Three small cap stocks Lucas likes
Three small cap stocks Lucas likes
About this video
Lucas Goode from Investors Mutual shares his opinion on the smaller end of the market which has experienced a long period of underperformance against large caps, with small caps witnessing more than 30% underperformance at one point. Lucas suggests that this trend is shifting, referring to the recent recovery over the last two quarters. He also observes the numerous fluctuations in the Russell Index.
Lucas brings a specific focus on Austal, influenced by the South Korean shipbuilder's takeover offer. However, he finds the offer, bid at $2.82, inadequate for Austal's fair value which he believes must begin with a three or even a four to be competitive. Lucas further elaborates on Austal's assets, including their $20 billion order book, and speculates that bidding might lure private equity firms in the data room to participate.
Lastly, Lucas also discusses Ridley Corporation and Cooper Energy. He sees Ridley as a steady grower under management and speculates that it could be a potential target for takeover offers. As for Cooper Energy, Lucas highlights how forecasted gas shortages in Australia might drive up prices, reaping significant benefits for east coast suppliers like Cooper. He also associates the successful development of Otway Phase three and the recent completion of the risk-laden BMG abandonment as promising signals for Cooper's future growth.
Find the full unedited transcript of this interview below:
0:00
Well, let's get across the smaller end of the market now. Lucas Goode joining us from Investors Mutual. Lucas, good to see you. Good to see you, Andrew. I was taking a look. In fact, the Russell last night was smashed, wasn't it? Um, what are you making of the smaller end of the market at the moment? And I guess now we're in the beginning of a new quarter. Yeah. Look, we had such a long period of underperformance of small caps versus. Versus large caps. About over a rolling three year underperformance was about 30%, over 30% at one point. A bit of a recovery the last two quarters. Um, but I mean, look, the Russell does bounce around a lot. So I don't think you read too much into a single single overnight move. Certainly the US market was looking like it needed a bit of a correction. All right. Well, let's get, uh, specific stock wise locally, at least with some companies in the news is going to be with Austal. Yeah. A South Korean shipbuilder lobbing, uh, takeover offer, although also saying, well, let's just be a little cautious here because you've got to get it through the regulator. Yeah. Look, a bit of a head scratcher of a response. In some ways, I think. I mean, clearly,
0:59
um, a lot of political concerns and intrigue around, uh, around a defense contractor for both the Australian and US governments in Australia. I mean, interestingly enough, it's not out of completely out of the ordinary for an allied, um, an Allied owned shipbuilder to, to supply the US Navy. Um, obviously you got Austal in Alabama, but also the Italian shipbuilder Fincantieri has got a shipyard in the US that supplies boats to the US Navy to, um, slightly complicated nozzles case because they do also subcontractor General Dynamics on the nuclear submarines. So that probably would have to stay within the aukus countries. You'd think um, I think more is, you know, my biggest response as a shareholder, I was just $2.82. I mean, no way. It's it's not even close to fair value for Austal. Um, what is fair value? Look, I think the board would, would need a, would need something beginning with a three even to entertain it. And maybe it would need to start with a four to get it done. I mean I still net tangible assets per share is about $2.45. And that ascribes nothing to the $20 billion order book that they've got. Um,
1:59
so we still think there's a lot of upside on a standalone basis for Austal. But the other thing with, with the Anwar, um, bid that was made public is that there's been rumors for a long time. There's a couple of us private equity firms in the data room for us to. So maybe this can bring them out into the open. Um, and does put us still in play. And M&A has certainly been a big factor of the small cap end of the market over the last 6 to 9 months. So so what did you make of their response when they referred more to, uh, regulatory issues rather than the actual value of the company? Yeah. I mean, look, clearly there would be some regulatory issues. I mean, I think a lot of those military contracts do have changing control provisions in them. Um, so it does complicate any bid. But yeah. Look, it was somewhat interesting to me that, you know, I would have thought they would have dismissed the $2.82 bit out of hand anyway. Um, but I think also just, just flagging that, hey, we're not actually sure that you'd be able to complete this transaction.
2:48
All right, that is all. Still, let's move on now to Ridley Corporation. Interesting stock. This one was animal nutrition. And uh flies under the radar somewhat, doesn't it, given its market performance over the past four years or so it's look, it's been a really steady just a steady grower under the under the management team led by Quentin Hildebrand, a really A-grade management team. I got to say, um, look, as I just touched on with, with Austin Andrew, I mean, I it's been a real failure of the small cap end of the market over the last 6 to 9 months. So I think that's a function of both. You know, how cheap small caps are relative to larger caps, but also just funding costs as they've stabilized potentially, you know, larger companies and, and financial buyers, uh, are having the confidence to, to make these takeover offers. I mean, we've had more than a dozen takeover bids for, for portfolio companies in the last six months alone at IML. And so you can't help but wonder, well, you know, what could be next? Um, and, you know, I look at Ridley, GrainCorp made a takeover offer for them about a decade ago. Uh, it's something that maybe would make sense for GrainCorp that that's the really stock feed business be countercyclical with grain feed, GrainCorp
3:48
core core business. Um, potentially some synergies in GrainCorp seed crushing business with with Ridley's tallow business. Uh, would an international buyer look at Ridley to get feedstock for biofuels? Um,
4:01
so, you know, we do think Ridley could be a potential target. But even as we stand there today, I mean, we're never going to own something just on the hope that it's going to get taken out. It's, you know, obviously nice when it happens. But Ridley itself, we think is a really steady performer. Well, clearly, I mean, you don't you have to take a look at that chart. So you just be happy to hold that at the moment. Oh absolutely. Would it's not about 15 times next year's earnings. And for a business that we think is really showing some some stable growth in recent years. And also what we've seen, you know M&A is a two sided coin. Companies can also add value by partaking in M&A themselves. And we really like the deal that really did. Late last year buying Oceana made meat processors. Uh, Kiwi company that provides effectively meat blocks into the global pet food market. And it's just we thought it was a really interesting acquisition because Ridley and Quentin is they've been quite vocal for a while, and trying to move that ingredient recovery business further up the value chain from just, you know, from biofuels, as an example, um, up into into pet pet food.
4:57
Let's now move into the energy space with the focus. Is on Cooper Energy, which is what gas supply into Southeast Asia from the Cooper Basin into the East coast, east coast of Australia. Right? Yep. Okay. Uh, now, as I gather, um, there was sort of we've had warnings about looming gas shortages. So what benefit do you see for a company like that? So look really topical right. Aemo came out a couple of weeks ago. And we've there's been repeated warnings about shortages within the decade on the East Coast. We know that supply out of the Bass Strait is declining. I mean, copper CEO Jay Norman actually was was in the press at the time of that ammo announcement. Just saying. Look how um, just pointing this out. Now, look, as an Australian, it's pretty ridiculous that one of the world's largest LNG exporters isn't going to have enough gas in a few years for our own domestic needs. Um, but for a supplier into the East Coast market, like copper. I mean, we know what happens when this supply shortages, the price goes up. And we've already seen that, you know, things are things are already moving in terms
5:57
of contracted prices. We're now hearing talk of 15 or $16 a gigajoule. Cooper's average contracted price at the moment is about eight bucks. Um, so the growth that they could get just through pricing out of their existing asset base is enormous. And you've also got some a great growth project in the Otway Phase three development. The big thing that's been hanging over Cooper's head has been this BMG abandonment that they've had to complete. Uh, we've already seen one cost blowout. So it was great to see that announcement this morning that they've completed 70% of the work and in fact, completed all of their lower reservoir work. So there's no longer any risk of hydrocarbons leaking into the sea. Um, so it looks like they're through. The worst of it there removes a real risk factor that had been weighing on the stock. And we think that it's the cleanest exposure on the ASX to the East Coast gas market. What are you expecting from the gas price then? We've sort of seen the oil price rise. It tends to take gas with it. It does. I mean, the interesting thing with with domestic gas, it's very much a domestic market because we're not selling on to the global market. Um, you know, generally the energy complex does tend to move
6:56
together. That's absolutely right. Uh, but just just to me, you know, I but you talk about that shortfall domestically, anyone watching I mean, you look at that that future the future path of demand and supply, I mean, demand is falling away as we electrify the economy, but supply is falling a lot faster. Well, and it goes to that narrative, doesn't it? That gas is integral to the transformation. Well, it absolutely is. I mean, not only do we hear a lot about how you need gas to actually balance out renewables in the energy grid, but gas isn't only used for electricity generation, right? I mean, there's large parts of the industrial economy that need gas as an input. So you actually there's parts of the Australian economy that can't function without gas.