Sign inJoin free

Watch / Investing

Unravelling the success of factor investing

12 June 20248:06

Unravelling the success of factor investing

General information only. ausbiz videos are general information only, produced by Ausbiz TV Pty Ltd, a media business that doesn’t give financial advice. They don’t take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Consider whether it’s right for you and read the PDS and TMD before acting on anything you watch.

About this video

Jason Hall from Hamilton12 provides detailed views on factor investing, highlighting its potential for high return exposure. Emphasizing the complexity of this investment strategy, Jason explains two primary ways of portfolio formation. The first method involves cherry-picking of individual stocks perceived to be good value, while the second method relies on maintaining a large, diverse portfolio offering exposure to one or more factors. Jason cites examples of the types of companies that have shown tendencies to yield higher returns on average, including companies with low asset growth, high-quality earnings, and high dividend yields.

Jason later raises the topic of industry-specific confines in factor investing. He mentions an ongoing debate surrounding its effectiveness, with one group advocating for the deliberate exposure to entire undervalued or overvalued industries. Jason uses historical events like the 20-year-old tech bubble and the property bubble of 2006-2008 to exemplify this viewpoint. However, he also presents an alternative perspective suggesting the identification of stocks within specific industries, which he calls 'industry neutral investing'. This method ranks stocks within industries like banking, mining, and technology based on a specific factor.

Towards the end of the discussion, Jason suggests that dividend yield is a crucial stock characteristic for Australian investors to consider, owing to the country's unique taxation system. He explains that by ranking all stocks within a market based on dividend yield and undertaking long positions in high dividend-paying stocks, investors could potentially gain beneficial returns. Despite this, he cautions that this method may not always guarantee success. Jason concludes by indicating a preference for an industry neutral position in factor investing due to its potential to provide consistent return premiums.

Unedited transcript below

0:00

Factor investing. So it's a strategy to gain exposure to a factor. So think quality momentum value and you all you do it so that you can ensure high returns. But nothing is that simple. So to walk us through it in a little more detail and with a little bit more nuance, I think Jason Hall from Hamilton, 24, joins me now. Hi, welcome. Great to have you back on Ozzfest. So yeah, give me your summary of factor investing.

0:27

Okay. So at the outset you gave a good description there of what factor investing is. There's two ways to form a portfolio. One is you try to pick individual stocks that you think are good value. The other is to hold a very large, diversified portfolio that gives you exposure to one or more factors and try to minimize exposure to anything that you don't think is going to generate high returns. So, for example, a historically, um, there's been a few stock characteristics that research has shown on average generate higher returns. Companies with, uh, low asset growth, companies that have, um, high quality earnings, which means they have few earnings surprises, um, and companies that pay high dividend yields. Companies with um, high book value relative to market value, for example.

1:16

Okay, so you determine what type of factor you are looking for. Does that necessarily mean that you stay within certain confines, like whether it be industry, so you're looking in tech or whether it be, you know, small versus large caps, like how do you sort of, um, where's the nuance in it?

1:37

Okay. So. Well, this is where there's a big debate about what the evidence shows. So there's one camp of academics and investors that say, well, the reason some of these factors generate higher returns is that they give you exposure to a whole industries which are necessarily undervalued or overvalued at any point in time. So, for example, if you think way back 20 years to the tech bubble, tech stocks were trading on really high prices compared to the book value of their assets. They had very few assets and we saw entire industry which was overvalued at the time. If you think to the property bubble of 2006 to 2008, we saw an entire asset class, which was, um, which was over value. So there's one cohort of people that say you should rank stocks by the factor or the stock characteristic, maybe buy stocks that have low prices relative to earnings or cash flow. Maybe you rank stocks according to dividend yield. Maybe you rank stocks according to asset growth and you ignore industry and the the supporting

2:37

evidence for that is about six decades of research from the US that says on average, over that 60 year period, investors would have been better off by just ranking stocks according to some value based characteristics and forming portfolios on that basis.

2:55

Um. An alternative, though, is to think, to identify stocks that rank well on your particular stock characteristics, but within each particular industry. And this is what we call industry neutral investing. That means you take banks and you rank stocks by the factor within banks. You take mining companies and you rank stocks within mining companies by the factor. You take tech stocks and rank tech stocks according to the particular factor.

3:22

Um, the reason the first approach is very risky, despite it showing that on average it generates high returns relative to risk for investors, is that you're really making a bet that an entire industry is going to be overvalued or undervalued, um, at any point in time. And to be quite specific, it means that on most of these factors, they encourage investors to be value based investors. You heard in the previous segment, um, a comment about Select Harvest or I think no ACL offering a 6% fully franked dividend yield. And that would rank very highly both within its healthcare sector and across the broader market. But if you rank stocks according to any value based characteristic, you are necessarily going to be short healthcare and or underweight healthcare and technology stocks for an extended period of time, and you're necessarily going to be overweight. Utilities and financial services, these value based industries for an extended period of time. So the risk is that if you don't form an

4:22

industry neutral portfolio, or at least something that specifically considers industry characteristics, you could well underperform for an entire decade, um, because you've necessarily made a bet that an entire industry is undervalued. Right? Okay, I get it now. Um, we mentioned dividend yield here in Australia, as you well know. Uh, uh, you know, fully franked dividends, like we're very much a dividend market. So how does that factor in when you're considering factor investing?

4:52

Okay, well, I would argue that the most important stock characteristic investors should consider in Australia is dividend yield. Okay. The other characteristics like low asset growth, high quality earnings, um, high book to market. They're still relevant for investors. But because of the unique features of the Australian imputation tax system, we really, really care about dividends because of the substantial tax benefits investors can expose themselves to. So one way of forming a high dividend yield portfolio is to rank all the stocks in the market by dividend yield and take a long position in the stocks paying the highest fully franked dividends and ignoring the stocks paying low dividends and frank dividends, and on average, forming portfolios on that industry agnostic basis versus forming portfolios on an industry neutral basis offers you about the same total returns premium, from buying high yield stocks compared to low yield stocks. And that premium, on average over 17 years has been about 2 to

5:51

2.3%.

5:53

The limitation of ignoring industry is that you can have substantial periods where that strategy fails. So for the first three and a half years of that last 17 year period, that strategy of ignoring industry would have led to underperformance of that portfolio by approximately 6% per year for three and a half years. The benefit would have been that over the subsequent 13.5 years, investors would have earned a return premium, including imputation credits of 3%. And you might think, well, happy days. I like a 3% alpha on an after tax basis. But forming a portfolio is on an industry neutral basis, gives you a more consistent returns premium. Over that first three and a half years, those high yielding stocks would have earned a 1.5% return premium, including credits, and over the subsequent 13.5 years, they would have earned a returns premium of about 2.5%. So for investors looking for a

6:53

high average incremental return relative to their benchmark, they really have to consider taking an industry neutral position. Or in other words, the US evidence that we observe, um, says that you should ignore industry when forming a factor based portfolio because on average, it gives you a better reward for risk trade off. But our point is that the words, on average, are doing an awful lot of work in that conclusion. And investors typically, even if they're holding portfolios for a ten year period, don't realize the average result. They can realize something which is a long way from the average and lead to substantial underperformance. Okay, so summing it up, industry neutral versus not which wins

7:37

definitely for an industry neutral position or at least something approximating an industry neutral position. You don't need to be pathological about it, but ignoring any particular industry in an entire market means you're making a substantial industry bet. Uh, which means that if you hold that portfolio for 60 years and the future turns out to be approximately the same as the past, maybe you win. But that's beyond most investors lifetime, and in particular, beyond their investment horizon.

More like this

We value your privacy

We use essential cookies to make the site work. Non-essential cookies help us improve the experience. You can accept or reject non-essential cookies. Privacy policy