Sign inJoin free

Watch / Economy

Two stocks to consider and two stocks to avoid

13 Nov 20237:39

Two stocks to consider and two stocks to avoid

General information only. ausbiz videos are general information only, produced by Ausbiz TV Pty Ltd, a media business that doesn’t give financial advice. They don’t take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Consider whether it’s right for you and read the PDS and TMD before acting on anything you watch.

About this video

Jon Mills from Morningstar shares a nuanced perspective on Australia's recovery post-lockdown and the economic performance of China. Jon notes that despite a slower recovery than initially anticipated, there are still positive indicators such as a rise in commodity pricing. He identifies this as a result of decent economic growth compared to most of the rest of the world.

In regard to the residential property sector in China, Jon acknowledges severe issues, yet also recognises that steel production remains high. This is favourable for Australian iron ore miners such as BHP (BHP) and Rio (RIO). However, he shares less optimism for lithium, citing short term volatility as reason enough to not predict prices. Instead, he suggests an investment in lithium could be a good long-term move.

Lastly, Jon evaluates the performance of several companies in the market. He sees potential value in traditionally out-of-favour companies like Newmont (NEM), while cautioning against investments in South32 (S32) and Fortescue (FMG). From Jon's perspective, Deterra (DRR), despite owning the best mining royalty on earth, may be overvalued. He encourages investors to consider the likely reduction of the 100% payout ratio if Deterra expands its royalty portfolio.

Find the full unedited transcript of this interview below:

0:00

Now we're going to switch gears, turning to Australia's largest trading partner, China, and check in on some of the latest macroeconomic updates with Jon Mills from Morningstar, who joins me in the studio. Jon, thanks so much for coming in. Yeah. Morning. Anytime. Right. So let's have a look. It's sort of this this I suppose the recovery post lockdown. It's been a little bit bumpy. Third quarter GDP growth of 4.9%. Not as high as what they were expecting. But is it all necessarily negative. I don't think it's all negative. I mean, coming out of the lockdowns, everyone was very positive. And you saw commodity prices reflect that. I mean, iron ore and copper went up big time. And and since then it's the realization has been that it's a little slower, but it's still decent economic growth compared to, well, the rest of most of the rest of the world. Right. Okay. So if we have a look recently, the residential property sector, which has really been one of the big areas of concern,

0:59

is it now abating as we see or is something else going on as we see iron ore prices continue to move higher? Yeah, I mean, it's an interesting, interesting question because there are still severe problems in the in the residential property market in China. And as you say, it's a big part of their economy. I mean, new starts are going down. House prices are not really I think they've stabilized, but they're not really going up again. And a lot of developers are overleveraged and even going bust. Yet at the same time, you've still got very high steel production in China. And that's obviously fitting through to iron ore and also met coal demand. And so, look, I mean, the steel producers over there are still producing about a billion tonnes per year. And our iron ore miners such as BHP and Rio are benefiting from that. They are indeed. What about I was trying to touch on with Phineas at UBS about lithium prices. What is going on there? I mean, looks like you do have a slowdown in EV demand globally, possibly a bit of an

1:59

oversupply, but it could be of cars, EVs, but also potentially lithium. Is it a case of we need this sector to really now rationalize itself? I think it's more it's just I'm just short term volatility. I mean obviously lithium prices went up a lot and they've come back down a lot. But I think over the long term I mean as you mentioned, I mean EVs are going to roll out around the world. That'll be volatile as well. But I think if you're looking looking long term demand is going to be strong. And it's probably or it's unlikely, or at least we think that lithium supply will keep up. And so look you can't I can't predict short term prices. But I think lithium is a good a good point long term. Okay. Well let's maybe do a deep dive into some of the stocks that one can consider. And it's interesting Newmont now has you know taken taken over Newcrest. It's you know got a listing here in Australia. But gee the gold stocks really haven't been the top performers that some people had hoped for. Yeah. So I mean Newmont's

2:59

just taken off Newcrest and it's now listed on the ASX. Its share price hasn't done well. I think it's a combination of gold miners still being out of favour.

3:09

There's still worries about rising bond yields and that feeds through to all things being equal. That's lower gold prices because the opportunity cost to hold gold. But then if you look at Newmont itself I mean it's had a poor 2023 so far. So production has been lower than it should have been. Costs have been higher. And that's fed through to margins and hence earnings. So it's out of favour at the moment and we think there's an opportunity there. Okay. What about the likes of South 32. Run us through that one. Yes. So South32 hasn't been doing well recently as well. It's it's got a decent metallurgical coal business. But because of ESG, high coal prices aren't being reflected in its share price. And then in terms of other commodity exposures, copper, nickel, manganese, all those all those prices are down. And South32 tends to be a high cost miner than the likes of BHP and Rio. And so in a in a down market like we are now, where commodity prices are generally going down, it's more leveraged those lower prices. And we think that's been reflected in the share price.

4:09

Do you think the lower prices have more to do with the fact that maybe we're starting to discounting a global slowdown? I think so, yeah. I mean, look, China's the biggest source of demand for most commodities. But outside of China, generally speaking, well, in the West, higher interest rates are feeding through to to slow industrial production and slow economic growth. And yeah, I mean look the markets are forward forward looking as you know. And so that's I think that's a big reason why the likes of nickel and copper,

4:36

the prices have been down a lot recently. So yeah we'll see what happens okay. Maybe some stocks that investors should stay clear of. And it looks like one of them here is Fortescue which of course is rallying again because iron ore prices are going up and they're a relatively higher cost producer. They are relatively. Yeah. So that they are I mean.

4:59

You said the benefiting from high iron ore prices. Now I think things are $130 a tonne US and also discounts for their lower grade or are on the low side. And so at the moment things are very good for Fortescue. We, we, we don't think that's going to going to continue long term. We think iron ore prices will will moderate as Chinese steel production reduces. And then you've got Tweez green energy ambitions which he has great dreams in that aspect of the business. But we just think the they're unlikely to generate decent returns you know as green hydrogen or green ammonia and CapEx and opex on that side of the business is increasing. And so look, I mean, it's still on the green energy side, but we're we're not keen on Fortescue expanding into the green energy space. So that's why we think it's undervalued. And is it because it just creates too much sort of noise, too much stuff around it, too much investment, high CapEx? I think it's more we I mean, high CapEx is one

5:59

one issue. I mean, look, I mean, you know, BHP, it's got various commodities. So that's not really a problem if Fortescue diversifies into other businesses, but it's more that we don't see the economic case for it. I mean, they're talking about getting double digit returns. Well, you know, you can get you can get 20% returns plus by expanding their iron ore business. And so look, without subsidies, we just don't we don't think it's a good investment to invest in green hydrogen or green ammonia. Now in saying that if if we get something similar to the US subsidies that the the Inflation Reduction Act that was passed on a year ago or so, then some of these projects do become economic. And we think that's what Fortescue is trying to persuade the Australian government, amongst others, to to do implement. So look, we'll have a watching brief on on the green energy side. Yeah. Fair enough. It doesn't come cheaply to start with. What about doTERRA. So they get those great iron ore royalties don't they. Yeah. Look Terra is a fantastic

6:59

company. I mean it owns probably the best mining royalty on earth, BHP's iron ore mines in the Pilbara. All these half of them,

7:06

it's just overvalued. I mean, we'd love to own it, but it's, you know, it pays out 100% of its the income that gets from BHP. So far it's been unsuccessful that really diversifying and getting additional royalties. They are looking and given the cost of capital has been rising, they are getting more opportunities. We'd like to be patient, but I think one thing that will happen is if they do buy another royalty, you will see that 100% payout ratio be reduced. So if you're buying the turf for the for the dividend income, maybe that's something to consider as well.

More like this

We value your privacy

We use essential cookies to make the site work. Non-essential cookies help us improve the experience. You can accept or reject non-essential cookies. Privacy policy