Why more China stimulus should be expected
About this video
Key points:
Impact of Beijing's stimulus decision on the stock market
US-China trade dynamics and potential for conflict
BRICS role in global trade and the implications for Australia
Tim Davies from Carrara Capital discusses the recent stock rally cool-off in China, attributing it to Beijing's decision to delay further stimulus measures. The National Development and Reform Commission plays a role in executing policy rather than initiating large investments, which influences the market.
Tim observes substantial activity in the Hong Kong market, with hedge funds selling and acquiring Asia holdings. Notably, stocks like Alibaba (HKG: 9988) and JD (HKG: 9618) experience recovery, highlighting volatility in Chinese markets. He also notes increased trading volumes in China and shifts in investment bank views towards China.
The conversation touches on the US-China trade dynamic, with Tim emphasising the potential for BRICS countries to drive trade growth outside the US dollar. He sees opportunities for Australian exports, noting improved relations with China under current government policies, benefiting sectors like iron ore and agriculture.
Full unedited transcript below:
0:00
Let's then return to China. And that stock rally certainly cooled yesterday after Beijing's have held off on further stimulus measures, disappointing the market. Let's get some greater detail. Tim Davis joining us from Carrara Capital. Tim, good to see you. Good morning. Interesting. Those moves yesterday, wasn't it, because there was a lot of speculation about what we're going to hear from the Chinese with the what the chief economic planner. He was going to sort of detail exactly what all this amounts to, maybe announce some further stimulus he failed to deliver and therefore the market dropped significantly. Yeah. I'm glad I wasn't on yesterday morning talking about Chinese stocks for sure. It was a rough day for the managers, but I'm yeah, I think I think it's really important to step back and say, look, yesterday at the end the RC came out and and the NRC's role is to implement policy. So they don't have a budget. They don't get to make. We're going to invest $5 trillion statements, things like that. So they're the they execute based upon what the government had come
1:00
out previously over the last 3 or 4 weeks and spoken about. So the meeting was only announced on Monday morning. So I think a lot of people are sort of pointing towards this meeting and saying that's what's happened in the market, sold off because they didn't come up with a number. I think what really happened is Hong Kong just got over its skis. I mean, we know the Asia market was closed. Um, and Hong Kong kept rallying and rallying and rallying. And the trade yesterday was more, um, investors, hedge funds particularly were selling their Hong Kong holdings and buying that Asia holdings. So, um, there was about a 15 to 20% gap. And a lot of them took advantage of that. So we saw Shanghai up over 5% on the day, but we obviously saw some some pretty heavy selling in in, um, in Hong Kong a lot of stocks were down, you know, double digit. They have recovered pretty well. So in terms of how far they were expected to fall in the address, um, things like Alibaba and JD up about 4% overnight relative to the Hong Kong close. So probably another volatile day.
1:59
But you know, pretty normal stuff for Chinese markets. Well, yeah. The escalator up. Elevator down. But amazing, isn't it? What? What sort of volumes have we seen? It's been extraordinary. I mean, yesterday China traded half 1 trillion USD of volume. Now the Nasdaq market trades 200. On a good day. Um, Hong Kong had a record day of 80 billion USD for trading. And, you know, I think a lot of people you've got to remember someone's buying on the other side of that. So someone's out there hoovering up stock, um, and taking advantage of these big falls. Um, I think as well it's worthwhile just touching on. We've seen some really big shifts in, in views from things like Goldman Sachs and quite a few of these big global investment banks that have been negative on China for quite a few years that have changed their tone. Um, have really got, I think, the skills to analyze what and the context within the Chinese government to really understand what XI and the party is trying to achieve here, which is, you know, you think about that famous Draghi comment back in
2:59
2012 that we're going to do whatever it takes. I think most people who have been in the market for a long time see that moment now in China. So it's really being targeted at the markets. Um, the housing sector. So we would expect a lot more policy to come out over the next 3 or 4 weeks. And then again, the Ndic will come out and announce, this is how we're going to implement those additional policies. All right. So then how do you approach this as an investor? Well, I think it's a good opportunity, right? I mean, I think um, you know, today is probably going to be volatile. Um, often you get a second day of sell offs, um, when you have these sort of, you know, heavy sell days in Asia, particularly in Hong Kong. So, um, carefully today, I would say, um, but, you know, I think if you if you go back to the fundamentals of companies, even though things like JD.com and Alibaba are up quite a lot, they're still trading on single digit pace. They still have 30 to 50% cash on their balance sheets.
3:59
Um, they still are incredibly attractive trading at a 60 to 70% discount plus to the US peers. Um, and yes, you know, while they were up sort of 60 to 80% bounce and they've given, you know, a reasonable amount of that back. I think if you stand back from the fundamentals, things look really attractive actually for for long term investors. And that's why long only money, as we spoke about a couple of weeks ago, the big stimulus that we felt was coming in was the big global long. Only funds were massively underweight relative to benchmark. And a lot of this buying that we've seen over the last 2 to 3 weeks has been the banks indicating it's time to adjust and the funds following through and starting to build up and reduce that underweight
4:48
because we heard from sort of institutions, um, and, you know, individual countries that China is un investable. But that tone now has changed hasn't it. Definitely. Um, now of course this this stimulus targeting domestic consumption. What are what are the export side of the equation though. And I guess particularly as we head into the US election, potentially what we could see in the next administration. And, and, uh, you know, how that affects global trade.
5:17
Yeah. I think this is a really big question for the next five years. I mean, does the US and China realize that mutual destruction isn't good for the world? So if they keep attacking each other, it's going to impact markets. It's going to impact consumer sentiment. And potentially it leads to conflict. And. Well, and and to that point actually, we've just I've not I think, uh, the Chinese have slapped a tariff on um, is it um, is it what was it, brandy or French brandy. Yeah. Yeah, yeah. Which of course they're up in arms about. But of course this is in response to the Europeans putting those pretty much locking out Chinese EVs. Yeah. Look, I think it's interesting, if you look at the vote for most countries abstained from voting in the, um, in the eve decision of the EU. So there are only a handful of countries that said yes. Germany, for instance, said no because it knows it has a very large domestic market share in China, which is the largest car market in the
6:17
world now by a factor of about one and a half times the US. So it's a massive domestic market.
6:24
Um, and they're scared the Germans about losing market share in that market, which is, you know, for some of the brands, it's upwards of 20 or 30% of their volumes. Um, the French, they were they voted affirmative. And as a result of it, the Chinese will will probably start playing games and start putting tariffs on, on on things that matter to French exporters. I think the big picture this month is the new is the BRICs conference that's happening at the end of October. So BRICs is discussions that anything up to another ten members may be admitted. Now these are very large countries like Indonesia, Vietnam, Nigeria, which will get to 800 million people by the end of this century. These are massive population. So um, where I see trade going for China is increasingly within that BRICs group. So we're moving into this multipolar world. Um, I think a lot of people we've spoken about this for a long time, but if you take BRICs from its current size of ten and turn it into
7:23
20, well, these other ten countries, we've probably got close to 70% of the world's population. Um, what does it mean? It means that trade starts to grow non US dollar settlements starts to build amongst those countries. And much like Russia has pivoted its energy exports to other markets, we're likely to see China increasingly pivot, build manufacturing hubs like BYD, for instance, in BRICs countries, and gradually shift its trade away into those large emerging markets. What would the implications for Australia be when you have potentially those those exclusive trading blocs? And of course, China has been looking at Africa, Africa for resources, hasn't it?
8:08
Look, I think Australia is in a great position as long as, you know, I think if you go back to, you know, policy on the Morrison, we sort of like to poke China in the eye every day. Um, it's a bit like poking a bank manager in the day in the eye every day. It's not too smart. So I think under the current government, they've been much more, um, much more focused on the things that matter for Australia. I think, you know, things like iron ore and our agriculture exports, wine and things like that. I think they've played a much better hand with China in terms of, you know, standing up for things that matter to us and probably staying out of the things that matter less. And I think that's improved the relationship with China. So as long as I think we continue along that approach of balance and focusing on what matters for our country, um, rather than simply just sort of following the US, for instance, I think it means Australia is probably really well positioned for exports to Vietnam. Exports to India, some of these other
9:08
growth markets that are joining BRICs.