Sign inJoin free

Watch / Central Banks

Why is volatility so low?

11 July 20247:36

Why is volatility so low?

General information only. ausbiz videos are general information only, produced by Ausbiz TV Pty Ltd, a media business that doesn’t give financial advice. They don’t take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Consider whether it’s right for you and read the PDS and TMD before acting on anything you watch.

About this video

Key points:

  • Market is banking on the Federal Reserve's rate cuts despite rising interest rates

  • Softening job market might lead to bad economic news due to risks to earnings

  • Maintaining protective strategies is crucial amidst underlying economic erosion and artificially low market volatility.

Alastair McLeod, from Wheelhouse Partners, underscores the key role inflation plays in the current economic climate. Alastair emphasises how the anticipated reduction in CPI would allow the Federal Reserve to push through rate cuts, which the market is currently factoring in. He points out that this comes despite interest rates at a rate of five and a half percent in the US. He highlights that the market is substantially higher than two years ago when interest rates were a mere 25 basis points.

Delving into the theme of a softening job market, Alastair shares his insight into the diminishing number of job advertisements among the top 10,000 US corporations. Even though a slow economy might seem positive for a softer CPI print, Alastair warns that this phenomenon could inevitably lead to bad economic news. His prediction of the potential impacts includes risks to earnings, further softening of the job market, and an eventual slowing economy.

Ending his address on market volatility, Alastair voices his concurrence with Karl Rodda on the currently low volatility in the market being a seasonal occurrence. Elaborating on what he refers to as the 'bifurcated market', Alastair explains that a considerable number of stocks are moving consistently upward, offset by a high number of stocks moving in contrasting directions, thereby contributing to a visible stability in overall market volatility. Alastair ends by expressing the importance of maintaining protective strategies, especially when volatility is cheap amidst underlying economic erosion.

Full unedited transcript:

0:00

To get into the broader picture. What is driving market strength? What are the implications for volatility? Why is it so low? Alistair MacLeod, MD of Wheelhouse Partners, joins me now to discuss. Well, let's start with the bigger picture, though, because we've heard from Jay Powell over the last couple of sessions. And we're now awaiting that key inflation print. Just talk us through Alastair why this is so important.

0:22

Yeah. Good morning Juliet. It's um yeah I think the number the CPI tonight is important because the market is clearly more focused on inflation at the moment than it is on, you know, potentially a slowing economy and a softening labor market. So right now, um, you know, bad news is good news. So, you know, a slowing economy is is good for a softening CPI print. And yeah, I think, you know, it's really that focus on, um, potential rate cuts or expected rate cuts and the ability of the fed to be able to deliver them because. I mean, if you think about it two years ago, you know, the S&P 500 is 20% higher than what it was two years ago when interest rates were 25 basis points. You know, today, interest rates are five and a half in the US or the fed. Reserve rates is 5.5% and the market is 20% higher. So I think that's saying that at this point, the market is banking on those rate cuts coming through, and the only way they're going to come through is if

1:21

this inflation beast continues cooling and this trend of softening inflation prints come through. And in that sense, you know, this, you know, milestone or yardstick tonight of what that CPI print is is pretty important. And eventually, as you say, it could really flow through into bad news on the jobs market as well. You've got a chart that you've provided for us on an index of job ads for the top 10,000 US companies. What does this kind of tell us?

1:49

Yeah. Look, I think there's a there's a it's a different metric looking at a softening jobs market in the US. So this is almost it's kind of similar to the ANZ job survey. Um, you know this is advertisements for jobs by the top 10,000 corporates in America. Um, you can see that over the last 12 months that's been progressively softening and softening sort of more aggressively in the last month or so. So, you know, this is definitely suggestive that the labor market is softening, which is what Powell was referring to as well. And this is the point. You know, the market's melting up on rates expectations. You know typically historically that's not uncommon for the market to rally into that first rate cut. And you know whether that's in September or whatever time that is. But it's at that point that the market then decides actually we've got, you know, potential risk to earnings. We've got a softening job market, we've got a slowing economy, um, that starts flowing through into earnings multiples more aggressively. And it's not uncommon to see the market get, you know, start

2:48

getting sold off as the market pivots and starts focusing on bad news is actually bad news on the proviso that, well, inflation seems fine. But, you know, we're kind of at that tipping point now where some of these softening, um, you know, corrosive kind of economic that start to the market pays much more attention to those.

3:08

When we look at overall volatility, and I spoke to Karl Rodda about this earlier as well. Why do you think it's so low at the moment.

3:15

Yeah I listen to the interview with Carl. Look he I agree with him. You know if you if you were a couple of points right now in you know early July seasonally volatility is at its low point. It's you know there's a seasonality to the VIX. And with summer holidays in the US it's just the week after July 4th. Like volatility is historically quite low around this time of the year. Um it does tend to pick up from this point onwards into the end of the year. And it also tends to pick up, particularly in a presidential year as we run into November 2nd, probably maybe this year more than some others. So I think there's a seasonality element. Um, Karl mentioned that, yes, the growth in zero data adoption then. That's right. It's not just zero data adoptions, but there's been massive growth in option selling strategies, which are systematically selling one month options. And that, you know, option pricing is a function of supply and demand when there's massive growth in investors selling options. And given that volatility is such a key input into that price, it can depress, um, volatility at the index

4:15

level. But I think the other consideration what is suppressing volatility I think artificially low at the moment is this bifurcated market that we have at the moment. If you look at um, you know individual stock correlation. So just a you know the VIX is the index volatility. But the VIX sits on top of 500 individual securities in the US and the S&P 500 which are all going up and down. Right. But at the moment you've got this two speed market where a bigger and getting bigger block of stocks is just consistently moving up. And then you've got the other 495 securities which are doing their, you know, life's a lot tougher and they're going up and down doing their thing. So if you actually look at the correlation of those securities within the S&P 500, it's at a 16 year low, which is as long as this series goes back. So it didn't you know an all time low as far as this series is concerned. Um, in terms of so those stocks, some are going up, some are going down, but they're offsetting each other, which means that the index

5:15

level volatility appears very calm on the surface and it looks quite stable. But if you actually look under the hood the individual securities still got the same volatility. They're still moving around just as much. It just happens at the moment because of in part because of this bifurcated market. Almost equal numbers are moving up as a moving down. Now the risk is that when there's a shock, um, and it's more likely that the shock and market goes down, all those securities will start going down together, which means volatility will spike because all the stocks are moving in the same direction. And that's one of the reasons why, you know, you get massive spikes in the VIX is because all of the stocks are moving in the same direction. The whole market moves much more aggressively down than it typically does up. And that's why you get massive spikes in VIX or volatility when when um you know when you get a market shock like this and then crash protection as well Alastair a little bit of a hedge there.

6:13

Yeah. Well you know that's what we do it. You know we kind of specialize in sort of protective strategies like that. And you know, again, if options are cheap because there's a heap of people selling, then it can make sense that, well, maybe it makes sense to be a buyer of those because if volatility is artificially low, if underneath the headline market's going up, there is this erosion in earnings. And this is erosion in the economic growth, then I think having some protection, particularly at the moment when volatility is particularly cheap for those reasons that I mentioned, I think can give you the, you know, the advantage that you can remain invested in equities and whether it's Australian or the US, wherever you can receive the dividends, you can receive the exposure to that asset class. But particularly at this point when the volatility is so cheap and we think artificially cheap to buy some protection. On the downside, to give you some insurance that if if the labor market continues to soften, if a recession comes quicker than expected, if there's more

7:13

uncertainty about the US presidential election as we move into November and potentially the Democratic convention, um, you've got some protection there that, you know, can preserve your capital that's not reliant on styles or sectors. You know, if the market goes down, your protection is there and, you know, you can benefit from that and monetize that and gives you the optionality to do different things with it. If that scenario eventually.

More like this

We value your privacy

We use essential cookies to make the site work. Non-essential cookies help us improve the experience. You can accept or reject non-essential cookies. Privacy policy