Sign inJoin free

Watch / Reporting Season

The "whip effect" on small cap results

8 Aug 20247:10

The "whip effect" on small cap results

General information only. ausbiz videos are general information only, produced by Ausbiz TV Pty Ltd, a media business that doesn’t give financial advice. They don’t take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Consider whether it’s right for you and read the PDS and TMD before acting on anything you watch.

About this video

Luke Winchester, fromMerewether Capital,outlines recent small cap earnings.

Key points:

  • Early earnings results have produced some fascinating data, particularly in terms of how (AD8:ASX) has fared.

  • His analysis extends to the 'whip effect' on supply chains, a considerable factor in increased share value fluctuations

  • He discusses the challenging environment for sectors such as real estate, focusing on Charter Hall (ASX: CLW) and Mirvac (ASX: MGR) .

Full unedited transcript below:

0:00

What are the early earnings results telling us about the health of the economy? Luke Winchester from Merryweather Capital joins me now to discuss what investors are looking out for. I wanted to start with alternate, though, Luke, because one of our guests earlier in the week said, why would you come through with your preliminary numbers when you didn't have to on such a volatile day? And it certainly looks like alternate got smacked by releasing those even though they were okay?

0:22

Yeah. Hang on. Juliette. Um, although it was a real fascinating, fascinating case study. Um, obviously got those numbers out early. And I think, as you were reading down the announcement, if you're an alternate shareholder, um, FY 24 numbers look fantastic. I think a beat on everything. And, um, you would have been quite happy until you hit that FY 25 outlook and all of a sudden, you know, things weren't so rosy. And the charts are there. You can see the the huge impact to the share price. And I think when you have moves like that, it was a richly valued stock and you know, and get a big intraday move, it certainly grabs headlines. But what I wanted to touch on and to sort of this broader, um, segment, this theme is, you know, grabbing the updates from these companies, what are they seeing, what's happening and how can you apply it across a portfolio. So I thought, you know, let's dig a bit deeper into what actually happened here with ordinate. And could that potentially happen to other stocks that that people may own. And just people prepare themselves for reporting season. So you know, we thought today what's really happened is um, when when Covid hit and we had that initial chip shortage, um, they struggled as a

1:21

manufacturer to get product out, out the door. Um, now, of course, you've got a long supply chain. You've got to go through distributors, retailers through to your end customer. And there's a lot of parties in that chain that hold their own inventories. And, um, you know, it can be difficult to actually measure that in demand from the customer. So ordinate, you know, they get backlogged through that Covid period, then, uh, 2023 2024, some bumper results as they pick up all that, that demand. And there's a big pull forward of demand as well, because, you know, those those parties in the supply chains had wound down their inventory as well to support, you know, the end users where they could. So a big bring forward of demand. And you saw really strong FY 23, really strong FY 24. Of course that leaves a big hole in FY 25. And you know, when you look across this this supply chain, it's called the whip effect. You know, you crack the weapon and that, that that tip of the whip is a much higher impact than what you see at the front. That's really what's hit ordinate here. It's um, you know, and I think there'll be some criticism for, for ordinates management when you see, you know,

2:21

an intraday share move of 30, 35%. Um, but as I wrote in my notes, I'm quite forgiving. I think this whip effect for manufacturers is very difficult to see. Um, you know, very difficult to manage. I don't know, an alternate. Just to clarify, I suspect the underlying health of the business is probably not too bad, though. I'm not saying investors should be jumping in today. Um, but I wouldn't necessarily look at what's happened here in FY 25 as a structural decline in the business. I think this is a business that, you know, has to manage a difficult international manufacturing flow. And obviously, um, it has seen a bit of difficulty doing that. Um, so sorry. Last, last final point. So, so who can we look to as an example of okay, this, you know, being a global manufacturer can be hard. The first names that come to mind, Breville RB, you know, manufacturers that ship globally maybe don't have quite that visibility on their end. Customer. Um, you know, you hope management teams can manage their way through. But as we just saw with ordinate, it can be exceptionally difficult to do so. Again, I think this is a couple of names, um, that

3:21

you just maybe have have that extra bit of attention come this reporting season. What are they seeing? What are they saying? Yeah. All right. Well let's move to a different sector in the rates we had chart a whole long rate out today. It's been a very challenging time for this sector.

3:37

Yeah. Look I sent through my notes I noted Charter Hall and of course, you know the result looks okay. But the one thing you look to is their office segment, about 11% of their business, um, quite challenged. You've seen the capitalization rate shoot up and you spoke about it in the intro. I actually missed it. Mirvac out today as well. Um, it's primarily office, about two thirds office without big downgrade shares off 12%. So I sort of, you know, unfortunately, I haven't brought an example where people can look ahead. But, you know, this is sort of what I'm talking about. You can look at a peer like Charter Hall long Wale read the overall result looks okay, but within that result, what's doing well? What's doing poorly? Can we can we look at that? Can we, can we analyze that and maybe extrapolate it to appear? And as I sort of said in my notes, I think it was clear that office was the struggling segment here. The backwards looking numbers are okay, but it's that forward looking, of course, where the markets always focus. What are you seeing across the forward? Um, and I sort of said in my notes, you know, I think it's one to, to watch for the peers who are more exposed to office. And of course, here we are today. Mirvac out alongside Charter Hall long Wale

4:37

REIT much more exposed that office seeing that pain much more. So again you know how long this trend plays out I don't know, but I just think it's always interesting to sort of look through these results. What are the trends. What are management teams saying. And can we extrapolate that to other places. And sort of as investors prepare ourselves for what we might see in reporting season, what are we seeing in terms of the consumer and the health of the consumer, which is interesting, particularly in the wake of the last RBA meeting.

5:03

Yeah. Well of course interest rates really do drive this conversation, don't they? But um, as I said in my email to you guys, um, I always love credit Corp is one of the first companies to come out with their results. And it's such a consumer focused business. You know, they buy purchase debt ledgers from from banks, telcos, utilities, um, they also lend themselves directly to consumers. So I always find it's a really helpful result to get that first day of reporting season, to get that, that finger on the pulse straight away of what are we seeing? So when I looked at that, um, the general comments from Credit Corp management was, um, consumer lending was a bit weaker in the sense of, um, lower settlements. You know, they're lending less money than maybe what they expected. Maybe that's a sign that consumers starting at a bit tapped out and something to look for. Um, but when we look at at a reason and losses both within range. So, you know, again, as an investor, you start to say, okay, that's that's a nice data point from that sort of provider. Who can we extrapolate that to retailers. Consumer discretionary. Maybe there's a bit of legs in those sectors. Yet if we're still seeing

6:03

consumers relatively doing okay, um, you know money me wiser a couple of peers in that consumer lending space also sort of said they're seeing the same things. They haven't seen those impacts yet to, um, to to losses in arrears. Of course. Interestingly enough, Myer's also out today. Again, I missed this until, uh, after I sent the email through to you guys with the notes. Um, but Maya is out today with a bit of a weaker result, so it can sometimes be hard to sort of, you know, businesses will always have their individual effects, no doubt about that. But I always think it's really important as an investor as we go through reporting season, as you're getting trading updates and outlooks, you know, don't just look at what you own, look at, look at other stocks. Can you can you grab data points? Can you grab pieces of reports that maybe give you a bit of an insight into your portfolio companies or things that are on your watch list and you're interested in? So it's certainly what I'm doing through reporting season. I always love getting Credit Corp up front. The rates are always interesting as well. Um, you know, and of course, I think ordinate and ResMed was another example of a company that's had its issues as that global manufacturer now potentially coming out the other side of the good,

7:04

good result on Friday. So always see what you can grab from from these numbers and extrapolate across a portfolio to other names.

More like this

We value your privacy

We use essential cookies to make the site work. Non-essential cookies help us improve the experience. You can accept or reject non-essential cookies. Privacy policy