Which stocks and sectors for September?
Which stocks and sectors for September?
About this video
Key topics:
Market valuation and volatility in Q3 and Q4.
Value and small-cap stocks poised for growth.
Sector-specific insights: utilities, consumer, and technology.
Dave Sekera from Morningstar shares insights on current market trends. He notes the value opportunity in small-cap and mid-cap stocks, seeing potential for sustained growth.
Dave also observes that the market is fairly valued but anticipates volatility in September and October, presenting opportunities for strategic investments. He highlights the importance of earnings guidance amid expected slow economic growth.
In sectors, Dave suggests utilities may be overextended, with alternating stock recommendations to consider. He sees value stocks as undervalued, with potential for performance as rates decline.
Full unedited transcript below:
0:00
Dave Sekera for Morningstar joins me now for more on market. Dave, hi. Welcome back to Oz Biz. Now we have a big risk event happening after market close here in Australia today with that US non-farm payroll report. But generally speaking, um, when you look at the market, when you look at equities for the remainder of the year, is it ripe for broadening out beyond that? I thematic that has been so dominant in FY 24
0:28
away from a lot of those overvalued, overextended IE stocks that we thought had just run up, you know too far and too fast and into a number of different areas within the marketplace. So in our third quarter market outlook titled Market Drivers shifting from thematic to idiosyncratic, you know, we outlined those reasons why we saw better valuations in the value category as opposed to the core and the growth stocks, as well as into, you know, small cap stocks and mid-cap stocks. And really, that's what we've been seeing about, you know, the past six weeks or so. And based on our valuations, we think that still has further room to run. Okay. So how do you see it playing out, particularly when we know that we have the US election looming?
1:11
Yeah. So right now the market overall is pretty fairly valued you know in our mind. So I would actually look to keep a market way position on US stocks at this point. But I do think you know September and October could be pretty choppy. And that actually may give investors opportunities to move into overweight positions. Now historically, September has always been a tough month for the US equity markets. You know, we're certainly seeing that over the past couple of days, you know, starting to play out again. And then of course, you know, in October we really have two events that are coming up. So one, I think a lot of traders in the US would look to exit positions by the end of October. You know, before we get into the risk of the US presidential elections. But of course, we also have third quarter earnings coming out in the middle of October. My concern there isn't so much that I think that they may miss earnings in the third quarter. But really, what could happen is that companies might start reducing their guidance for the fourth quarter or even going into 2025. The reason behind that is our US economics team. We are in the slow growth
2:11
camp. We think that the rate of economic growth is going to slow not only here in the third quarter, but into the fourth quarter and the first quarter of next year. So if management teams are seeing that as well, I think there is a lot of guidance risk that the, you know, they could be bringing their earnings numbers down for the market. And of course, you know the market could sell off on that okay. So earnings risk looking forward. So those guidance statements are going to be ever so important. But when you talk about valuation when you talk about opportunity in the market. So just flesh out a little bit you know the value argument and also how you're feeling about small caps.
2:47
Sure. So from the value perspective you know value stocks you know other than you know just recently have lagged and they've lagged for quite a while. And when we put together our valuations you know in the value category. And we compare that to the overall market valuation. You know we've got a balance here. But when we look at it going all the way back to 2010, you know, value stocks are still relatively undervalued relative to the broad market valuation. And so that's part of the reason they're why we think that still has further to run. And similarly when we look at small cap stocks and look at the valuations that are relative to our broad market valuations, again they've come a little bit off the bottom. But looking all the way back to 2010, you know, they're still very near some of the most undervalued levels relative to the overall market. So it's really the valuations between those two that we expect are correct over time. Why we think both of them have, you know, still further to run. But having said that, more from even like a technical point of view, you know, small caps, you know, historically have performed very
3:47
well when interest rates are declining and the fed is easing monetary policy. And of course, you know, value stocks I do think should outperform as compared to growth stocks as we see the economy slow over the next couple quarters. Okay, so there you go. That's, um, I guess the the factor, the quality. Um, when it comes to specific sectors and stocks, are there some sectors that you have, you know, shifted your view on recently date?
4:14
Well, to the downside, we actually changed our recommendation to an underweight on the utility sector. Now we weren't overweight at the beginning of 2024. But after rising I think over 22% year to date. Utilities as a sector are now trading at about 8% premium. You know, of course, the story there has been that rising electricity demand from AI as compared to traditional computing, you know, it's really going to end up bolstering, you know, demand and earnings for utilities, you know, over the long term. Now we've already actually incorporated that into our earnings estimates. In fact, we are highlighting that, you know, last fall, you know, in our mind if you're buying utilities today just based on that growing demand, you're actually about, you know, ten months probably too late to that trade. So we're looking a lot of different swaps in the utility sector, looking at some of these stocks that have run too far, too fast, you know, two, two star stocks I would highlight that we think are probably pretty good cells right now. Or Southern Company and Dominion Energy and look to swap those into some of the other utilities that remain undervalued. So the two I'm going to highlight there
5:14
are four star rated Evergy. It's actually a recent new pick that our utility team has put out there. So one of the more undervalued stocks in the sector. The other one is going to be four star rated NiSource that trades at about a 5% discount, but still pays over a 3% dividend yield. Okay. Interesting. Great. When do you think or what is your view on consumer related stocks be that discretionary or staples.
5:39
Well it's really going to come down and be very idiosyncratic in the consumer defensive sector. That's actually one of the more overvalued sectors in our view today trades at about a 14% premium. Of course, we've seen a big rotation in the marketplace. People going into more defensive type positions. But, you know, there's still a number of different food stocks there. And there's also a number of different more product oriented companies can view. It's a four star rated stock trades at a 15% discount. You know that's one where we see their turnaround taking hold. We expect to see margins move to the upside. And if you're looking for, you know, some of the highest quality of the high quality companies. You know Clorox company we rate with a wide economic moat, you know, trades at a 9% discount still over a 3% dividend yield. So I'd look really more for those idiosyncratic situations in the consumer space and steer clear of, you know, those type of names where they're really going to be much more levered to not only consumer spending, but more consumer discretionary spending. You know, target would be a stock. It trades at a 15%
6:39
premium to fair value. We think generally the company has a pretty undifferentiated portfolio of products. That would be one that, you know, that type of situation I'd steer clear of for the next couple quarters. Yeah. All right. Thank you. Okay. So you're underweight technology which you have, um, outlined previously. It would be remiss of me not to ask for your view on Nvidia after that massive fall. This week we had Bank of America analyst saying that it could actually be a bit of a buying opportunity. Now, what do you think?
7:08
We think Nvidia's were actually pretty fairly valued, you know, near the current levels today. You know really why did the stock pull back. It's a combination of a couple of different things. You know they beat you know earnings. But they beat earnings by a lot less margin when they beat you know in the past you know the guidance that they provided for this quarter while it was in line with expectations you know prior quarters you know to always been above expectations. So I think from a point of view from the sentiment, you know, it took a lot of wind, you know, out of the sails. So we maintained our $105 share, you know, valuation there. So it's still pretty close to that that three star category meaning that we think it's fairly valued at this point. But again, you know, there's still a lot further run room to run. In the AI space, you know, just generally, one of the things I noted last quarter was, you know, alphabet in its earnings call, you know, kind of made the offhand comment that the risk for AI right now isn't spending too much, but it's actually not spending enough. And even, you know, Microsoft, meta, Amazon, you know, they're
8:08
all pointing to much higher CapEx spending over the next 12 months. Well, there you go. Okay, so, Dave, just a final word to leave investors with as we head further into the month of September. So so just is it proceed with a bit of caution.
8:25
I think so I think things can be pretty choppy here. You know, over the next two months I want to really get past the US elections before I'm going to call it an all clear signal. So I think right now what you need to do is, you know, market weight, the market overall move into those areas, like the small cap stocks that we think are undervalued into the value category, which is also undervalued. And if we do have, you know, some good market pullbacks, I think that'll be a much better time to move into overweight positions.