Why you need to consider met coal
Why you need to consider met coal
About this video
Aaron Binsted from Lazard Asset Management presents his analysis of the financial quarter, noting the underperformance of the Australian market due to commodities-related stocks. He asserts that the large cap stocks in the Australian market have had good price performance, largely due to multiples, rather than earnings growth. On reflecting Australia's trend mimicking the US, Aaron claims there may not be the same fundamentals to back it up.
In discussing the sectors he's favouring, Aaron cites the coal industry as an interesting one, specifically met coal or coking coal used in steelmaking. He points out how Australia dominates the supply of this coal in the seaborne market but has struggled to keep up with supply. He emphasizes the rising demand for steel in India and an upgrade in long-term net coal price by Goldman Sachs to stress the potential of the sector. In this context, he brings attention to companies like Whitehaven (ASX: WHC), Coronado (ASX: CRN), Bowen Coking Coal (ASX: BCB), and Stanmore (ASX: SMR), which have potentially not been adequately represented in share prices.
Addressing energy transitions, Aaron insists on the vitality of met coal in the short to mid-term, especially for India, which is set to add 50 million tons of blast furnace production by 2030. Further, he considers defensive stocks as worthwhile, given that consumer-facing names are reportedly experiencing earning downgrades. He particularly singles out Regis Group and Endeavour Group as attractive prospects in the defensive category.
Full unedited transcrit below:
0:00
Now take a look at the bigger picture and perhaps some get some specifics as we look back at the June quarter. Arab instead joining us from Lazard Asset Management Aaron welcome. Morning, Andrew, as we begin the new financial year. So when you look back at the June quarter and I guess you look at the Australian market, it has underperformed global markets, perhaps weighed down, particularly by those commodity related stocks. How do you view it. Yeah. Look interesting. This is something that I don't normally point to. But size was probably one of the dominant factors, if not the not dominant factor in the June quarter. We've, you know, relentlessly here about the Magnificent Seven in the US. Those, you know, large cap stocks that just continue powering on. Um, now we've actually seen similar trends from a market performance perspective in Australia. Not as dramatic but perhaps driven by somewhat different things. So we know that the Mag seven has been driven by a very strong earnings, with Nvidia being the prime example and the key driver with a bit of multiple expansion on top. In Australia, our
1:00
very large cap stocks, our mega cap stocks have had good price performance, but pretty much without the earnings growth. So it's all been multiples. So some might look at that and say we're kind of following the US trends but perhaps without the same fundamentals to back it up. All right. Given what we've seen in the June quarter as we're now
1:17
into the next quarter beginning of the new financial year, what are you looking at at the moment? What what sectors are you favoring? Yeah, look, there's one that I think is interesting. That's quite a small sector but interesting nonetheless. And that's met coal or coking coal. Now this is the coal that's used in steelmaking primarily. Now why is it interesting. So it's actually a structurally tight market. Um, so Australia is about 50% of the supply of the seaborne market for that commodity. It's about 350 million tonnes that market. Australia has really struggled to keep up its supply. So in 2023, Australian export volumes are still about 20 million tonnes down on where they were in 2019, despite demand growing. India is the great source of growth there. Their steel demand and steel production is going up a lot and indeed over the next 5 or 6 years, their blast furnace steel production is is expected to go up another 50 million tons. Now, these factors led Goldman Sachs just recently to
2:16
upgrade their long term net coal price, their hard coking coal price to $240. So that's the interesting backdrop, um, tight structural market. As I mentioned. There's also a bit of a catalyst. So very unfortunately there was an underground gas ignition at the Grosvenor coal mine in Queensland, one of Anglos, Anglos, coal mines. Now that mine is about 3.5 million tonnes of production of the very highest grade of coal at that premium level, hard coking coal, about 1.5% of seaborne supply. Now, that might not sound a lot, but when you've got a tight underlying market, pulling some of that supply out can really make a difference. All right. So yeah you look at that scenario then um supply taking a bit of a hit demand increasing. Let's take a look specifically at some of the stocks you see is likely to benefit. Yeah absolutely. So firstly you know the underlying commodity prices gapped up about $10 a tonne on that news. That's right across the spectrum. So from that premium level best
3:16
quality and even the mid vol and low vol. excuse me, um, PCI specs of coal, they've gone up really strongly. So there's probably four names that have the best leverage to that in Australia. Uh there's Whitehaven because they bought those BHP mines last year. Um there's Coronado,
3:33
there's Bowen Coking Coal and there's Stanmore. So we've got really strong commodity price moves. The share prices have not responded that much. And it's worth noting that last time there was an outage of this kind in the northern yellow mine, this outage wasn't in place for a matter of weeks. It was a period you needed to measure in months, if not years. So we may have a constrained supply environment for some time, leading to elevated commodity prices, which should help those stocks, which is why I think they're interesting. What's your longer term view then on this subsector, given obviously that energy transition we're seeing, but perhaps the necessity of coal, certainly, at least in the short to mid term. Yeah. Look especially for met coal and this is where I really would differentiate it from thermal coal for power production. Look India needs more steel. They are building more blast furnaces. As I mentioned between now and 2030 they're going to add 50 million tons of blast furnace production that's locked in demand growth until the end of 2030. There's just no
4:33
supply. Coal is really supply constrained. And so it really is a structurally, you know, quite positive story. Okay. So you're much more focused on India than China even given obviously the growth issues that continue. Yeah. And China does not actually import that much coal from Australia anymore. They get a lot of it. They about 50% is internally sourced in China, but they also import from Russia and from Mongolia. So it's not as big a driver as the seaborne market. It really is all about India. Now, the same time, I see you're also looking at some of the defensive stocks at the moment. Why is that. Yeah. So while the headline aggregate retail sales data looks pretty good through May, we saw a bunch of, you know, more consumer facing names give earnings downgrades. And so it may just be worth thinking about what are some reasonably valued more defensive names in the market. And there's a couple that we think are relevant for people now. And indeed, you know, playing a role in our portfolios. One of those is region group. Um, the, you know, um, neighborhood shopping center REIT. Um, owner. Why do we think that's
5:33
interesting? First of all, it's an asset class that is not being disrupted, um, by work, from home, online shopping, any of those sorts of things. It's everyday needs type retail. You know, these are the things that your local Woolworths or Coles is housed in, you know, at your local shops.
5:49
Yield is a bit, you know, around 6.5% today. We think that's going to vary modestly, grow over time with lease escalation. It's trading at about a 12% discount to book value. Um, what was interesting is in the last revaluation the asset value was flat. Now we think that investors should think that asset values will decline over time, but the pace is decelerating and given you've got income growth coming through, it should not be a drastic change and it should be very manageable. So that's the name we like. Another one I see you're looking at is endeavour Group, with the potential that it is going to split its business. I think the split is less likely personally, given that the bottle shops and the pubs and the gaming go together.
6:30
Be that as it may.
6:32
Excuse me.
6:34
Uh, endeavor. It's now trading at a discount to the market. Those staple type businesses, Coles, Woolies, and ever have typically traded at premiums. We know from Metcash results that liquor retailing is holding up really well.
6:47
And gaming stats coming through a really solid. So, uh, excuse me again, solid 4.5% yield. Comps suggest good earnings valuation. Attractive. We like endeavor.