“This is an aggressive move by Macquarie, but is it as good as it seems?”
About this video
Andrew Wielandt from DP Wealth Advisory shares his insights on the rapidly growing ETF sector and Macquarie's aggressive push for competition in this market. He argues this move could bring about a price war in the funds management industry. Andrew opines that offering investors exposure to portfolios of ASX listed shares with near-zero management fees is indeed a strategic move. However, he warns investors to remain cautious and to assess whether it's genuinely as good as it appears.
In addition, Andrew acknowledges Macquarie's intention to gain market share but also raises concerns about potential repercussions for the managed fund industry. Andrew suggests this could be another blow to the managed fund industry as burgeoning active managers must compete with the significantly low fee structure Macquarie's products boast. He further highlights some active managed fund players' tendency to present their products as ETFs to appear more appealing.
Finally, Andrew delves into the underperformance of active fund managers over the long term, citing a lack of consistency in beating the ASX, S&P 200 over a span of 10-15 years. He encourages investors to be wary of this trend while considering their investment choices. Andrew ends with a discussion on ways to gain exposure to European markets through various funds such as the Vanguard product VEC, the Betashares product, and one tracking the Euro Stoxx 50.
Below is the full unedited transcript of this interview:
0:00
Well. The ETF sector is growing at a fast pace, and number three is attempting to get a piece of that pie by offering investors exposure to a portfolio of 200 ASX listed shares, with management fees set close to zero. Macquarie's aggressive push into the sector could stoke a price war across the funds management industry. Let's get across this with our ETF whisperer Andrew Wielandt from DP Wealth Advisory. If you are the man to speak to because not only are you the ETF whisperer, you're also ex Macquarie, aren't you?
0:29
Yeah, sure. 20 years ago.
0:32
Yeah that's good enough. All right. What do you make of the move? Yeah. Um, it's an interesting one. Um, Andrew, it's, uh, it's, uh, passive fees for an active product. Uh, because if you look at sort of the cheapest, uh, passive products out there, they're charging somewhere between 3 and 4 basis points, so not quite nil, but, you know, pretty close to it. Uh, and if you look at your average active fund and this is a very, very, very long piece of string because there are literally hundreds of ETFs out there, but you'd think you're active ETF average one to be 3040, 50 basis points. So it's a very aggressive move by Macquarie. Three basis points for the Australian active strategy eight basis points for the global strategy. You can certainly see that. It really does seem to be a grab for market share from a macquarie point of view. So from an investor point of view, you know, the humble viewers and listeners of Aussies, you know, it should be something you should be paying attention to. But equally so Andrew, is it
1:32
as good as it seems. Oh well is it that's the question. And is it inevitably going to spark something of a, a more further competition there that the others are going to have to respond? Well, arguably depends on which lens you're looking at this. Um, Andrew, arguably, it's yet another nail in the coffin of the managed fund industry. Um, because, again, the active guys and girls are saying, look, you know, we can deliver alpha, we can deliver outperformance, but you've got to pay us 100 basis points or, you know, whatever the the average managed fund fees plus an app performance fee. And I might add, we should also stress that these Macquarie products also have performance fees as well. So it's not just that straight three basis or eight basis points. There's also a performance fee on top of that. But back to the managed fund guys and girls. Yeah look I mean we saw perpetual leavers a little bit earlier and there's a lot of consolidation occurring there. So there's pressure on them. And then on the ETF space it's going to create some pressure. But we
2:32
are finding a number of these active managed fund um sorry active managed fund players bringing their products and cloaking themselves in that ETF cloth cloth rubber. So I'm not so sure it's going to it'll if anything it'll be a positive for ETFs. But it's certainly a negative for uh for managed funds. But I guess probably Andrew. The other key takeaway with due respect to all of this is that we know that active fund managers and we I'm using the Spiva research from S&P. The long term underperformance over long term I'm talking 15 years is 77%. So 77% of active managers in Australia you try and beat the ASX, S&P 200 fail and it goes who have got that global um, look through the ones that are playing in that global space. That number is 94%. So guess what I'm saying is it's great for active managers, but the track record isn't there over 1015 years. All right okay. So be aware.
3:31
All right Andrew. So you do come to us normally with the three TFS. You've done it again today. Let's get into it. And Europe is the thematic here and particularly again today. Yeah. Well and if you you might have noticed a company like Novo Nordisk done reasonably well of late. So if you want to get a slice of that and perhaps other companies such as ASML and the like, how would you do it. Yeah. So Andrew, there's three ways you can play this. Uh, the first one is we're looking at the Vanguard product vec and it tracks the FTSE developed Europe index. It's Unhedged. And that's really important because if you look at like what the dollar did overnight, the Aussie dollar up 1% knocking on the door of $0.67. So if you're worried about the dollar then you need to think is an unhedged exposure the way to go? This is unhedged, but it gives you geographic exposure to Europe. Europe has been unloved. Andrew. Um, economic growth this year is only forecast to be about 0.7 of a percent relative to the US at 2.5%. But there's an expectation with rate cuts coming for Europe that
4:31
Europe might be the place to be. So certainly this vécu product might be one to think about 23% Europe, uh, Europe UK, 17% France and 16% Switzerland. And it's returned about 8% per annum over the last 12 months. All right. What if you want to go hedged with the focus on exporters. Yeah. Arguably hedged is maybe what you might want to start turning your mind to. So there's the Betashares product here. Um it's got. Less funds under management is only about 53 million. But again, hedged hasn't really been a place people have been thinking they should now start turning their mind to it again. Similar types of names um, ASML, LVMH, which of course you'd be familiar with of course Andrew and S&P uh, much heavier exposure to France. France is about 30%, Germany 28% and the Netherlands around 13%. And this one is returned around 12.5% over the last 12 months. Um, it has a high technology exposure relative to that Vanguard
5:31
product as well. Yeah. All right. And finally, uh, one that tracks the Euro Stoxx 50. What's it got? Yeah, it's it's done really well. $190 million funds under management again. Unhedged. But it tracks that Euro Stoxx 50, which is, you know, one of those larger exchanges or indexes to be following 40% France, uh, 25% Germany. And it's up nearly 20% for the year. So to me, if you're trying to sort of follow a broader index, this is probably one to think about, albeit Unhedged keep remembering the unhedged piece. If you're looking for the hedge piece, certainly that betashares product, but nothing wrong with the Vanguard one. If you're looking for Europe and thinking about mean reversion and you know those interest rates coming through into 2025 and Europe outperforming any one of these three should be considered as part of your portfolio.