US mid-term lessons for Australia
About this video
Key points:
Andrew Thomas and Grant Lovett describe the Democrats' gains as extraordinary, comparing the scale of the result with the post-Watergate election of 1974. They say the outcome was primarily a rejection of Donald Trump.
They caution against interpreting the result as a broad endorsement of the Democratic agenda, arguing voters had limited alternatives in a binary political contest.
The result reinforces how inflation, interest rates and housing affordability are weighing on incumbent governments globally.
Magenta Advisory's Andrew Thomas and Grant Lovett say the US midterm result is a significant rejection of Donald Trump, with the scale of the Democrats' gains comparable to the political shift following Watergate in 1974. They warn Democrats against interpreting the result as a broad endorsement of their policies, arguing voters were largely expressing opposition to Trump in a political system where the choice is effectively between two parties. They also point to the Democrats' success in selecting candidates suited to their local electorates as an important factor.
The pair say the election reinforces the political risks facing incumbent governments as cost-of-living pressures, inflation, interest rates and housing affordability weigh on voters around the world. In Australia, they believe the Albanese government may need to recalibrate its budget strategy, although they argue it has already taken difficult decisions on tax concessions and restraining NDIS expenditure. They say the government's political position could improve if interest rates stabilise and household finances begin to recover ahead of the next federal election.
Attention also turns to New Zealand, where the centre-right government faces a challenging re-election campaign amid a soft economy. Thomas and Lovett say the contest remains tight, with a centrist party potentially holding the balance of power in coalition negotiations. They argue that, in Australia and overseas, voters ultimately judge governments on their economic circumstances but also on whether they believe the next government can improve their financial position.