Valuing, monetising and investing in nature
Valuing, monetising and investing in nature
About this video
Martijn Wilder, CEO and Founder of Pollination Group discusses the domestic and global trends in valuing nature and ascribing a value to biodiversity and nature for business and investors.
Increasingly investors and businesses are seeking to not only assess the risks posed to their businesses but also the investment opportunities.
As the climate challenges increase, businesses and investors are assessing the importance of nature as part of the full equation of achieving better outcomes.
Valuing nature is not easy as much of the value is hard to ascribe when historical business models generate higher returns in the short term. The inclusion of carbon credits or sequestration is one means of generating positive outcomes as are other technologies which provide better end results.
Find the full unedited transcript of this interview below:
And turning our focus onto the private sector's relationship with nature and the role that nature plays in capital markets has come into focus with a recent report called Nature Finance Focus from the Pollination Group. Joining us now live in the studio to explain and discuss the report is Martijn Wilder, founder and CEO of Pollination Group. Welcome, Martijn. Thank you for coming in. Thanks for having me. So can you explain pollination group? What are what is the group? What are you trying to achieve? So pollination was about four years ago. It's a climate and nature investment and advisory firm. The purpose for setting up the firm was really that people were increasingly concerned about climate and nature and the risk that those things presented, but also the investment opportunities. And so for pollination, really the intent was how we bring together a team of people that could guide the capital markets into towards investing these opportunities, but also to understanding the way
0:59
in which climate and nature would affect business going forward. Absolutely, because business and nature have been inextricably linked. But of course, it's not just about, I suppose, business ignoring it now. It's how business, I suppose, can invest in it, how capital markets can invest in it. So what sort of things trends are you starting to see in this space? I think one of the challenges with nature, unlike climate today, is that as a general rule, people just see nature as a public good. So it's out there. You know, your business does rely on nature more than people realise, particularly if you're relying on water supply chains, if you're in the agricultural space. Nature natural capital is critical. If you have infrastructure and there are climate events like storms and hurricanes and other things that actually affect and destroy or destroy infrastructure, that is a major problem on your investment. So one of the things that we have tried to do and are trying to do
1:59
is to really put a value on nature that goes beyond this sort of intrinsic concept, but has a real economic value. And so in order to do that, pollination has been advising clients on what and how nature has a direct correlation with their business, how significant impacts on nature can affect their supply chains in their business, and also creating investment products, which we can come back to about how you can invest in nature. So on one side of the ledger, so to speak, you've got risks. So it's a risk factor. On the other side, it's trying to translate it into investment opportunities. So how does one actually value nature? So the challenge with nature is that we all know it has a value. We all live in it every day. We breathe the air, we drink, the water. We know that it's absolutely fundamental. But in a traditional economic sense, people have not really put an economic value on that per se. I mean, academics have done that, others have done that. But businesses tend to just either pay for water,
2:59
but they don't actually, as a general rule, you know, you get a license to pollute, but you don't really build into that the broader damage that that has. So there's an increasing attempt to really put a value on nature and to do that through a tool such as things called accounting for nature, which is really trying to put a more definitive value on nature. It's very difficult though, if you are talking about biodiversity and you're down to the, you know, the last 20 koalas in Australia, what value do you put on those koalas versus a property development? I mean, those are the things that we're grappling with, but we know intrinsically that there is a massive loss of biodiversity, a massive loss of of tree and land cover in Australia and we have to reverse those trends. And so we have to find ways to really put a value on that nature that goes beyond just the, I guess, the intrinsic value that we've been used to. Okay. So in this report, you've been looking at how investors are looking at this space. Maybe you could run us through. Are there any differences between how Australian
3:59
investors are looking at it versus, let's say, European or us, and maybe if there's an appetite globally in this space? So I think what I would say is that
4:11
over the last few years, many of the big financial institutions have called increasingly for the need to invest in nature. They've said we need trillions and trillions of dollars to invest in nature, to reverse species loss, biodiversity loss, protect water systems. Those calls have just simply been increasing. And there's now obviously a global commitment to make sure that we that we protect nature and that we have these very large areas protected by 2030. One of the challenges is that if I'm a traditional economic investor, I look at nature and say, well, what's my economic return? And I don't look at it in a context of what is my what is society's return? And if I'm managing money for someone's superannuation, of course I need a return on that money and therefore I'm looking directly at investing in nature.
4:56
So I'm looking at directly getting a return from that investment in. So one of the things I think that's going on globally and we're seeing a huge amount of momentum at the moment is a real interest in how do we invest in nature and how do we not only get an economic return, but how do we incorporate that that nature risk and that nature return into every business decision that is made. So if I give you to answer your specific question. Australia is pushing ahead with this. The government has a piece of legislation called the Nature Repair Bill. In Europe we have a very big focus on nature and a number of large corporates announcing new funds to invest in nature all the time. But again, they struggle with how do you get that return? So pollination, when we first approached this topic, we the first fund that we set up was a fund called Climate Asset Management, which is a joint venture with HSBC that is a natural capital investor. And the idea was that over ten years, by the time ten years were passed, we would hopefully be able to invest in biodiversity and wildlife and give investors a
5:56
return in the short term because that was not possible. Our investment class in the first fund is really investing in in regenerative agriculture, forestry that's done in a more sustainable way, sustainable fisheries. So investing in those asset classes and those industries that have a direct impact on nature, but minimising that impact and then saying to investors will get your return from doing agriculture in a way that is much better and has much less impact on nature and in fact will increase biodiversity and will increase nature outcomes. So in that sense, we've started with with an investment thesis to invest in things that are critically interacting with nature. And over time, as those properties we invest in, for example, those agricultural outcomes will have an increasing positive impact on biodiversity. We'll look to how to monetize that part of the investment as well. And over time we'll do that. At the moment we've also launched a venture capital fund and that fund is looking at investing in nature technologies and technologies that help you
6:56
better manage and better restore and better look after nature, but also use nature itself to get better outcomes. So whether that's investing in in the growing of seaweed that reduces emissions, Is that also. Yes, Yes. I've been trying to get him on the program, actually. He's so busy, though, he's conked out after Europe. That's right. Maybe just it's a very interesting product, what he's trying to put in place. Yeah. So so things like what Sam is doing, which is investing in in existing nature to get a better climate outcome or investing in in satellite imaging, that can give you a very good overview of what's going on on the ground in terms of landscapes, understanding the carbon and biodiversity loss, all that data. There are many things that are happening in the nature tech space that will help us protect and preserve nature but have a wider application as we go forward. So the thesis that we have is creating an investment product for investors in which they can invest in nature and get an economic return, which to date has been quite difficult to do. Absolutely.
7:56
One thing that has always sprung to mind, and this could be far too simplistic, but it's interesting the way that we adopt nature as tourism, like there is quite a big value ascribed to going to see the gorillas, you know, in I've forgotten the mountain range, but you know exactly where I'm talking about.
8:17
And is this potentially something that could work on a large scale because you by attaching an industry tourism that is overarching over biodiversity, be it the rainforest, you know, with the orangutans, with the Sumatran tigers, none left. But anyway, you know, what I'm saying is, is that is that an example of how nature is given a value of some sort? That is one example. But the challenge there would be if I have an area of traditional rainforest, Indonesia, for example, with orangutans, the the the economic argument is, do I get a bit of value for that or do I get a better value from chopping down the rainforest and producing timber? And unfortunately, to date, the more destructive economic outcomes have always overridden, the less destructive and the nature preservation outcomes. So in many ways, we're trying to readdress that balance and make sure that, you know, when if you realize that saving orangutans in
9:17
the wild is absolutely critical, how do you put a value around that and find alternatives to chopping the rainforest down so i.e., having more sustainable forestry and other activities? The Great Barrier Reef is another example of that, where Great Barrier Reef is critical for tourism. Huge amount of operators operate there, yet we're struggling with runoff from farming activities onto the reef, other activities that are happening there, damaging the reef as well as natural activities like like like bleaching. But again, you know, the Great Barrier Reef is our biggest economic tourism asset. And if you put if you understand the value of that to the Australian economy, it would hopefully make you think differently about the way in which we damage that reef. What role can. Carbon pricing and carbon offsets have in protecting biodiversity. So in many of the current activities that people do, such as planting trees or stopping trees being chopped down or restoring landscapes, the only revenue source actually
10:17
is carbon. So it is true, there's been a lot of a lot of debate about carbon markets and about the use of carbon offsets. But at the end of the day, excuse me, until we actually find an alternative revenue source to those projects, the only way to fund them is carbon. So I don't think there's anybody who would be adverse to large corporate saying that biodiversity project over there has a huge biodiversity outcome. We're going to work out how to measure it and we're going to fund those outcomes as opposed to buying the carbon, even though it has a carbon outcome that is embedded in that we need to. And what the Federal Government's nature repair bill tries to do is to actually find a way to value nature so that investors can invest in nature. It's still a little way to go with that legislation, but it's setting the clear foundations for that journey, which is very important. It really challenges the whole paradigm of investing that we're currently sitting in, which is very short term based. And that's that's the great irony, isn't it,
11:17
Because superannuation funds have to invest for a very long time frame and yet they're often judged on a very short time frame. It seems to me it's a similar corollary with nature we need. It's a very long term valuation that is trying to be pulled forward into the here and now. Yeah, that's right. And one of the things that the report tries to to tease out is to say we've spent a lot of time talking about climate risk. We're now spending a lot of time talking about nature risk. And with the Efdd, which is a task force on Nature financial disclosure, there is a lot of focus on nature risk. But we're also in this report trying to say to investors, you need to really understand that nature is actually an intrinsic economic part of the return that you will get on your investments. Because if you invest in a company that has a big nature exposure or is doing, you could ultimately lose your money. On the other hand, if you invest in a company that's doing positive things for nature and is being
12:16
nature positive, it's more likely to be economically sound long term, but better prepared for when things change, but are prepared for dealing with supply chain interruptions that link back to nature. And so we're trying to make in this report tease out the fact that it's very important that both investors and companies understand that being nature positive and doing good things for nature will ultimately enhance shareholder value. It's obviously come a long way in the last ten years. I mean, people were vaguely talking about it ten years ago, but here you have pollination group, you've set it up, you've got a venture capital fund, you've got another joint fund with HSBC. What sort of pathways do you envisage going forward, Martin, to really accelerate this to where it needs to go? Yeah. Look, I think there's a push and a pull factor here. So unfortunately, on the push side, as we see things happen, such as the loss of biodiversity, the loss of of things like what we saw in California with, with
13:15
pollination of of of a lot of the the the orange vineyards. ET cetera. Being lost. Things like water shortages, as we saw in South Africa. Those will push people to understand there is a real risk to their business. On the pool side, I think it's about how do we get the tools that are right to value nature? How do we incorporate the way in which we account for that value within economic decision making? And how do we make sure that we have tools that are better equipped, that when we are running a business and it does have an impact on nature that we know, we know how to measure that? Another really important point also is that you will have seen maybe in California last week, the Californian government is now suing the oil and gas companies for their contribution towards climate. You will start to see litigation around nature as well. And so if I'm a company that has a license to pollute and I pay a small fee to pollute and with an EPA license and that's that's acceptable today, that will not be acceptable in the future. The damage that's being
14:15
done to a lot of the environment, I think is is starting to really be recognized as as far more than just then. I think we're always sort of out of sight, out of mind. I think now it's really in sight and in mind. And last question, because obviously you come from a legal background. You know you're a lawyer, so who better place to comment on this form of litigation? Now, there have been examples where it's been successful around the globe and then other places where it has failed. Is this a trend, do you think, that we're increasingly going to see? Yes. So we have seen over the last ten years a significant increase in directors being and companies being sued for their failure to take into account. Climate risk, climate consequences at the international level. There's been agreement now to have compensation funds set up in the same way they did for tobacco. This is a trend that's going on. And while the I guess 1st May say early on, those
15:15
undertaking litigation were were basically non-government organizations or or those sorts of groups, when in fact you have the government of California running litigation, that's huge is another shift. Yeah. So that's a government against its own corporates taking action against the damage that's had on its own state on behalf of the people of California. And you'll see similar trends happen in nature going forward.