Sign inJoin free

Watch / Investment strategy

The three factors to consider when choosing an investment manager

28 Nov 20236:56

The three factors to consider when choosing an investment manager

General information only. ausbiz videos are general information only, produced by Ausbiz TV Pty Ltd, a media business that doesn’t give financial advice. They don’t take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Consider whether it’s right for you and read the PDS and TMD before acting on anything you watch.

About this video

Equity manager selection poses as many challenges as selecting equities for a portfolio, according to Jason Hall of Hamilton12.

A good relationship is key, but Jason explains that three metrics must be considered: fee minimisation, active share, and a solid track record. He cautions that while many companies are focused on reducing fees, this is not enough. Low fee managers often make too few active bets, consequently, the focus should be on increasing the amount of active share. This is the proportion of the portfolio that differs from the underlying index, a metric supported by research showing that investing in managers with low fees and above-average active share can lead to positive risk-adjusted returns.

However, Jason warns that identifying an outperforming manager on track record alone can be incredibly difficult. Rankings often change based on the style preference of the manager and whether their particular style is currently in vogue. Instead, Jason recommends focussing on recent performance relative to a risk-adjusted benchmark and understanding the method undertaken by the manager to accomplish high performance. For sustainable success, the manager should have a consistent and systematic investment strategy with above-average active share.

Ultimately, an investor’s individual financial goals ought to drive decisions, and Jason urges anyone selecting an equity manager to align with someone who both outperforms a benchmark and achieves their personal volatility preference. The key factors to consider include persistent performance relative to a risk-adjusted benchmark, moderate fees, and an above-average degree of active bets. This, coupled with a systematic investment strategy persistently implemented, may result in successful future performance.

- Relationship, fee minimisation, active share, and a solid track record are critical in hiring an equity manager.

- Identifying an outperforming manager based on track records alone can be tricky, approach should be nuanced, considering recent performance against a risk-adjusted benchmark.

- Decisions should be guided by personal financial goals, with a preference for managers who outperform benchmarks and align with individual volatility preference.

Find the full unedited transcript of this interview below:

0:00

Let's talk now about the process of selecting equity managers, which sometimes can be as challenges as selecting equities for your portfolio itself. Jason Hall from Hamilton12, joins me now to discuss the metrics worth paying attention to when choosing an equity manager. It's a bit like choosing anything. You've got to have that good relationship. What are you looking for here, Jason?

0:20

Well, when we're trying to choose an equity manager, whether that's someone running a managed fund or someone to run a separately managed account, we're getting given lots of signals now to focus on particular things. So, for example, regulators and the government is trying to say minimize fees and you get messages from index fund providers saying and diversify. But you can't really focus on just one thing because there's really three metrics that you need to have. Any chance of selecting an active manager that you think is going to, on a regular basis, earn abnormal returns related to the risk of that manager.

0:59

Those are fee minimisation,

1:02

active share

1:04

and and a track record.

1:07

Fee minimisation is obvious right? There's lots of literature showing that high fee managers, managers charging, you know, one, 2 or 3% expense ratios on average can't make enough active bets to outperform given their fees. But you can't just try to minimize fees. Unfortunately, lots of the messages that superannuation investors are getting is to say the only thing you should do is try to minimize fees.

1:36

But low fee managers generally keep their fees low by making very few actual active bets. So what you have to do is try to increase the amount of active share. Active share is the proportion of the portfolio which is actually different from the underlying index. And what the research shows is that if you invest in managers that have a combination of above average, average, active share and with low fees, at least you're in a reasonable chance of being able to achieve positive risk adjusted returns.

2:12

The third criteria you need is also go ahead. No, I was just going to say when you talk about looking at track records, how difficult can that be though? Because you're looking at different growth and value strategies as well.

2:25

All incredibly difficult. So if you try to rank managers just by track record, which is the third plank, you need to have any chance of identifying an outperforming manager. Often managers that end up in the top tier rankings on a short term basis. Um, there are growth manager or they're a value manager. And managers have these persistent style preferences. And their style just by chance happened to be in favour. So in the last year, had you been in big Tech in the US, in your global allocation of your portfolio, you would have done really well. But you can't bank on being in big in big tech, doing well all the time. Um, and so this style preference makes it very difficult if you just rank managers by recent performance. But if you look at both recent performance relative to a risk adjusted benchmark and ask how did the manager achieve that performance, it gives you some insight into whether performance is likely to be persistent.

3:25

So what you want to do is ask the manager, well, tell me, exactly what strategy did you invoke to achieve that positive risk adjusted return? It's a bit like asking a football coach. How did you achieve persistent track record in winning premierships? So you look at the system in place, the Brisbane Broncos or the Melbourne Storm, for example, these teams that have built their track record or Penrith in recent years, if they were able to achieve that outperformance via a systematic and persistent investment strategy with above average active share, you've got a good chance of that performance being persistent. Whereas if they say, well, you know, we gaze into our crystal ball and we, you know, had this great insight. But the way they got that insight was just kind of random from one end to the next. It suggests that there was a fair bit of luck on their side, and that their performance will revert to the mean. Hmm.

4:20

Jason, when it comes to choosing anything, no matter what it is, even if you are talking about a football coach, I mean, everybody's needs are different. How important is it to kind of go into these conversations with your own financial goals, rather than talking to a friend who says, look, this equity manager was good for me.

4:38

That that that's crucial. Right. So I talked to talk to my father, who was a self-managed retiree in his late 70s. And despite the fact that he has substantial amount of wealth to fund his income in retirement more than he needs, he asks a very persistent question, which is very common among self-funded retirees.

4:59

Do I have enough? And of course, he does have enough. But if he observed lots of volatility in the equity market, he gets nervous about it, despite the fact that even with a substantial correction, he would feel very uncomfortable with a very high equity allocation in his portfolio. Whereas other people, younger people and people with a high degree of risk tolerance, if there was a substantial correction in equity markets or bond markets or property markets, they have the ability to recover from that by saving more over their lifetime earnings. So aligning people's risk preferences and tax preferences is crucial to make sure that every night when they go to sleep, they're with an equity manager who is both outperforming relative to a benchmark but also achieving their volatility preference.

5:50

All right. So of course preferences as you talked about now you were talking about some of the key factors. And I think I cut you off on the third just to remind us what it is.

5:59

What we need are persistent performance relative to a risk adjusted benchmark, and by that we mean a benchmark that can be replicated just by buying index funds, because that's our default position. That's our low cost rule. Diversified portfolio. Secondly, we need moderate fees. If the fees are certainly above 2% and in most cases above 1%, it's very difficult for active bets to overcome those high fees with high performance. And we need an above average degree of active bets in order to be any reasonable chance of that performance persisting in the future. And underpinning all of that is the idea of whether the investment managers strategy does seem to be something which is systematic, that the implementing day after day, week after week, as opposed to observing something shiny, which is going to lead to short term outperformance but inevitably mean reversion.

More like this

We value your privacy

We use essential cookies to make the site work. Non-essential cookies help us improve the experience. You can accept or reject non-essential cookies. Privacy policy