Why the RBA has changed its tone
About this video
Key highlights:
The RBA might have a difficult balancing act between controlling inflation and sustaining economic growth in the light of record immigration in Australia.
Rabobank views the first rate cut by the RBA only occurring in November.
The rise in gold prices may signal changes in the market's view on inflation and future real interest rates.
Ben Picton from Rabobank talks about the implications of the recent release of the RBA meeting minutes. Ben highlights the shift in tone as the RBA did not consider a rate hike for March, suggesting that there is still strength in the job market despite a drop in unemployment rate from 4.1% to 3.7%. He suggests that while higher interest rates may be welcomed by savers, retirees and young people saving for their first home, others may struggle with the prospect of further rate hikes.
He then discusses the challenge for the RBA in managing inflation alongside the current impact of record immigration. Ben states the immigration boosts demands for goods, services and housing while also increasing the supply of labour. Based on Rabobank's view, the first rate cut by the RBA may not take place until November, suggesting that the RBA may be among the last central banks to cut rates.
Diving into international matters, Ben weighs in on the performance of the US, European economies and geopolitical risks. Emphasising on the strength of the US economy, he questions the need for the Federal Reserve and ECB to further cut rates. He also mentions various indicators affecting inflation and the economy, such as geopolitical threats, a rise in energy prices, and growth in Chinese manufacturing. Ben concludes by discussing the unusual rise in gold prices which are seen as indicative of how the market perceives inflation and real interest rates in the future.
Find the full unedited transcript of this interview below:
0:00
Now. The minutes from last month's RBA meeting have been released, showing the board did not consider the case for a hike in March, marking a significant shift in tone from from the central bank. To discuss the minutes in more detail and the implications of recent US inflation. Ben Picton from Rabobank joins me here in the studio. Ben, great to see you. Thank you for coming in. My pleasure. Well, I, for one, am relieved that they've dropped the rate hike talk. Um, surely the Australian economy couldn't sustain another rate hike. Well, I guess it depends who you ask. And and there's certainly people out there who would love to see higher interest rates. And we think about savers. Retirees. Right. Maybe some young people who are saving for a first home. They might like to see higher rates. But, um, I think it's a change in tone from the RBA. Fair to say, but also worth pointing out that the RBA meeting was held two days before the labor force report, where we saw the unemployment rate dropped from 4.1% to
1:00
3.7%. So the jobs market is still sending a signal of underlying strength. Yeah, it's really, really challenging. Everyone says this cycle isn't different, but it does appear to be a little bit different because we've got other factors that force, don't we? These record immigration levels characterised here in Australia, but it's also the case in the US. I'm led to believe that is creating demand and demand not only for goods and services, but they're also providing labor, but they're also pushing up the cost of housing. So it creates this challenge, does it not for the RBA. How do you get inflation under control without inducing a slowdown? Yeah, it certainly does create a challenge for the central bank. And on the immigration issue, they're not entirely sure where that plays out in terms of does it add more to demand or does it add more to the supply side of the equation? Our general feeling is that in the short run, it adds more to demand. And then over the longer term, there's a
1:59
supply effect that sort of offsets that, or maybe to a greater degree. Now it does provide some difficulties for the RBA when they're trying to get inflation back down and also keep the economy growing. But for the moment, it looks like they still seem to be on that narrow path that Phil Lowe used to talk about. Absolutely. And when is Rabobank looking for the first rate cuts? Where are you sitting in terms of the time frame? Yeah. So we think that the RBA will be one of the last central banks to cut rates. So we have a number of reasons behind that expectation. But our view is that the first rate cut in Australia arrives in November of this year. Can any banks around the world, um, start to cut rates before the fed, do you think? Well, it'll be a foot race between the fed and the ECB? We think so. Both of those central banks are openly talking about the timing of rate cuts. So there's not really any question of further hikes from either of them. Maybe a little bit of a change in tone from the fed just in the
2:59
last day or two. And we have Jerome Powell speaking tonight. So it'll be worth tuning in to see what he has to say. What are you thinking around some of the data that's come out of the US? The JOLTS data looked to be a little bit better than expected. The PMI went into expansionary territory. Obviously we've got more jobs data this week, but there are some experts saying that the US economy looks like it's really accelerating and there's real question marks. Therefore why would the fed cut. Yeah. Well it's a question worth asking. And we've we've had our suspicions for a while that the underlying strength in the economy in the United States is, uh, is a risk for, for cutting rates. So if we're seeing asset prices, very elevated stocks keep making new all time highs. We're seeing gold prices trading at all time highs. We're seeing oil at year to date highs and up quite strongly overnight. And if the economy is still growing and unemployment is still low then where's the argument for
3:59
aggressive rate cuts. It's it is hard to see. So we really need to start to see the data turn a little bit and the US economy start to slow down. Do you think the European economies and are starting to show? I suppose the greater weakness, the greater declines in inflation is that are there economies experiencing that greater fall in inflation? We think so. And and we saw this in the German CPI numbers overnight a little bit softer there in Germany, the UK, the inflation numbers coming out of the UK all of a sudden look quite soft. And we'll get a little bit better of an idea later on this evening when we get CPI figures for the eurozone as well. Yeah. How significant is what seems to be a bubbling up again of geopolitical risks. Um, you know, Israel having identified that they bombed Syria. But that's the expectation with the Iran embassy. I was also listening today about the
4:58
possibility for. Ukraine to push further into Russia to attack some of their oil depots, etc.. Do you think these are some of the reasons that could be pushing oil price higher? And what implications are there then for inflation if we continue to see this rise in energy prices? Yeah, absolutely. It's definitely a big risk, a supply side pressure and something that we've been flagging for many months, basically since the Hamas attacks on Israel in October of last year. So we've always said that the risk is that it spills over and draws in other regional players, and we start to see the energy complex dragged into geopolitics. Just on Ukraine attacking Russian oil refineries. We have been seeing crude oil prices moving up steadily in recent days, but something that doesn't get discussed as much as what's happening with refined products. So things like diesel, which is the world's most important transport fuel, and that has really been taking off
5:58
even relative to crude oil prices. And is that because you are seeing the likes of Ukraine trying to take out Russian refining capacity? Yeah, it's a combination of less refining capacity in the market, but also a more robust growth outlook for places like the United States. Yeah, and it's also interesting, I've picked up as well that, um, Asia Pacific shipping has turned as well. And we did see those slightly better than expected didn't we. Figures manufacturing figures PMIs out of China. Is China now starting to improve almost at the wrong point in the cycle. The economic growth. Yeah it looks like maybe they are. So we are starting to see some stronger stronger prints out of China. We know that there has been some stimulus delivered by the PBoC as well as the central government in China, and maybe that's starting to show up in the figures. Mhm. Last but not least, gold price is it's it's interesting because normally
6:58
a strong US dollar which it has been very very strong. Um and real interest rates. They haven't been falling again. You've had you know bond yields moving up. Is is is the gold price. Do you think signaling something else like safe havens central bank buying maybe geopolitics on the rise again. Yeah I think gold will be the indicator to watch. I think it's fascinating what's happening with the gold price at the moment. Because as you say, we've started to see gold prices going up even when bond yields are rising. And that hasn't been the case for a long time. We saw gold would rise when bond yields fell. But now we're starting to see the opposite happening. And and that does raise some questions about how the market is viewing inflation and real interest rates in the future. Do you think there's a risk that we see a continue to see a sell off in Treasury market, Treasury yields or Treasury markets, I should say, with the bond yields moving up? Uh, well, it's certainly a risk. We wouldn't rule it out. It's not
7:58
our our base case that we'll see secular higher interest rates. We're expecting bond yields to settle down a little bit. Uh but yeah it's definitely a risk.