Three stocks with 'high quality' earnings
Three stocks with 'high quality' earnings
About this video
Key highlights:
Resilience of many companies' revenue lines
Positive impact of cost moderation
Assessment of SG Fleet Group, Integral Diagnostics, and Bega Cheese's business performance and growth potential
Marc Whittaker of Investors Mutual outlines his observations on the recent reporting season. Despite expressed concerns about a softer consumer outlook, Marc suggests there were surprising improvements in the resilience of many companies' revenue lines. In Marc's view, he finds that margins have held up better, with visible margin expansion in a few cases. He points to moderated costs, such as freight, and cost of goods sold which supported the gross profit line. Moreover, deflation in China has been a significant gain for Australian companies. He believes this has boosted bottom lines during the reporting season.
He mentions three noteworthy companies which have shown improved earnings outlook and composition. SG Fleet Group (SGF) is identified as a major fleet management company, benefiting greatly from the transition to electric vehicles and associated tax advantages. Marc believes the company's shares are set to move higher over time. Furthermore, Integral Diagnostics (IDX), while facing cost challenges due to Covid, is expected to see a growth spurt with the return of volumetric demands. Despite facing a cost difference on the stenography and radiology end due to Covid, he perceives a bottoming margin of about 18% which he expects to improve over time.
Lastly, Marc makes reference to Bega Cheese (BGA), pointing out the two parts of the company to be their branded food business and bulk commodity business. The company, being a consumer favorite, has suffered losses due to the influence of soft global demand and China's dip in purchases. Yet, he conjectures the company's branded business to be virtually resilient and earning a considerable EBITDA, laying emphasis on brand strength. Marc expects Bega to break even on the commodity side in the long run, turning losses into profits. Moreover, he concludes that Bega's shares are on discount and holds significant growth potential.
Below is the full unedited transcript of this interview:
0:00
Reporting season is now behind us from February. Let's get into some of those results and what it all means in terms of how to invest from here on. Marc Whittaker joining us from Investors Mutual. Mike good to see you. Andrew. How are you? Very well. Um, okay. Let me then ask you to sum it up. Um, uh, what you saw in in reporting season. Yeah. So surprisingly, in some ways reporting season was actually better than expected. So if we looked at the revenue lines for lots of companies are relatively resilient. So we had a lot of chatter going into reporting season that the consumer would be softer outlooks would be a little bit softer, but surprisingly, in many cases revenue lines were actually quite held up quite well. And what we have seen is margins hold up better and dare I say, some margin expansion as well because we have seen some moderation in costs. So whether that was freight, cost of goods sold mainly of that gross profit line, we did start to see some cost moderation or abatement, which was encouraging. We have seen deflation in China. So a lot of the goods being exported from China currently we are seeing deflation there. So that certainly helped some of the
0:59
bottom lines that we saw reported in reporting season. Those perhaps better than expected results that maybe we saw both here in Australia and also out of reporting season in the States, a very good reason why we're continuing to see this, this market rally. Well, aside from what we saw last night, of course, and today. But overall, yeah, I mean you can see why markets have moved higher earnings have surprised on the upside. Generally speaking outlook isn't that bad. So we've all painted a doom and gloom scenario in some quarters of the market. But the outlook isn't that bad. The consumer is still softening a little bit and I think inflation's still hanging around. So we haven't sort of knocked those nails on the head just yet. But but by and large the outlooks have been generally better than expected. So in the wake of local reporting season have you readjusted your portfolio? We've always focused on on quality as one of our key benchmarks. When we look to invest in companies. I've got three names for you today, which I want to pitch to, uh, to you and your listeners or viewers, just these are three examples of companies where I think the quality of the earnings outlook and the composition of the earnings
2:00
quality has improved. So more conviction coming out of reporting season that actually the earnings quality and composition of these companies is improving, is getting better. And what that generally means is that the market over time, we've prepared to pay more for these sorts of earnings quality. So I would expect these three names in particular to start moving higher. They did report good outlooks and outcomes during the reporting season. So they have seen some price appreciation. But I think in each of these instances that the stocks are cheap. As I said, the quality of the earnings is improving. And I think these share prices move higher over time. All right. Well let's start with the first one you pick being SG fleet Group and fleet management. Yeah. So the largest fleet management company in the country. So if you think about corporate uh auto fleets or government department auto fleets, one of the big positive tailwinds in that sector at the moment is the transition to electric vehicles and the tax benefits that come around that. So actually fleet plays in that fleet management space. So we're seeing a lot of procurement of electric vehicles from government fleets and corporate fleets. And that's a real tailwind for them because they they procure
2:59
the fleet on behalf of these these departments, whether it's a corporate department or a government department. And on the leasing side, we're seeing obviously, these tax benefits that come through if you are purchasing an electric vehicle. So that's been a real tailwind for the sector in general. So if we look at Macmillan Shakespeare, we look at smart Group, we look at fleet partners as well. They've all had a nice uplift on the back of results that look pretty good pretty decent. And we've got that strong EV tailwind behind them actually fleets trading on ten times PE. So it's at least a minimum 20% discount to its closest PE in that space. So on a dividend yield of 7% fully franked. And what I really liked about the result was that the quality of the earnings for that first half that they've just reported was, in my view, of the highest quality. So we actually fleets really benefited the last 3 or 4 years is those residual values or those second hand car values over time have held up really well, largely as a legacy of Covid and the lack of new car supply coming in. What we saw in this result was that that revenue line actually dropped away quite significantly, but we saw a dramatic uplift in the rest of the business and the revenues around the rest of the business. So a strong
3:59
pipeline backlog of new car orders, they've added leasing orders, uh, fleet management demand. So for me, all of a sudden, that's a result which I look at and say, you know what? The quality of that result is actually quite good and improving because that that less recurring, sort of more lumpy end of lease or residual value income is actually dropping away quite significantly. But the top line still grew at 11%. And we're getting some reasonably good margin appreciation, and we're getting some very good earnings growth. And as I say on a p e of ten, a dividend yield of 7%, fully franked, it's quite compelling. The liquidity of the stock has improved quite a lot too. So I think it goes into the uh the ASX 300 at some point. And that's going to that's going to compel a lot of buying on the back of that inclusion as well. So I think lots of things are like about that stock at the moment. All right. That's Shiflett. Let's now move on to Integral Diagnostics. And it's actually been punished by the market. It has been knocked around the head a little bit. I think what we saw in this result was that margins are bottomed. So revenue lines again all three examples I'm pointing out to you
4:59
today. There's no question about demand. There's demand for what they do. There's demand for innovated leasing. There's demand for radiology services. Where the issue has been with Indigo Diagnostics in particular, is the cost line. So we're still tackling the impacts of Covid. So, you know, finding radiologists, finding stenographers, uh, you know, the ways that you have to pay to secure these sorts of people has been elevated. So while the top line has been great, growing at 8%, that that cost base has been a bit of an issue. So what we saw in this half just reported was that margins have bottomed at about 18%. And from here we would expect margins to improve. Now why do I think the quality of that result was somewhat higher than expected as well? Well, if we look at the top line, that 8% growth, volume, volume growth was actually pretty much zero in that in that result. So it was really a it was really a combination of Medicare indexation, about 3 to 4%, and the mix of scans and radiology processes that that within that revenue line meant that, generally speaking, they got a higher price per scan or per per radiology process. But volume
5:58
growth was almost zero. So what we can expect to see is volumes start to return over time. As more GP's come into the country and people, more people get back to visiting their GP, that's been a real bottleneck or choke point for the for the stock. We're going to see that top line continue to move higher and as that top line is higher again, we've talked about cost basis moderating. So the prices you're paying to secure radiologists and nursing staff is now moderating a little bit. We should start to see those margins expand as well. All right. So you talk about the demand certainly in the fleet management in radiology. What about in cheese Bega Cheese funnily enough begets and still that much cheese though that's really a legacy of the company. What I really liked about this business is there's two parts of the Bega. There's the branded food business. So you think about Vegemite, you think about Bega Peanut Butter, you think about dairy farmers, you think about dairy, iced coffee, you think about Yoplait yogurt. These are all very strong, uh, consumer brands that resonate with mums and dads in the shopping centre, in the supermarket. And on the other hand, you've got this bulk commodity business where they procure milk from dairy farms and they process that milk given to branded products,
6:58
or they sell that into international commodity markets and that international commodity market. So you think about skim milk powder, whole milk powder, butter, cream cheese and so forth. That's been really depressed because China hasn't been buying in a global demand has been a little bit soft. And so we've seen bigger actually lose 15 to $20 million on that commodity side. So what I really liked about this result was what that means is that the branded business is actually earning about $200 million of EBITDA. Now, that's a that's a pretty significant branded consumer business. And if I look at the likes of a a2 milk or the likes of a turkey wine, these sorts of companies are trading on multiples EBITDA multiples of 14 to 15 times. You can get bigger now for ten times for the whole business. Now, what I really like about the outlook for this particular business is that the losses that they're earning in that brand, in that bulk business, rather that 15 to 20 million, that's coming back to zero over time and we'll start to grow and become a positive contributor. But what that means is that you're getting that branded business at a significant discount. And if we look at the M&A that's happened in that space in recent times, whether it was United Malt Group,
7:58
which was a malting business that went for 12 times EBITDA, you look at it looks at Blackmores again, not not a food business, but a consumer facing businesses. It went for 20 times EBITDA. All of a sudden you can start to see, oh hang on, this is a business that's on sale. It's in the supermarket. It's been discounted. Uh, it's I can get a value well above what the current share price is. If I just think about well what would a what would inquire be prepared to pay for what is a high quality consumer food business. And for me the upside is quite, quite significant. And as it is for three months that I point out to you today.