Sign inJoin free

Watch / Three stocks for...

Two downgrades and an upgrade

9 May 20246:08

Two downgrades and an upgrade

General information only. ausbiz videos are general information only, produced by Ausbiz TV Pty Ltd, a media business that doesn’t give financial advice. They don’t take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Consider whether it’s right for you and read the PDS and TMD before acting on anything you watch.

About this video

Key highlights:

  • Rudi Filapek-Vandyck highlights Aria Group's positive performance amidst Australia's buoyant housing market

  • The FN Arena expert shares alarming updates on Tourism Holdings and ANZ Bank's disappointing performance compared to other banks

  • Rudi also observes recent retail trends, signalling possible short-term setbacks despite optimistic forecasts

Rudi Filapek-Vandyck of FN Arena comments on recent updates from leading financial and property corporations. Rudi mentions Aria Group's stronger than anticipated accomplishments in light of Australia's robust housing market. He also brings to light significant news regarding Tourism Holdings, reframing the company's recent profit warning as an indication of potentially weak performance in the first half of 2025. He proposes that the current challenging state of the share price may not be its lowest point.

Rudi goes on to examine the conditions of major banks amidst a tough environment. He observes ANZ Bank's underwhelming performance, evidenced by its subdued share price and lowered forecasts, compared to its counterparts Westpac, NAB, and CBA. Rudi also discusses Babcock's problems contrasted with ARB and Super Retail, which seem less troubled.

Finally, Rudi shares his observations regarding retail performance in light of the Easter effect and potential tax cuts. He warns of possible short-term disappointments despite some emerging optimism amongst brokers. Rudi also notes the increasing market interest in copper exposure and BHP's pursuit of Anglo American.

Below is the full unedited transcript of this interview:

0:00

Let's get into some broker updates. Rudi Filapek-Vandyck from FN Arena joins me. Hi, Rudi. I saw you tweet about re Group the city update there because that's come out with numbers. Your thoughts here?

0:13

Well, uh, better than expected. And I think that's that's what counts on the day.

0:19

Um, I mean, needless to say, our group is one of those, uh, extremely strong performance on the Australian share market. Um, it's difficult to bet against the housing market in Australia. Um, I would like to exclude myself, but Australians are absolutely,

0:38

completely into properties. They are. And and if you're owning and if you want to, if you want to play that theme, of course, then Aria has been and probably still remains the place to be to play that theme. Yeah. I think, um, we had a guest yesterday saying domain Group was its poor cousin. Aria certainly seems to be the one that people prefer. Um, let's look as well about what we saw with Tourism Holdings, because that had such a big move and a downgrade here from Morgans as well.

1:07

I think the lesson here for investors is that just because a company has issued bad news, it doesn't mean that it can't get worse. And and the market was expecting not great news from Tourism Holdings. Uh, but then they came out with, with with quite a severe profit warning and the share price got shellacked, of course. Uh, the bad news here is that, uh, Morgans, who was as equally as shocked as as the rest of the market, uh, they think there were enough indications in the market update to, uh, to predict now that the first half of the next financial year that's 2025, uh, will be weak as well. And that's obviously something to to to keep in mind. It means that a weak share price, as we are experiencing this week, is not necessarily the bottom just yet when it comes to the banks. We're just talking with Harry about a lot of the buybacks and the update. CBA looks like it's a bit of a

2:07

beat, but what our broker is saying about ANZ,

2:10

well, the there are a few certainties in life and that's when the banks are doing it tough. They will take care of their shareholders as we are experiencing a this week. Um, the the summary with ANZ and that's even more pertinent since we had a slightly better than expected result, I think from, from commbank today. Um, and that seems to be the weakest now, the weakest out of the big four. And um, that was also reflected in a more subdued share price response on the day of release. And that's also now being reflected in brokers after the results, uh, share price targets seem to be coming down. Forecasts seem to be coming down for ANZ. And that's quite in contrast to the likes of Westpac, NAB and probably CBA today. So it would appear that for the time being, um, the, the weakest laggard is uh, is ANZ Bank now. Yeah. Um, you mentioned about Australians

3:09

being obsessed with property. What about obsessed with fixing our cars because bankers been hit quite hard recently. What are the brokers saying?

3:19

Well, because yes, I haven't been I haven't been a big I was early in the year, I was asked which stock I disliked the most, and I did pick Babcock so I could, I could Trump, I could do the Trump thing here. Um, I think, I think there's a lot of uncertainty with Babcock. Um, the, the, the, the new CEO designate decided a few days before he was, uh, he was taking up his position that he wasn't going to do it. And then we get a big profit warning from the company itself. So I think investors should draw their own conclusions at the very least, uh, the likes of ARB and and and good which sort of are in the same sector as this super retail. They don't seem to have the problems that Babcock has, definitely not to that extent. And when it comes to some of the weakness, Rudy, that we've been seeing in retail, I was talking about this with Harry as well. I mean, baby bunting today, that 21% drop. But JB Hi-Fi came up with an

4:18

update as well. Is this kind of priced in or what are the brokers saying about some of the weakness from these retailers? Uh, early, early responses to to, uh, JB Hi-Fi today is that there has been an Easter effect, which has sort of pulled back a little bit on the sales numbers, and that's probably a little bit perceived as a, as a, as a, as a disappointment. But then if that, if it's simply the Easter effect, that should then, uh, rectify itself. Um, I can sense some of the brokers getting a little bit more optimistic for the second half of the year. Uh, but we'll have to see, of course. What what happens, what part of that optimism is because the conditions. Just very tough right now and there should be a slightly stimulative budget coming, coming ahead in the weeks ahead with, with with some tax cuts basically. And maybe at some point we will see the RBA cutting interest rates. So there is of

5:18

optimism creeping in into broker's forecasts. But as we are experiencing with with this week's updates, uh, that's a little bit further out. And in the short term we have to be careful for disappointments. And just a quick word as well, reading on some of the the mining players or the copper players I just saw on your website, um, the showroom partners focus on icy mines.

5:41

Um, to be honest, I haven't. I haven't particularly seen that one, but I know that I know that RC mines is, is is often mentioned as, as as as a, as a pure play. But I don't think they're producing just yet. Uh, I think that's, that's a, that's a feature story. But needless to say, uh, the market is getting is heating up towards, uh, copper exposure, which is not right now but should be in the years ahead. And that also explains why BHP is going after Anglo American.

More like this

We value your privacy

We use essential cookies to make the site work. Non-essential cookies help us improve the experience. You can accept or reject non-essential cookies. Privacy policy