Sign inJoin free

Watch / Stock Selection

Why this QSR play is more compelling than Starbucks

2 Oct 202310:09

Why this QSR play is more compelling than Starbucks

General information only. ausbiz videos are general information only, produced by Ausbiz TV Pty Ltd, a media business that doesn’t give financial advice. They don’t take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Consider whether it’s right for you and read the PDS and TMD before acting on anything you watch.

About this video

Jonathan Nurick from DivGro shares his take on two companies in the quick service restaurant industry, with a focus on global organizations that have shown impressive and reliable dividend growth. In the U.S. market, he targets enterprises known for their capacity to increase their dividends staggeringly and regularly. Rather than being drawn to resources, Jonathan shows a preference for industries with a solid foundation, such as software, medical devices, and franchise businesses.

Jonathan focuses on two titans in the fast-service restaurant sector, Starbucks (NASDAQ: SBUX) and Wingstop (NASDAQ: WING). He commends Wingstop for its financial planning and lower capital obligation required of franchisees, elements that have triggered a wave of new establishments.

Conversely, he draws attention to Starbucks' shift in employee policies amidst the pandemic, an action that ignited the cause for unionizing and led to a redistribution of investments from shareholders towards enhancing the working experience. Looking at the dividend scenario, Jonathan finds Wingstop's accelerated rate a better prospect than the decelerating one of Starbucks.

Find the full unedited transcript of this interview below:

0:00

Let's get stock specific now. Looking at two international companies in the quick restaurant service industry. Our next guest saying that one company looks far more compelling than the other despite a wide market cap differential. Jonathan Nurick joining us from DivGro. Jonathan, good to catch up with you again. Thanks for having me. Well, I was just I was going to get your perspective on where markets are tracking at the moment. I mean, what

0:23

I mean, because we take this opportunity because we're in the end of the quarter. What's your overall assessment of of particularly, I guess, investor sentiment at the moment? So so like we were discussing before, active growth, we're looking for a very, very narrow segment of the global companies and that we're looking for companies with explosive dividend growth and reliable dividend growth. So while I'd love to tell you about what's going on in the macro, in all companies everywhere, I can really just discuss with you a small minority of companies that adhere to our principles. No, that's fair enough. Hence your your company name div growth. That's what your your perspective is, isn't it? So with a focus though, on the US market, before we get specific with a couple of the companies you're looking at, what are you looking for in your portfolio? We are looking for companies that have a demonstrated ability and desire to pay and raise their dividend at a rapid rate, which we consider 15% per year. Now there is overwhelming academic

1:22

and empirical tested evidence that shows that where the dividend goes, the price almost always follows. And so if you can find a company that can raise its dividend and 15% a year

1:34

common sense as well as what we just discussed, would suggest that the share price should follow more or less at the same rate. Now, not every day, because on any given day you might have macro news of one kind or another that shakes investor sentiment. But over a longer time period, and we're thinking in a multi year, even decade based approach, if you can find those companies that can raise at 15% a year,

2:00

you're going to get a similar outcome from a share price performance standpoint. So are you sector agnostic as such? Is it all bottom up for you? We are sector agnostic, except that there are relatively few sectors that historically have been able to do what we're looking for because sectors that are very sensitive to various macro fluctuations that are beyond their control simply won't be able to raise their profitability in a almost linear fashion. So we're not in resources because we don't have any insight about whether a particular resource is going up or down and therefore whether the profitability of our companies are going to be up or down. On the other hand, we're looking for things that we consider have an installed base and that might be an installed base of software and installed base of medical devices. Or in the case that we're going to talk about today and installed base of franchisees who are running their business. All right. Well, let's get into it then. You'll focus on two companies today, one of which will be well known,

3:00

Starbucks, the other less so in Wingstop. Just explain. We know what Starbucks so everybody knows about Starbucks. Everybody has probably sampled the coffee. Many do it daily. But Wingstop is a little bit different. Wingstop is a quick service restaurant format in the chicken wing space. Wingstop is very cleverly designed from a financial standpoint. It has been designed to use that part of the chicken that is generally overlooked by restaurants, and therefore it's much cheaper than, say, breast milk,

3:32

breast meat,

3:34

Wingstop are designed to be takeaway or delivery, meaning that you don't need a big rental footprint for your store. And if you need a smaller footprint and it's very simple to cook wings, you innovate by sauces, not by core part of the menu. You only need four people to run a restaurant. So if you have a smaller footprint that doesn't need to be on the high street because it's being a takeaway delivery and it hardly needs any people and its cost of inputs is lower. What you have is a low capital commitment for a franchisee to set up a store and then you can have enormous throughput and that becomes extremely attractive for franchisees from a financial standpoint. And it's no surprise that Wingstop literally has franchisees queuing up to open these stores, whereas most of the rest of their peers, there's a little bit of back and forth of trying to persuade franchisees to put up more capital

4:34

because the financial investment is simply a little bit different.

4:38

Wingstop today has just crossed 2000 restaurants, which doesn't sound like much compared to Starbucks. Is that just in North America? It's primarily in North America, but they have a significant presence in Mexico, in Indonesia, in the UK, they recently begun the process of rolling out stores in South Korea and Canada. So it is a model that has been proven in a. Few different countries. And interestingly, because they're seen as a value, relatively cheap price, but high indulgence occasion in other markets where there is a less developed chicken wing experience, as there is in the United States, they're able to charge slightly higher and units or restaurants open at much higher opens in terms of the revenue that goes through a store, but the cost is the same. All right. So before we get into how its dividend profile stacks up, then, let's take a look at Starbucks, the comparison there. So pardon me. So Starbucks would be very familiar. Starbucks is one of the

5:38

largest quick service formats in the world in the coffee space. And we were invested in Starbucks for a very long time. And in fact, from a dividend standpoint, we were very pleased when the pandemic broke out and everybody obviously had to go in and stay in their home and stores were closed at Starbucks with their dividend commitment, continue to pay and raise their dividend, which all of the companies in the portfolio did. There are minority. Many companies reduced or withdrew their dividends, but because of the pandemic, a few things came to light that challenged Starbucks. And one by one, our opinion cooled on Starbucks. Starbucks for a very long time was an innovator in looking after its employees. They gave health care benefits when it wasn't the thing that was done in quick service restaurants. They gave educational benefits to their staff. And in fact, if we look at Starbucks as if it were a university, it would be one of the largest universities in the

6:38

United States. That's a fantastic benefit to give to its employees. But the nature of the role of a Starbucks employee in a store changed during the pandemic because for a while people couldn't come. And if they couldn't come and if you had a higher quality employee that you looked after a little bit better than they might have got elsewhere in a similar job, they did a better job and provided a better experience to somebody coming into the store that entitled you to repeat customers coming every day at a high price.

7:08

But if they couldn't come and they were now doing drive thru delivery, take away the nature of the role changed and employees began. What you've now seen actually in the news recently United States in the auto sector which were not in but you saw unionization drive something that Starbucks hadn't experienced before. And first it was one store petitioning to unionize and then six and then 19 and then 200. And all of a sudden, this edge that Starbucks had, they lost the focus a little bit. And Howard Schultz, the founder, long term CEO, actually had a few stints as CEO, came back to try and fix the problem, went to listening to to listen to all the people working for Starbucks. And if we now come back to the dividend trajectory to be able to open a Starbucks every day, you need these high quality employees and you need to look after them. And Howard Schultz decided Howard Schultz has since retired and a new CEO was being appointed. We don't

8:08

know much about this new CEO because he's only been in the seat for a relatively short period of time. So we're still figuring him out. Exactly. But a lot of capital that was earmarked for shareholder returns to continue boosting this dividend forwards and a very material buyback has since been reallocated to trying to improve the employee experience, which long term is probably good, but for the intermediate term simply throws a question mark into some of the dynamics financially of this business. And if we come back to the dividend perspective, for the first ten years of being a dividend payer, Starbucks, which began paying dividends in 2010, grew its dividend in excess of 20% a year.

8:52

And today that isn't true anymore. All right. So we're almost out of time, but then how does that stack up then with the trajectory you're seeing for the dividend profile at at Wingstop? So Wingstop, the exact reverse is taking place. And you have a queue of franchisees desperately trying to lay out more, more capital to open more stores. And Wingstop, having gone through 2000 stores, has changed its advertising instead of being local because there simply weren't enough for national advertising. Now they've reallocated that to advertising on the NFL, the NBA. And what that means is that the efficiency and effectiveness of your advertising improves dramatically. And when you marry that up with a very rapid store, all that which costs you nothing because franchisees are putting up the capital, you see very explosive change in dividend of 15 to 20% per year, plus the occasional special dividend which they've been paying about every two years, which is about five

9:52

years worth of dividends in one go. And we believe that where the dividend growth goes, the share. Price is likely to follow.

10:02

One of these companies is slowing its dividend to about 8% higher and the other one is still accelerating the dividend. For us, it's much more compelling.

More like this

We value your privacy

We use essential cookies to make the site work. Non-essential cookies help us improve the experience. You can accept or reject non-essential cookies. Privacy policy