Why Aussie growth investing might be dead
Why Aussie growth investing might be dead
About this video
Key points:
Proposed capital gains changes seen as heavily disadvantaging growth investment
Tax tilt may push companies to pay dividends rather than reinvest in growth
Higher effective tax on capital gains could favour foreign investors over locals
Suhas Nayak from Allan Gray argues that the proposed capital gains tax changes risk distorting Australia’s investment landscape by favouring income stocks over growth companies. Nayak sets out a scenario where a $10 franked dividend attracts a 24% tax burden for an investor on the top marginal rate, while a $10 real capital gain on the same company could be taxed at 47%. In Nayak’s view, this gap encourages investors, and more importantly boards, to prioritise dividends rather than reinvestment.
Nayak states that such settings act as a “tax on productivity”, as companies may feel compelled to distribute profits instead of funding growth, ultimately constraining long-term economic expansion and undermining Treasury’s projected tax take. He also contends that the changes significantly raise the cost of capital for Australian resident shareholders compared with foreign investors, who can often realise capital gains without Australian capital gains tax, potentially accelerating foreign ownership of key ASX businesses.
Nayak advocates simpler, more neutral tax treatment. He prefers retaining a capital gains tax discount structure while extending the minimum holding period, for example to two years, to lift revenue without disrupting the franking credit regime or discouraging risk-taking and long-term investment. He indicates Allan Gray is watching closely but has not yet altered portfolio strategy.