looking to the world to help get out of a bit of its economic funk, but, um, fascinating that they've had such a decrease on their or almost all of their inflationary Mark's, uh, measures rather at the moment and in quite a bit of a downward spiral on in disinflation, which can be as dangerous as is runaway inflation when you have this race to the bottom, essentially of everything being cut. Um, a lot of Western companies that are based in Shanghai at the moment are reporting a little bit of a lack of confidence in the market, looking more externally to try and as you said, Danielle, really ship this disinflation overseas, try and sell products abroad that, uh, otherwise the local economy is not buying where we think this might start to be a bit of a problem is we obviously saw at the sort of the crux of Covid, so many global suppliers took their, uh, their outsource work from China to places like
5:47
Vietnam, Indonesia, India, these emerging economies really benefited from that. If we start to see quite an influx of these products in China coming back out into the market, that's going to obviously naturally agitate and create some frictions for those those economies that have benefited from this influx of manufacturing into theirs. Uh, and then it begs the question, what it does for an already pretty well fractured relationship trade relationship with the US. There's obviously still the looming issues with Taiwan semiconductors being semiconductor facilities rather being built up in Oregon and places like that in the US en masse. That's not going to help if we suddenly see an influx of significantly discounted Chinese products entering the market, because naturally it's a it's a matter of the consumer is going to follow where the cheapest, uh, cheapest products are. And we don't want to see that fracture. Obviously, some of those US relationships with those new new emerging economies. So it's a it's an interesting one. It's something we're looking at closely.
6:47
Interestingly for us we're seeing this be quite a problem in the global supply and supply chain and logistics, um, space where they're really looking at how they're going to be able to manage the influx of products leaving the country and how they're going to facilitate the the vessels to get it in and out. So, um, interesting that we're in this position and probably something we'll keep a close eye on when you say about the logistics, is that got anything to do with all the geopolitics that's going on? Well, you've got two things, don't you. You've got the Suez Canal with its problems. But also the Panama Canal has had a chronic drought which is also caused problems.
7:23
And then you couple it with the fact that you've also got significant trouble still in the Red sea. Um, they're seeing a significant spike in pirate, uh, pirate activity over their attacking trade vessels. So you've got quite a bit of. And this is an interesting part of the economy that I suppose we don't look at broadly as a consensus in finances. Um, supply chain still goes on, whether you like it or not. We still have to go and be able to buy a bananas in the morning and, and, you know, buy a new bed frame or whatever that might be. But we often don't pay attention to global supply chain constraints up until they become a problem, as we saw through Covid. Uh, and as you said, with the geopolitical issues still with the Suez Canal and the Panama Canal, you then throw in these dynamic or these this measure rather of China potentially flooding the market with with cheap discounted products. How are we going to facilitate that when you've already got so many different ports, key ports across the world, and Singapore is already starting to see some of that trouble as well, being one of the major ones for Asia. Uh, how are they going to facilitate this influx
8:23
demand when you've already got vessels pretty much put to the brink in some of these other, um, you know, war affected areas? Uh, I love your point. It's not a problem until it is. That kind of sums up markets, doesn't it? It's never bad news until it is bad news. So speaking of uncertainties, uh, obviously the US elections and, uh, well, I suppose for some of us it seems like a pretty huge year when it comes to that. If you were to put your lens over some of the potential outcomes and whether or not markets perform better under, you know, the GOP or the Democrats, share your thoughts with us.
9:02
Look. Then we thought we'd throw this one in there, because I think we're getting a bit of a name out of ourselves for having a always a bit of an interesting stack to round up the chat. But, um, yes, it's a good point. You know, Democrat versus Republican, Trump versus Biden, although Trump's not confirmed yet, but it's a strong chance and he's likely to be the running candidate for the Republican Party. It comes up almost every four years as we hit an election year in the US. You know, which which party does better. Now, there was an academic in the US that that ran this data. And so as a first party, did, you know, Democrat versus Republican? Democrat, funnily enough, comes out marginally just on top on average since the Truman era. Uh, I think they did like a 12.2% versus the, the, um, uh, the Republican Party, which did about 11.1%. And that's performance for the stock market. So you're talking about a 1.1 1.2% differential from the stock market's performance, depending on Republican or Democrat. What was interesting about this paper from this academic rather, was that he
10:02
dug further and said, well, if we can try and strip out all of the influences that had nothing necessarily to do with the president at the time. So whether that's, um, you know, credit spreads, whether it was the health of the economy broadly, whether is it the yield curve is indicating a recession, uh, things like macro influences, you know, wars, uh, financial crashes, etc. if you can strip that all out. And it's all very, very obviously very technical. But for the purposes of this, if you can strip it all out, what was the actual performance of the president relative to the stock market? Was there an ability of the of the president of the day to be able to influence the performance of the stock market now, all the way back to Truman, Jimmy Carter came out as the best, um, performance and performer, and Ronald Reagan was was actually the worst. But the reality was, funnily enough, when you actually look at the data, it's an absolute random walk. And I think it's a really good reflection and probably a good way to to conclude that the chap, Daniel, is that you can look for patterns in just about any subset of
11:02
data. The reality is, is that it's a it's often an exercise in futility. It doesn't actually get you anywhere. So trying to pick a political party, trying to pick a president to be a good performer for the stock market is probably not your best use of time. And I daresay you'd be better off looking at other metrics for your analysis.