Wealthy & Wise | When pay drives performance (or not)
Wealthy & Wise | When pay drives performance (or not)
About this video
This week's Wealthy & Wise looks at executive remuneration and how value investors should judge incentives.
Executive pay structures may influence management behaviour, risk and ultimately shareholder returns.
We are joined by Howard Coleman and Sanjee Narendran from TeamInvest, and Rachel Waterhouse from the Australian Shareholders' Association.
Howard Coleman argues that once a company’s fundamentals stack up, the remuneration report becomes critical, as it can indicate what management is actually striving to achieve over time. Coleman regards clarity, alignment and quantum as the three pillars of a sound incentive structure and views excessive complexity and jargon as potential red flags for investors.
Coleman and Narendran maintain that poorly designed incentives, such as bonuses tied to total profit, total shareholder return against peers or opaque culture measures, may lead to value-destructive acquisitions or excessive focus on share price.
They prefer straightforward, auditable metrics like earnings per share or return on invested capital, tailored to the company’s capital intensity and business model.
The Australian Shareholders Association’s position is that retail investors should weigh both short-term and long-term incentives, ensuring they are realistic, measurable and encourage long-term thinking rather than short-term gains. Waterhouse highlights the importance of including non-financial metrics such as culture and reputation, citing Qantas (ASX:QAN) and Commonwealth Bank of Australia (ASX:CBA) as examples where reputational issues shape incentive redesign.