Which forecasting school is crazy?
About this video
Damien Klassen from Nucleus Wealth shares his viewpoint on the contradiction between analysts' forecasts, business surveys, and the actual state of the economy.
Damien mentions that while some analysts draw attention to historical hard data growth and others hone in on surveys or soft data, the reality and performance of the stock market frequently do not align with these analyses. Unraveling this paradox, Damien points out the regular inconsistency between such predictions and verifiable statistics like employment rates and GDP growth.
Despite the grim outlook posited by some, Damien observes that the real numbers have remained consistently robust. Touching on projections for 2024 market growth, Damien explores certain sectors' likely trajectories. As for the tech sector, particularly the 'big six', Damien voices his reservations over their continued profitability due to high expenses, engineered growth, and fluctuating accounting assumptions.
Yet, he openly recognizes their commendable performance in recent times. In summary, Damien posits that investors' tendency to selectively use data that reinforces their market stance, results in a chasm in market perceptions.
Find the full unedited transcript of this interview below:
0:00
My next guest thinks there's a paradox in analysts forecasts and business surveys. Although bulls point to historical growth from hard data and bears point to surveys and expectations, measures or soft data, stock market earnings show the opposite is true. Damien Klassen from Nucleus Wealth joins me now to discuss where reality differs from what markets are pricing in. Good to see you. Damien, what are you seeing? Yeah. So I mean, as you mentioned in that in your intro, they yeah, there's this real paradox where we've got we look through it sort of macroeconomic indicators and traditionally like there's a, there's a whole range of different things you look at and everything from soft indicators. So the forward surveys and forecasts and business confidence and all those types of things and pretty much, um, it's very hard to find any of those that look positive. There's a lot of them that look downright recessionary, but the actual data coming through, you know, employment, uh, and, and things like that and GDP growth is not too bad.
0:59
You'd probably put in the camp. And so, so you've got this part where the future has been looking quite bad for some time, but the, the actual numbers have been coming through. All right. And stock markets exactly the opposite, where, you know, the last two quarters have been sort of -5% growth sort of in terms of earnings. But we're looking at growth forecasts for Q3 of um, of basically flat and then sort of five, 5 to 10% growth depending upon which markets you're looking at, 5% sort of globally and and closer to ten in the US for Q4 And then and then down Right. Great growth for for for 2024. Now now the first thing you sort of go, well, how much of that is just the tech and admittedly like if you take the big six which the chart you've got up on your screen now. So basically in for Q4, if you just had the just that big six, they were they're sort of adding almost 4% growth to Q3 numbers, but then all the other stocks remove that. So so yeah, they add for everyone else takes it all
1:59
away. You end up back flat for Q3. For Q4, they add almost 6% and every other stock basically does nothing. And so you end up with that. Yeah, almost 6% growth. And then but for 2024, it's some pretty broad based optimism right across the markets. It's not all coming from those big six, most of it's coming from from other stocks. And that's where there's this real difference of opinion where, you know, the macroeconomic data is saying higher interest rates mean slower economies, mean profits are low. And
2:30
whereas whereas stock market earnings are or the forecast that are factored in at the moment are saying the opposite. Yeah, I mean you're talking about your pace to which forecasting school is crazy because both can't be right. It's kind of like listening to those studies that say red wine is good for you versus the ones that say it's not. But how are you looking at, I guess, the alternate explanation here? You pick whether you like red wine or not, I think. And that's what that's what people are doing is that, you know, if you like red wine, you say, I'll believe the studies that say it's that say it's good for me. And if I don't if I don't, then I'll say I'll take the studies to say it's bad. And I think that's what's happening with a lot of the the stock market numbers. If you're a stock market bull, then absolutely you'll you look at the analyst forecast and say, yep, great, everything's fine. Um, and if you're a bear, you'll take the macroeconomic forecast and say and so that's why we have these competing schools. Look, traditionally what happens is that the macroeconomic ones tend to win out. I think for me, what what you traditionally what you usually see in analyst forecasts, particularly for when things
3:30
get uncertain, is they sort of revert to 10%. Um, and then what happens is they'll either rise or fall over the over the coming year, back to back to the level. So if you look at a time series of analyst forecasts over the last sort of 20 odd years, almost every single year starts at 10% and then either ends up at 20 or down at zero, you know, depending upon what whether it's a good year or bad year. And,
3:54
you know, for my part,
3:56
the fact that we've had two very weak quarters, we're still got you know, we haven't seen any any response on the on the interest rate front. We are seeing things slowing. We're seeing higher energy prices. That's also going to slow consumption. It seems difficult to me to come up with a reason why stocks will suddenly rebound and earnings into 2024. Let's talk a little bit more about some of those tech players. You were looking at some of the big six. Where do you see potential, I guess, movement from those? And I notice well that Amazon got hit hard in the US session overnight on that FTC ruling. Yeah, absolutely. Look, I mean, the issue with those stocks is the earnings have been very good, um, for a lot of those stocks. Some of that has been a little bit of accounting changes. So particularly in um, we've seen some of the cloud guys change the number of years that their servers will last. And so while that's, that's notionally, I mean it is an unambiguously good thing that that yes, we thought they were going to last 3 or 4 years and actually now we're finding out
4:56
they last 5 or 6 years before we need to retire them. So that's great. And. And it does mean higher earnings. But there is some
5:03
that means some of the depreciation charges and some of the earnings growth we're seeing is is not really sort of organic growth. It's more a change in assumptions for your accounting. And so so yeah, so potentially earnings aren't quite as good as what as as what you might think, just looking at the rural growth rates. Um, the other problem with those stocks obviously is is is very expensive. Now if you go back to the the side so so I think probably two months ago think we came on here to talk a lot about that earnings and and those types of markets. I mean if you look at the the total spend of all on all data centers and assume that it sort of doubled and tripled over the next sort of five years or think I've got it tripling over the next five years and Nvidia took a 90% market share of of all of the uh,
5:56
of, of all that the chips that sort of related to, to the I stuff then you could justify the Nvidia valuation. So there's some, some pretty good growth sort of already factored into the Nvidia share price. Um, and so I do think there's a, there's a, there is an element of saying um, I've trying to work out how many companies are genuinely going to be spending $100 million plus a year redoing the calculations for their AI and how many are actually going to rely on, you know, a Google or a or an OpenAI and then just tweak. And so, yeah, people are spending a lot on on AI, but but nowhere near as much as what factored into some of these or particularly some of the the Nvidia or some of the, the top stocks. Um yeah. So, so I guess, I guess for me it's yes, like the, I like the fundamentals. Um, it's now question about how expensive so we hold a lot of these, a lot of them in our portfolios but we've been you know lightning rather than rather than adding to positions.