Two small caps keeping the peace
About this video
Luke Winchester from Merewether Capital articulates concerns arising from small and micro-cap investors on company remuneration reports amid difficult market conditions. He observes shareholder activism, where votes against executive pay at General Meetings (GMs) signal dissatisfaction. Luke underscores this form of protest, particularly impactful for individual investors with limited influence, as a straightforward means to demand corporate accountability and change.
Delving into the mechanics of AGM votes, Luke emphasises the significance of remuneration report strikes and their potential to lead to board spills. Using Merewether Capital's holding, XREF (XRF), as an example, he illustrates that despite reasonable executive compensation, protest votes often reflect broader discontent with a company's direction and stock performance.
Furthermore, Luke displays optimism by spotlighting companies like Smart Parking (SPZ), which exemplify effective management and growth, demonstrating that there are still success stories amid general investor unease. He discusses Sequoia Wealth's (SEQ) positive update, operational pivot and strategy, and their use of a hefty cash reserve which could potentially lead to value-adding mergers and acquisitions, coupled with a commitment to dividends.
Below is an unedited transcript of the interview:
Hot under the collar. That's how many small cap investors are apparently feeling when it comes to remuneration reports. Luke Winchester from Merewether Capital has been listening in to AGM and he is here to dish. Luke, welcome. Nice to see you there. So what's the deal? They don't like remuneration. Like is there just angst out there because it's been such a tough area of the market. You think?
0:23
A spot on I don't mean. It's been a tough couple of years for for micro-cap and small cap investors. And, you know, as times have been tough and things have dragged on, a lot of investors are left wondering, you know, what actions are being taken by boards and management teams to, you know, turn around businesses and look to arrest the slide that a lot of these businesses are seeing in their share prices. And generally speaking, there's not a lot of actions that particularly small shareholders can take. Obviously, larger institutional shareholders can often enact some change in the background. But one way that is quite effective for for all shareholders is voting at ATMs. And so I wanted to have a quick chat today about, you know, what we have seen across the space. And a bit of a common theme is, you know, some some protest votes, for lack of a better word, against some of these remuneration reports. Okay. So you can give us examples if you like.
1:21
But if this is an expression of just general unease, is it also just wanting something, anything to be done to sort of change the trajectory for some of these small caps? Yeah, yeah. So I mean, let's talk about the the regulatory side of voting, voting at an AGM. So the remuneration report is voted on every year at an AGM, and if it receives more than 25% of the votes as a, as a no, then a strike is given against that remuneration report. Now nothing theoretically happens at that point. But if a board was to receive two strikes in consecutive years, then it actually goes to an automatic spill resolution and the board would have to be put up, you know, to potentially be spilled and replaced. So, you know, when you see these large no votes against the remuneration reports, again, to your point before, it's a little bit of a protest vote. You don't necessarily expect something to happen straight away. And a lot of the times it's not even
2:21
shareholders specifically pushing back against the remuneration, which is often quite reasonable. But it is the simplest way, as I said, for shareholders to to have that voice, particularly small individual shareholders, you know, to to try and push against
2:37
push against these boards and management teams and try to enact some of that change. So I will provide an example and look at a stock that I hold in the mirror with a capital portfolio. It's been a very poor performer for me. You know, Ref. Ex-f1 is the ticker. It had 57% votes against its remuneration report. And in my opinion, the remuneration report is quite reasonable. I don't think the management and the board, you know, overly remunerated or have, you know, soft incentive packages or anything like that. I think it was purely just, you know, shareholders a little bit sick of the operational direction that the business is going in and that being reflected in the share price. So that's one example. But, you know, if you were to open up any of these businesses, that's had a pretty tough couple of years and sort of not much has gone on in the background, you'll see some some decent votes against these remuneration reports, some of them resulting in that strike, which I was talking about before. Okay. And just a final question on that, Luke.
3:37
If you get a strike and nothing seems to change. I mean, what's the next step? You would imagine that small cap investors would get even more angry? Or do most boards sort of take that on board and act appropriately?
3:53
Look, I think most boards do take it on board. At the end of the day, they are supposed to act in the interest of shareholders. Not not the management teams that are running the business. And most genuinely, you know, do that and, you know, sort of take that, that sort of protest or warning shot at them quite seriously and sort of engage with shareholders and say, what is the change that you're looking to enact and what can we do? As far as formally, I mean, as I said before, you need two consecutive years. So if nothing was to happen, you would have to wait for the next AGM and have another, another vote against the remuneration report. But, you know, realistically, if you get a large vote against the remuneration report, it generally indicates there's some disgruntled shareholders there. And it's not uncommon to see a spill resolution brought ahead earlier. If you can get 5% of the shareholder base to agree to that. So, you know, it's something we have seen in the last couple of years on the market. And as I've sort of said in my notes, Nadine, I think
4:53
it's something we might see a little bit more of just some of this shareholder activism, maybe some of it done a bit more passively behind the scenes rather than as aggressive as, you know, spill resolutions and things like that. But nonetheless, as sort of said, I think the winds are changing and it's clear that shareholders are disgruntled. And I think boards and management both need to sit up and listen and pay attention to what's being said. Okay, Luke, can't all be bad news for AGM. Come on, give us some good news.
5:23
Well, I was on two weeks ago, wasn't on, was very grumpy and said I didn't want to ruin it. I'll bring some good stuff and I'll do the same again this week. Nadine. So a couple of stocks who thought had really good updates and as the first one, I am a shareholder of and a happy shareholder, which is Smart Parking.
5:39
I've spoken about these guys before, and I know people who tune in regularly are probably sick of me talking about them. But I'll keep banging the table for these guys because, you know, it's the example of a management team and a board that think are just executing brilliantly right now and happy to keep backing them at what they're doing. So these guys do parking management, you know, cameras and software privately for retail, hospitality, airports, even some councils as well. And it's a real it's a real growing industry. So so you know the old industry of the bloke walking around in his high of his jacket, you know, manually writing parking tickets is slowly dying and being replaced by these camera operated systems. And smart parking is well and truly entrenched in that space as one of the leaders. And they're just they're just, as I said, just executing to that sort of growth trajectory really well. So the key metric for these guys is what they call their sites under operation, which is how many sort of parking lots they have under
6:39
management. And that number has just been ticking up beautifully, to the point where they originally had a goal of 1500 sites before December 2025, and they've actually, sorry, 2024 and they've brought that forward to June. So about six months ahead of schedule. And given it's a it's a business where it's very much unit economic driven, like each site is sort of an incremental addition and there's very little sort of fixed cost onto that, that operating base below it. You can model it out quite cleanly. And I've sort of done that in the past. I've got a blog on the Meriweather Capital website where I've sort of said, if think this business gets to that 1500 sites, you know, it could be spinning out somewhere between 18 to $20 million of EBITDA, which on the current market cap makes it incredibly cheap. So first quarter update was really strong tracking towards it. Margins were even better than expected. So again, this is one where,
7:32
you know, sort of paired against what we were just talking about. These guys had no issues at their AGM. I think holders on the whole were quite happy. Okay, give us give us one more, Luke
7:42
and one more. So I don't own this one. But look, you know credit where it's due. Sequoia wealth
7:47
a fantastic update from these guys. So they had a tougher year last year. You had a few one offs, a few issues. They spun off an asset really well. Got a very good price on a on a clearinghouse asset that they had. They brought in about 40 odd million dollars. And they've recently given a couple of updates that said, operationally, that business is sort of really turned around from those issues it had last year. So they came out the other week. It wasn't actually an update, but we'll throw it in here anyway. They're guiding towards 10 million operating EBITDA this year. That's more than double on last year. As said, that's coming off a bit of a lower base and some one offs in that previous period. But nonetheless I mean it's a fantastic operational result. And I think the key to it, I mean, if you look at if you look at the valuation, on the whole it looks okay, but but sort of doesn't blow your socks off. But when you factor in that huge cash balance these guys have from spinning off that asset last year, you know, trades on sort of like 3 to
8:47
4 times the adjusted enterprise value when you remove the cash on the balance sheet. And it's a management team where M&A is definitely a focus for them. There's some risk to that. It's tough to acquire in the space there in in that financial services space, financial planning advice, insurance, things like that. But nonetheless if they can acquire, well bolt on some earnings. You know, this is a business that you could see, you know, even from an operational point of view, trading on that sort of 4 to 5 times quite quickly, if they can bring some earnings in. And in the meantime, one thing I noted in the notes, Nadine, is they've committed to paying a nice dividend. So it's that classic. People love to say that classic example. And you get paid to wait. So you know, if management can find great acquisitions, fantastic. If they can't, you'll get cash back as shareholders in a nice healthy sort of nine, 10% at these prices. So not one I own. Unfortunately. I've tried to I've sort of been anchored to lower prices, which is never a good thing. But nonetheless, for those who hold it, I'm sure they're also very happy as well.