Time in the market > timing the market
About this video
Jesse Moors of Spatium Capital, discusses the underlying luck element often attributed to successful investment portfolios, likening it to a mental bias that investors usually deny in times of prosperity while accepting it during failures. He questions whether portfolio success can be chalked up to strategic thinking alone or if luck plays a greater role than acknowledged.
Jesse points out that regardless of the luck factor, the integrity of the investment choice remains vital. Touching upon the shift he has observed from equity to private credit, Jesse emphasises the cautioning element. He notes market players' interest in private credit with seemingly guaranteed high returns, suggesting that investors need to remember such guaranteed returns do not exist. He imparts a warning about the potential ‘bad debts’ and delinquency rates that can drastically impact these seeming gains, advising a vigilant approach towards this sector of the market.
Lastly, Jesse shares his views about the importance of longevity and consistent performance in the investment market. He acknowledges successful investors like Warren Buffett, Kerr Neilson and Peter Cooper, attributing their success not solely to a specific investment thesis but to their time spent in the market. He advises investors to focus on long-term goals, to avoid being influenced by temporary market movements and to remain dedicated to their strategy.
Find the full unedited transcript of this interview below:
All right. Well, is there a looming bubble in private credits? Our next guest thinks that time the luck may have a role to play when it comes to building portfolios. Let's get into it. Jesse Moors joining us now from Spatium Capital. Hey, Jesse, good to catch up with you. All right. Luck. What's luck got to do with it. But what you're also talking about timing. Talk us through what you're seeing then. Just in terms of private credit.
0:26
Andrew, good to speak with you again. So maybe we'll address the lack portion first. So I think it's an interesting time. No doubt a lot of fund managers are probably scratching their heads looking at the terminal at the moment. Not sure why performance or why the market is not trending in the way that we'd anticipate. Got us thinking to do a little bit of a deep dive into the concept of luck, right? Think of it as a as a bias. There's a bit of a mental bias that we might use. It's interesting when your portfolio is going really, really well, you'd probably tell people, or you probably tell yourself that you knew it was going to go well, you knew it was the right investment, you knew it was the right thematic, you knew it was the right sector, whatever you might have chosen to be above. But when things go wrong with a tendency is as a humans, as a population to say, oh, it's a bit of bad luck. I didn't see that coming. That was a bit of a black swan that caught me off guard. Whatever. So I think it's just an interesting point to raise that I dare say there'd be maybe a few fundies that are writing newsletters to their clients saying, look, it's a bit of they might
1:26
not use the word luck, but we didn't anticipate this. We didn't see this this quarter off guard, effectively inferring or implying bad luck. But then when things are going well, no one will ever say it was just good luck. We got lucky. People will say it was my brilliance. It was, you know, we saw that was going to happen, hence why we invested. So setting the luck piece aside, now conscious that we are equity fund managers so we have no direct interest or influence in private debt or private credit markets. But we are finding it anecdotally quite interesting. Over the last month and a half, almost eight weeks now that we're speaking to a lot of wealth managers and a lot of people in the allocation space, speaking about the significant shift toward a full portfolios towards private credit, now that's all good. And, well, when they're offering nine, 10%
2:18
yields on the basis that obviously that the products that they're investing in, the fixed income products are obviously quite stable. But I think it's interesting for us in equity land that you are getting a bit of an undertone of people saying, oh, well, you know, it's a guaranteed nine, ten, 12% and think it's important for clients to be conscious that there are no such things as a guaranteed return, because if they were you wouldn't you wouldn't be invested in equity markets. You'd have everything in private credit if it was a guarantee. So just think that there's a bit of caution there that given that we are seeing some managers and some of these private credit operators coming out saying, oh, you know, we're offering X percent, which look quite incredible relative to equity markets at the moment. We would caution that there are such things as bad debts and delinquency rates that can affect these term premiums. And with a previous experience in insolvency, I can tell you when it goes wrong, it goes pretty horribly wrong pretty quickly. So we just think that there should be a little bit of caution in that segment of the market. At the moment, it feels like that there's a
3:18
little bit too much exuberance heading that way, when I wouldn't have thought, we're out of the woods just yet. Yeah, because we are seeing particularly private equity has casting its eyes across what's going on in the listed space at the moment, isn't it? I mean, there are some opportunities there. Clearly they're seeking to take advantage of.
3:38
Yeah, absolutely. I mean that's the beauty suppose of listed markets is their price daily their price by the minute by the second. If you can get that feed. So you have a little bit more transparency there. I think that's just where you know, any asset class that has less transparency obviously needs to be looked at in respect to the risk pay off for, for that lack of transparency. So again, just sort of a
4:04
when you're hearing a broad consensus in the market that there's a lot of money shifting in that direction, you will naturally get opportunists in that segment of the market that probably aren't doing the right, probably aren't investing in the right projects. And inevitably one of those dominoes will fall. And unfortunately, there's often a little bit of a chain reaction there that can blow up a few of those other private credit offerings. So I think that's just the word at the moment is just just exercise a bit of caution and thinking that that's where the money is to be made conclusively right now.
4:34
So, Jesse, a familiar refrain, it's not timing the market. It's time in the market. What is that value there?
4:43
I think this is just an interesting point. Broadly, when you look at some of the most successful investors globally over the last 40, 50, 60 years, if you look at Warren Buffett, but, you know, you look at Kurt Nielsen, probably one of Australia's most successful investors, over the last or at least 25 years, you had a really strong track record. Peter Cooper is another one who goes under the radar, who's had a really strong period of time. Some of the other guys based in Sydney, Samuel Terry, like you get some of these operators that have successful track records. And the common thread there is, you know, whether you're taking any of those local investors, whether you're using Warren Buffett, Stan Druckenmiller, George Soros, longevity is the key for these successful track records. Alpha might not be there for three or 4 or 5 years. You can have an extended period of time, and then certainly these managers might come on board for another 5 or 10 year period. So longevity in itself is a bit of a paradox because you don't have more time right now. You only get
5:43
time through the passing of time. So there's really no other way to fast track it. That's just the irony of of being a human and the concept of time more broadly. But I think an interesting commonality that we see amongst these really successful long term managers, not necessarily from their investment thesis, but time in the market. The longevity is you often see that the principles, if you could draw broad principles across all of them that are on record, is it's often there's a bit of reversion, there's a bit of mean reversion to the way that they invest. It's the sort of the predictability of history. Now, whilst we always say in the industry, past performance is not an indicator of the future, which is true, you will often see the repetition of historical events in some way, shape or form that a lot of these managers are really sophisticated and well equipped to be able to capitalise on as and when they become available. So, you know, a great example is we were on the chat with yourself, Andrew, what about a month ago, maybe six weeks ago, saying we think the time is now for
6:43
Australian smalls and we are seeing that broad consensus come back. Notwithstanding, Aussie smalls have had a pretty horrible three months. So again, you can't compound three months into the future is to that's that's the expectation. But if you're prepared and if your position right, you can possibly be like, you know, the next Neilson or the next Peter Cooper. If you can remain convicted, avoid style, drift, take your ego and your emotions out of it and remain focused on what it is you're trying to execute.