What's the next move for central banks?
What's the next move for central banks?
About this video
Key points:
Anticipated dovish pivot of the Reserve Bank of New Zealand (RBNZ)
Potential rate hike by the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) due to persistent inflationary pressures
Potential Federal Reserve rate cuts amidst signs of a US economic slowdown.
Ben Picton from RaboBank indicates that many are anticipating a dovish pivot from the Reserve Bank of New Zealand (RBNZ), in light of softening economic data since their May meeting. According to Ben, the upcoming meeting could result in an unexpected turn of events or simply affirm predictions. Insinuating a deviation from historical trends, Ben suggests RBNZ might trail behind other central banks in terms of rate cuts this time, in comparison to its usual bellwether stance in the global economy.
In the local context, Ben highlights the key differences between the Reserve Bank of Australia's (RBA) dual mandate and the RBNZ's primary focus on price stability. He notes that RBA's mandate, coupled with persistent inflationary pressures, could lead to a rate hike in August, a view he asserts RaboBank was among the earliest to espouse. Ben mentions that strong credit growth and indications of non-stringent financial conditions may also play a part in instigating a tighter policy.
Focusing on the broader context, Ben reflects on the prospects of the Federal Reserve cutting rates due to the anticipated slowdown of the US economy in the final quarter of the year. He points out telltale signs such as paradoxical non-farm payroll figures, intermittent initial claims numbers, and gradually easing hourly wages as potential indicators of an impending slowdown.
Full unedited transcript:
0:00
So what can be read in the RBNZ decision for Australia? Joining me now is Rob Banks Ben Picton. But first off Ben, before we get to what it means for us. Do you think it's going to be a nothing burger or something very very exciting at 12?
0:13
Yeah, that's a really good question. And I guess that is the $64,000 question. We've been expecting a dovish pivot from the RBNZ for some time. And I think like many market analysts, we thought that that would come in May. And we were as surprised as anyone that they really went the other direction and maybe amped up the hawkish rhetoric a little bit and, uh, indicated that cuts would come later than what most people were expecting. So, uh, given the run of economic data, and it has certainly softened since that May meeting, uh, we're still expecting a dovish pivot to come. Um, but yeah, this one is a really binary meeting. It's either going to be absolutely nothing or it's going to be the pivot that we've all been waiting for. And I guess then more broadly, what does it mean for the RBA, which as we were discussing with Carl, very much lagged in terms of the interest rate hiking cycle, whereas the BNZ, you could say kind of went out in front.
1:06
Yeah. The RBNZ tends to be a little bit of a bellwether in the global economy. They tend to sort of move first among the central banks. But this this time around things seem to be a little bit different. We think that they're going to be in the back of the pack, uh, to some degree. In terms of cuts, we've already seen those cuts in, uh, in Canada and the EU, and we're expecting fed cuts, uh, later in the year. Uh, we did have a fairly aggressive, uh, forecast on rate cuts for the RBNZ. And, uh, and it remains our forecast that they'll be cutting as early as August. But, uh, it really depends on what they say today. Uh, that may have to be revised after after we get some comments from them. In terms of the RBA. I think, uh, Kyle, your previous guest was quite right that there's a big distinction between the two and that's that the RBA has the dual mandate. They have to look at the labor market and what's happening with employment. And the RBNZ has the luxury of just focusing on price stability and making sure that they get inflation under control. Yeah, I think it's going to be very, very interesting. The August meeting, given that
2:06
they're not meeting in July, will be very live, no doubt. You have always been all Rabobank, I guess one of the few that was saying, look, we're not going to see cuts this year. What sort of the outlook of the likelihood of a hike in August?
2:21
Yeah. So if we look at financial markets, they put it around about 1 in 4 chance of a hike in August. We were one of the earlier banks to to come out and say that we do think that they will hike in August. So we changed our view back on the 1st of May. Uh, we said that we think an August rate hike from the RBA and then a follow up hike in in November, and that lines up with the statement of monetary policy that the RBA is expected to release. The reasons the reasoning behind that is because we've seen inflationary pressures in Australia have been persistent. Uh, particularly we've seen trimmed mean inflation rising for four months in a row. We've seen the headline inflation number in the in the monthly series. At least surprising two ticks to the upside for the last two months in a row. And even the quarterly data in the first quarter of this year was was stronger than expected. And and if you look below that as well, there's there's other indications that maybe financial conditions are not especially tight. We're seeing very strong credit growth figures. Credit growth never returned to the
3:21
levels that we saw pre-pandemic back in 2019. So it doesn't look to us like this as a market that's that's really struggling to to extend new credit. And and that sort of indicates to us that policy might may have to go tighter. What do you think, though, in terms of how it could affect the everyday person with a mortgage, given what we've seen in these consumer sentiment readings?
3:44
Yeah, the sentiment ratings are certainly very weak at recessionary levels. They have been sort of gradually grinding higher since early 2023. So, uh, although they're still very, very low and, uh, and much lower than where they've been over recent years. Uh, the trend is broadly upwards. And we do have those tax cuts now and those, those subsidies coming through. And, uh, if we're expecting economic growth to pick up in the second half of the year, and we are and the analysts are, then maybe we will start to see some of those sentiment numbers start to improve in the months ahead. All right. Let's talk. Ben. Excuse me. There's a fly coming into my face in terms of what we saw from the fed overnight. And I guess the sense that Jay Powell is indicating they're starting to get a sign of inflation. Do you think it's likely that, as the money market suggests, there will be 50 basis points of cuts this year?
4:37
We think so. We've held a we've held a forecast for many months now that we expect a fed cut in September and then a follow up cut in December. So we think we get 50 basis points worth of cuts. Um our view has been that the US economy will start to slow down quite substantially into the into the final quarter of the year. And we think we're starting to see that in some of the data now. So I think the the underlying weakness in the non-farm payrolls has been reasonably well covered. We're seeing a big disparity between the establishment survey and the household survey in the in the non-farm payrolls figures, uh, almost every month we're seeing big downward revisions to previous month's payrolls. And when we look at where the job creation is actually happening, similar to Australia, it all seems to be in the government sector. So health care, social assistance, uh, public administration, those, those sorts of jobs, whereas the private sector seems to really sort of be struggling to generate new employment. So if we look at that and we look at other things like the, uh, the initial claims
5:36
numbers, which are a little bit more patchy, but starting to show softness. If we look at things like, uh, hourly wages, they're starting to pull back a little bit. Uh, then we think that, uh, the US economy is headed for a slowdown towards the back end of the year.