Sign inJoin free

Watch / Markets

Why does yield matter?

1 Nov 20237:29

Why does yield matter?

General information only. ausbiz videos are general information only, produced by Ausbiz TV Pty Ltd, a media business that doesn’t give financial advice. They don’t take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Consider whether it’s right for you and read the PDS and TMD before acting on anything you watch.

About this video

Jason Hall from Hamilton12 underscores the significance and profitability of high yield and dividend-bearing stocks for an investor's portfolio. Jason's view points out that the market's fixation on interest rates could divert investors from advantageous potentials such as dividend yields.

He elaborates that these yields offer crucial tax advantages and have consistently yielded return premiums in the past, opposing the idea that all high yield stocks consistently underperform. Highlighting the Australian market, Jason points out it reaps these benefits where dividend yield and tax perks improve the investor's return.

Rather than attempting to forecast interest rate shifts - a challenging endeavor for investors, in his opinion - Jason provides guidance to investors to capitalize on the difference between value stocks (those distributing the majority of their profits as dividends) and growth stocks as a means to boost earnings.

This strategy, according to Jason, is sturdy, offering superior returns than even the best quartile portfolio managers can secure over a prolonged duration.

Find the full unedited transcript of this interview below:

0:00

Well, when it comes to dividends, there are plenty of stocks on the ASX to choose from. But just how important is the role that high yield stocks play in portfolios? Jason Hall from Hamilton12, joins me now for more. I mean, yield matters a lot for a lot of investors. But Jason tell us your take.

0:18

So something that's been fascinating to me in the last couple of years watching equity markets is the parlor game. We're playing with interest rates like we used to as investors monitor like employment figures coming out and gross domestic product, the whole productivity figures, sales figures. But we seem to have developed sort of an almost unhealthy obsession with interest rates at the moment.

0:46

Um, and what caught my attention this week was we had some inflation data came out

0:52

that sort of surprise people on the upside for 5.4% annual inflation. And whenever you've got kind of a upward shift to inflation, um, people start thinking about income and where might they put their money. And I thought it would be good to revisit some work we did on dividend yields that we first put out in July. Um, dividend yields are really important for Australian investors, much more so compared to US investors or investors in Europe or Asia. And that's because of the very substantial tax benefits associated with dividends that come via our franking system.

1:29

And often in the discussion about where to place our money, whether it's in equities or bonds or particular equities within the market, we often ignore just how much advantage there is from high yield investing.

1:44

So we looked at the data for 41 years. We updated this data to the 30th of October 2023. And what it shows is that over 41 years, if you think about inflation adjusted for tax advantaged returns, so including the benefit of franking credits.

2:03

A high yield portfolio has earned about 12% per year, compared to about 9.5% per year in the broader market, which is a 2.5% annual average differential.

2:16

High yield investing doesn't always beat the market. There's a period there in regime five where high yield investing underperformed over a six and a half year period by a 2.3% per year. But in every other regime, you can see there the benefits of a yield premium in terms of higher pre-tax returns, as well as the substantial tax advantages associated with yield in Australia, has generated a return premium in most of those regimes above 3%.

2:48

All right. So above 3%, which is a pretty good rating or I guess I guess index return that you would be hoping for. But as you say, the Australian market currently trading on a 12 month forward dividend yield of 4% and 5.3%, including tax benefits. So how do we get to that kind of level?

3:05

Well. So that's for the broader market. That's and that's a normal dividend. You're in the Australian market the Australian market in aggregate. The stock has traded in a forward dividend yield somewhere around about three and a half to 4.5%

3:20

and inclusive of tax benefits 5.3%. But if you segment that market into, on an industry basis, the top quartile of yield stocks on an after tax basis, you actually get to a 6% pre-tax dividend yield and an 8.1% tax advantaged dividend yield. Um, if you take the bottom quartile of yield stocks. So these are your growth stocks, companies investing most of their earnings back in new projects. They're only trading on a dividend yield on an after tax basis of around about 2%. Um, and in particular the tax advantages of this high yield stocks comprise 1.8% of that returns differential between those growth stocks and those value stocks, the companies paying out the majority of their earnings as dividends. The reason that 2% differential matters is that if you look at active portfolio managers over an extended period of time,

4:20

the best portfolio managers, the top quartile or portfolio managers on approximately a ten year basis

4:28

beat the market by about 2% per year. So if you're out there looking for a portfolio manager that you think is going to earn higher returns for investors, the realistic expectation about how well you can do by doing the due diligence to identify that great manager is about 2% per year.

4:47

The evidence shows that if you compare these value stocks versus growth stocks and take advantage of that tax benefit, you're getting that 1.8% differential.

4:58

Just from a tax break, just because of the mix of companies paying out high dividends for shareholders. Jason, just quickly now, the reason that sorry, just to interrupt, just talk us through some of the difficult tasks. You're talking about picking the direction of interest rates, because I just my earlier guest said there's a 5050 chance in his view is whether or not the RBA moves again and you're looking at those sort of implications as well as as you mentioned there, the tax implications.

5:25

Well, that's that's exactly the point. Your guest said 5050. And in most circumstances, the direction of interest rates is going to be a 5050 bit. And this is where we get to this parlor game of trying to pick the direction of interest rate movements.

5:41

High yield stocks

5:43

are sensitive to interest rate movements. Even in one of the obvious newsletters that came out this week, it mentioned the interest rate sensitive banks, for example. So when inflation came out, there's some talk about higher interest rates for longer. And a couple of banking stocks had an adverse reaction to that.

6:01

But the problem of going down the rabbit hole of trying to pick interest rate movements is that once you start forming portfolios and the basis of where you think interest rates are going to go, you have to do it all the time. You can't care about interest rates on Monday and not care about them on Friday. You have to be continuously trying to guess that direction of interest rate movements. And the reason it's why it's so hard is because you are always trying to guess what you think is going to be the 12 to 24 month impact of today's interest rate changes. The reserve Bank has increased interest rates several times in the past year and then put that on hold and it put them on hold for a very important reason, is that over the next year, there are still hundreds of thousands of homeowners that are going to have their variable interest rates increase as the effect of all of the Reserve Bank's interest rate increases flow through to their home loans. But that's

7:00

not currently showing up in their spending in their consumption data. So the reason for the RBA's pause is his trying to guess what is the next 12 months impact on that inflation data. And that's an extremely challenging thing for the investor to do. And even if you have that skill, you have to be week after week saying, okay, how am I going to shift my portfolio today in response to whatever the latest news headline is about interest rates?

More like this

We value your privacy

We use essential cookies to make the site work. Non-essential cookies help us improve the experience. You can accept or reject non-essential cookies. Privacy policy