Sign inJoin free

Watch / Agriculture

Why cocoa has gone loco

1 Oct 20244:10

Why cocoa has gone loco

General information only. ausbiz videos are general information only, produced by Ausbiz TV Pty Ltd, a media business that doesn’t give financial advice. They don’t take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Consider whether it’s right for you and read the PDS and TMD before acting on anything you watch.

About this video

Paul Joules from Rabobank states that cocoa commodity prices are at their highest in nearly 50 years, putting pressure on chocolate producers worldwide. He notes that these high prices will soon be passed onto consumers, suggesting that chocolate lovers should brace for higher costs.

Paul explains the primary issues are rooted in West Africa, where 70% of the world's cocoa is produced. Factors such as crop issues, farmer exit, and tree diseases in Ivory Coast and Ghana have contributed to the price surge. Hedging practices mean these costs will impact consumers more next year.

Companies are responding with strategies like shrinkflation and ingredient substitution to manage profits. Paul believes that government intervention might be needed to set higher fixed farmgate prices to boost production. However, rising costs could lead to decreased chocolate consumption due to sticker shock

Full unedited transcript below:

0:00

Posted last week after getting word of a Rabobank report on my ex account. As if things couldn't get worse. Cocoa commodity prices have hit their highest levels in nearly 50 years. That is putting strong pressure on chocolate producers around the globe. That makes me think my evening indulgence might be getting more sexy soon. So to tell us all about it, Rabobank s Paul Jules joins me in studio. Hey, Paul. Hey. How's it going? Good. Am I going to have to pay? Well, let's just get right to the. Let's not bury the lead. Am I going to have to start paying more for chocolate? Unfortunately, you probably will. Yes. And we haven't seen the worst of it. So in the report, one of the things we highlighted is that the worst is still yet to come in terms of consumer pricing, and that is our expectation. We've had high commodity prices for quite a while, so at the start of the year they peaked at $12,000 a tonne, which is four times the average. Um, but now we expect to see those prices be passed on more to the consumer. Okay.

0:59

So why? So the reason that we had the production issues in the first place is all to do with West Africa. We have 70% of the world's cocoa production take place in Ivory Coast and Ghana. And there what we've seen is a number of different crop issues. We've seen farmers exit out of cocoa. We've seen farmers not receiving the full commodity price. We've seen a lot of tree disease. But the reason we don't expect to see this really passed on the consumer until next year is to deal with hedging. So these major chocolate companies would hedge eight months in advance, maybe a year and a half in advance. Of course, if you go back a year and a half, commodity prices weren't where they are today. But we do expect now that as these prices get passed on to the these companies, then it will then be passed on to the consumer. Okay. So what is being done to help mitigate, you know, the spike in prices, the shortage of supply that we're seeing. So we are seeing some some kind of a production increase. So within, you know, a few select countries because you can only really produce cocoa in some very specific countries that have a certain proximity to the

1:59

equator. Within those countries, we're seeing a little bit of an increase in production. So of course that's helping. And then in terms of what the chocolate companies are doing, well, what you typically see and consumers don't like this, but what you typically see is shrinkflation, where these companies reduce the size of the chocolate bar or they'll alter the ingredients. For example, they'll use palm oil instead of cocoa as a substitute and try and reduce that cocoa content in order to increase their profits. Yeah, that's bad because we know that palm oil can be very, um, yeah, at very well. The supply chain is not great in the way that it's sourced. I don't mind shrinkflation because it means that I eat a little less potentially. Um, but so the manufacturers have a role to play. The producers have a role to play. Um, you know, is there any, any market sort of forces that would, would have some sort of a role to play in, in, you know, I know that hedging has kept prices down so far, but how does that sort of cycle go? Yeah. So I mean, really what you would expect is that when, you know, these companies become fully exposed and have to put in new hedges, then you

2:59

would expect prices to then go up. But the market fall in terms of you know, we go along the supply chain. I'd say the most important thing is I mentioned that 70% of the production is in West Africa. So in those two producing countries of Ivory Coast and Ghana, they actually have a fixed farmgate price which is set by the government. So that's different to the commodity price that we see in the futures market. So some would argue that that price hasn't been set high enough and potentially it needs some more intervention and that prices should be higher for the producers in order to incentivise more production there. There also is a risk that, you know, prices rise, people eat less chocolate. I mean, it is chocolate consumption at a very basic level, staying, you know, how does that sort of move around? Yeah, it's an interesting one because on the one hand you could argue it's quite a compulsive purchase. Maybe, you know, you're at the supermarket and you're at the checkout and you see a chocolate bar and you're inclined to purchase it, but then is there a point where if that price, for example, doubles, would you then think, well, maybe I shouldn't be purchasing this? So there's a bit of debate about whether, you know, we do actually have a

3:59

response. We do believe there's a bit of a response and there will be some sticker shock. So we do expect to see lower volumes. But of course, as I said, it's still a compulsory purchase, so it will have some resistance to inflation.

More like this

We value your privacy

We use essential cookies to make the site work. Non-essential cookies help us improve the experience. You can accept or reject non-essential cookies. Privacy policy