The real debate: Marcus vs Henry
The real debate: Marcus vs Henry
About this video
Key points:
Interest rate predictions: Marcus foresees a drop to 1%, while Henry anticipates rates between 3.5%-4%.
Bank stocks' performance driven by passive fund investments and high yields.
Resource sector needs significant changes in commodity prices for improvement.
Marcus Padley from Marcus Today predicts that interest rates will drop back to 1%, citing historical trends and deflationary pressures. He believes the market has overestimated inflation risks and sees rapid rate cuts in the near future. However, Henry Jennings disagrees, suggesting that such low rates would indicate significant economic issues.
Henry argues that interest rates should stabilise between 3.5% and 4% and doesn't foresee them dropping to 1%. He believes if rates fall that low, it would signal major problems, but he acknowledges the current landscape where robust bank performance is driven by high yields and limited risk options.
Both Marcus and Henry analyse the impact of these potential rate changes on various sectors, including banks and resources. Henry highlights that the stability and performance in the banking sector are partly fuelled by passive funds investing in large-cap stocks like the 'Big Four' Australian banks. However, they note that substantial improvement in the resource sector requires significant changes in commodity prices, likely driven by China's economic actions.
Full unedited transcript:
0:00
I have a treat for you.
0:01
Coming to you live from our studios here at Barangaroo. I believe for the first time as a double act, we have Marcus Padley and Henry Jennings joining me from Marcus today. Marcus. Welcome, Henry. Welcome. This is the great debate. Of course. Okay. So today, isn't it? Everyone's talking about it. Yep. The debate today. This is this is the entree. Let's call it to the great debate in the United States. Because I dare say, look, I don't know, maybe you guys do see the world through the same eyes, but I'm going to try to find out where your opinions may differ. If, you know, we've got we've got an obvious one there. Okay. Start one one of my office. And,
0:42
uh, Henry doesn't agree with this, but, uh, I have this theory that interest rates going back to 1% and going fairly rapidly as well. Uh, and, uh, it's based on the idea that we have seen a 40 year trend towards lower interest rates. And you can read and I went looking for why is that happened. And there are all sorts of academic papers and it's to do with access to the US bond market, globalization, Asian wealth, uh, being able to access the US bond market. It's to do with things like the GFC and risk aversion. It's to do with an ageing population, which the boomer, uh, wave is running through. And as we all get older, we get more risk averse, more likely to be in bonds. And bond yields have dropped. Plus, of course, a change in policy from Volcker all the way back in the 80s and 70s, uh, changing policy to get ahead of inflation. So we've had this big, long trend. And if you put it up on the chart, you'll see. And then
1:42
Covid happens and bang, interest rates go from 1% to 5%. And we are. And that every central bank thought was transitory. But they got it wrong. So in January 2022, they all woke up and went, hang on, this could get ingrained. We'd better raise interest rates. And. But we are now on top of that bump and we've got a deflationary or disinflationary pressures going on. There is. I read an article today suggesting that inflation in the US is going to under hit the Fed's target fairly quickly. So I think interest rates have peaked.
2:17
Uh, they have uh, inflation is going to come down more rapidly than expected. And if making money out of the market is about getting things or picking things that the markets got wrong, I think the market's got interest rates wrong. I think they're going to come down more rapidly than everyone expects. But then, okay, I'm not going to debate right now. Ask Henry. Well, yeah. Because I mean that would mean that things are going really, really, really poorly. Um, particularly we can see you consider historically where the sort of neutral rate has landed. Um, so, Henry, um, interest rates at 1%. Well, I think you're right, Nadine. If interest rates do go to 1%, something has gone kind of horribly wrong. You know, we saw very low interest rates after the GFC for a decade. And then we saw the central banks start to ease them back up before Covid hit. And then we got the big cuts and now they push them back up with the inflation. But if you look sort of long term for three and a half,
3:16
4% is kind of where it should kind of be maybe a little bit either side of that. But you know, realistically, if we got to 1%, something has gone awry. And if and if you believe, as Marcus does, for instance, that interest rates will go to 1% and the world is a happy place still because we've got no inflation. Um, we need a little bit of inflation, by the way. Um, then you should be just buying everything with your ears pinned back because they were back to Tina again. You know, there is no alternative. For the last few years, we have had a viable alternative. You can get four and a half, 5% in deposit accounts, retirees and self-managed super fund people and people living off interest rates are out. They're booking Carnival cruises like it's no tomorrow. They're out there on celebrity. They're going nuts because suddenly they've gone from 0 to 4 and a half, 5% with little risk as well. So I just see, you know,
4:16
interest rates are peaked. They're coming down. I don't think the RBA will raise rates. I think they're just talking the lock a lock. Um, and I think that is Michelle Bullock talking tough. We've got Sarah Hunter speaking today which will be interesting. She's a smart woman. Um, I think the RBA will keep things on hold for longer. I think the fed will cut 25 basis points and then talk about further cuts. I think the Chinese will cut their interest rates pretty much straight afterwards. But the neutral rate, I think is not 1%. I don't think that's happening. I don't think I'll see 1% in my working career, which may be foreshortened like this. I disagree with Marcus. Be careful what you wish for. But, but but it's. It is an interesting thought. And you won't, you won't. You won't get clicks by saying it's going to 3.5% or 2.5%. So it's deliberately sensational. But it would be interesting. And and it's already playing out because the right sector is going nuts. The bank sector, all, all
5:16
high yielding stocks will go to a premium if the risk free rate is that low and money's already pouring into it, and now you've got inflation coming off very rapidly, we could get there. Well, but
5:29
what will 1% do to the net interest margins on the banks. Oh it'll it'll decimate them. Know on the way down they'll be be able to do what they're already doing, which is dropping, uh, holding up variable rates and dropping term deposit rates. It widens their margins when rates are on the moon
5:48
anyway. Yeah. Okay. I think that you can see these guys are on, um, you know, opposite ends of the spectrum when it comes to Marcus is sensational healthy internal rates to. Well, I think that's probably reassuring for investors because these things need robust debate. Correct. Um, but but on the banks, like why are the banks doing so well? Why are they so expensive. It's I reckon someone's going to write an academic paper about why the banks have been doing so well. Uh, and I'm sure it's not as simple as it seems, but they are doing well because I think resources are doing terribly. And Australians are also, uh, very happy with the yields on banks relative to the rest of the market for the amount of risk they have to take. And I think there is this argument, and this is probably where the academic paper comes in, about just how much buying passive funds are doing when somebody buys an exchange traded fund over Australia and is naturally going into the bigger
6:48
stocks. And if you think about it, the bigger weightings they get, the more buying comes in. They're buying more. And it's sort of a bit of a self-fulfilling thing on passive funds. Maybe that's why they're doing so well. All I can say is I wouldn't be buying them. They look expensive, and I think there will be some moment where they come off. And I think what will kill them is a significant drop in the market. Might sound silly, but the biggest risk they've got is that the market starts to go down and everybody goes, right, that's the top. And the the passive fund money starts coming out and it comes out of them more than it in the same way. A lot of it comes out. That's that's my humble theory, Henry. Um, I think this goes back to Tina. I like Tina, there is no alternative. And that is the problem. There is, as Marcus says, resources have been troubled. We know that, um, banks are a oasis in a desert and people are gravitating towards them. They are kind of
7:47
Rolexes in some respects, and I've talked about this before. CBA is a Rolex stock because it's just expensive and it always will be. Um, but
7:56
the problem is there's no natural sellers of banks. It used to be that the Americans and the international hedge funds would smack the banks, because it was a proxy for Australian housing. That hasn't really worked. Australian housing just keeps going up and up and up and up. So that's taken them out. The retail guys well they're not going to sell them because they've dyed in the wool. They've had the banks forever. They've got nice big yields nice big dividends. They're safest houses. They're a machine you know 35 to $40 billion in cash profits out of the four banks. And don't even you know Macquarie is now knocking on the door. It's not the Fab Four, it's the Famous Five. So, um, there's no natural sellers. The buyers continue from the passive funds. The bigger they get, the more money comes in. The bigger they get, the more money comes in. They are the market. You know, the four banks are 30% of the market now. And if you don't want to buy BHP, where else do you go? That's that's the problem. And you know you've got your Wesfarmers, Woolies and Coles, no GMG which have performed terribly well, which have performed
8:56
terribly. Um, it's it's it's just because there is no alternative and it just and you know, we've seen this the market is dumb. You know Trump media. How dumb is that? You know really. Oh, we are veering into territory. Let's get it back to stocks because there's so much in what you guys have just been speaking of. But I'd like to get your view on where this market is headed then. And I think that, you know, it would take if if it would take a big, you know, market selloff to get money to come out of the banks. Do you foresee some sort of a big market selloff coming? Uh, no, I don't think you can say that. We, uh, and and one of the mistakes in Australia is to look at the ASX 200 index of the All Ordinaries index and use that as your base point. The media bringing it up every day. They should have two indices, which is the resources, the banks and everything else. The banks are currently on their all time highs. The resources are on their year low. You have to look at them
9:56
separately. So, uh, to put them in an average and say the whole market's going to fall over is probably wrong. What we want to talk about probably, is whether the banks are going to fall over and whether there's going to be some precipitous fall in the US. I just don't don't see it at all. And important to say to people who hold the banks, who've got capital gains tax issues, even if they haven't, a lot of retirees are holding them for income. And if these stocks are going to go till the end of can you believe? Don't let us interrupt your day, Marcus. And if if these stocks are going to go until they hand them on to their kids when they retire, then why would you bother caring about trying to sell them to buy them back cheaper? So, you know, there's a 1,015% gap maybe between where they bottom out next. It's just not worth some people train so I don't see anything precipitous. And as we've done in our strategy portfolio, you have to take every stock, uh, every sector on its own. So you trade resources, you trade banks, pick the tops and
10:56
bottoms, you trade the US big tech picks the top pick the tops and bottoms to talk about the whole market I think is, uh, just wrong in Australia. Um, well, especially when you know that we're dominated by the banks and the miners. Um, so on the resources, we're just showing today's stock prices for some of those companies. Um, what like when do they bottom
11:18
when they bottom. Okay. Might sound silly, but I've had I've had, um, email exchanges with members who write to me and say I'm optimistic about uranium. Um, you know, you can't be, uh, the correlation between resources and their underlying commodity prices very, very close. And the research is absolutely no use to you because it's based on the past. And the only thing that is going to drive the future is what commodity prices do. If you can get that right, you'll get it right. So what you look for now, because there is an opportunity and resources, what you look for now is a material bottoming in prices, particular commodity prices, all commodity prices for a solid reason rather than a one day blip. So you don't buy into oversold rallies. You buy into something material happening that's going to change commodity prices for more than a day. And that would be something to do with the Chinese economy, presumably. Yeah. And it's just not happening.
12:18
I just saw that flashed up with those. But you saw that as well, didn't you? Mineral resources 12.5% higher. Well, because I know there would be some calling the bottom in minerals. Uh, actually, last night we had a few drinks in the city, and I was saying to someone last night that minarets just looks like an absolute sitter at 30 bucks. The reason, of course, why it's rallied so hard today is cost cutting measures. They've messed around with some rosters. I think there's going to be some pretty unhappy mineral resource people in the lithium space. Two weeks on, two weeks off is now two weeks on, one week off. That is going to be that's that's not much fun. So, um, there will be a bottom in resources. And as Marcus says, it will require the, the, um, commodities to start to improve. And that will require China to pull their finger out and actually do something, because at the moment it's such an easy trade as well. You know, these international hedge funds, it's such an easy trade. Whack the resources
13:18
because China is in a hole and we're going to war, you know, 2.0 Cold War with China. And it's going to get worse after the election. In terms of tariffs, China is in a massive hole. And as a result, why not just keep pummelling the resource stocks. It's easy. And we've got, you know, we've got the biggest mining company in the world, BHP. It's such an easy target traded all over the world. It's liquid. It's you know what can possibly go wrong. It's also fabulous because we're going to make a fortune in a short period of time when it bottoms, when it bottoms for a material reason, not when it bottoms for a day. But there is a fantastic opportunity coming up. It's quite exciting. But when's it happen? Well, needs something needs to happen. Until now, I wouldn't, I wouldn't I know Henry does, but I wouldn't touch resources till, until something material happens. And then we will make. The only times you can make accelerated gains is when things have got really oversold. You look at the shorting list. It's all resources at the moment. So there's and what you know
14:18
about any stock on the shorting list is if there's a reason to buy it, it moves really quickly. And we wait that moment. But it's it's not today. Yeah. To your point about Mineral Resources, it was aftermarket clothes not to tell about 630, I think here in Sydney that it announced those cost cutting measures. Um, do you think, though, just to get stock specific for a second, that it is still too soon for mineral resources because of that pile of debt, that it still might be a 2026 story if you put Marcus is something fundamental has to change with lithium and iron ore. I reckon at 30 bucks mineral Resources an absolute screaming by Henry. You can't say that until the whole complex times. I can't say that I said it was a screaming buy at $0.39 is now $2.30.
15:05
That's our job is to say that. Yes, but we need we need something to change on lithium sentiment to make that happen. We need them to sell the Onslow Haulage Road, which they have done to Morgan Stanley. So that's good. That will get that debt down. Uh, the cost cutting measures they've announced is good as well. That will get that debt down. And Chris Ellison is not an idiot.
15:28
He will sort this out. Um, the debt is high, but, you know, it's still an iron ore business in the mining services business. If the lithium goes on care and maintenance and they basically make provisions for that and sell this haulage road, which they have done, as long as the trucks don't keep falling over, which is a bit of a problem. But, you know, I think at 30 bucks you'll look back on this in a year or two's time and go, you know what?
15:52
That was the buy. All right. I will agree with you the moment it goes up a couple of bucks, it's gone up four bucks today.
16:00
Ten bucks,
16:03
which we talked about it last night at 30 bucks I won't buy until there's a substantial change in the overall sector sentiment, I think. And that's still and that's China still missing. That's China primarily. Okay. Um, when let's just check in on the local market just to see how we're tracking. We're 20 minutes into this session. These guys, they don't have all day to give us. But what. Yeah we do.
16:26
We're actually realized we're early for lunch. We're having a 1980s throwback. We're looking for a bottle of Shiraz, but not at 11:00. Yeah, right. Oh, boy. Those were the days, I'm sure. I don't think I lived through them myself. Um, but. Yeah. Look, the local market 20 minutes into this session, down by about a 10th of a percent. Yeah. We are keeping our eye on the banks. We saw a lot of selling in the banks in the United States. We're keeping our eye on the resources space, as per usual. But you know, the energy stocks, the energy stocks, the sector as a whole is off by close to 7% with that price of Brent crude off. Yeah. To levels that haven't seen in years down below 70. Do well yes. Yes it did time that time that brilliantly. Yeah I kept their discipline. They didn't buy into the lithium story and they flogged off the oil and gas business to Woodside. Nailed it. Mike Henry nailed it. Great. Um, look, just for a
17:26
general, uh, where you are seeing opportunities in the market kind of chat. So if it's not banks, if it's not resources. Henry, where is it? Uh, we've talked about this before, and Marcus has got one one stock that he likes. Um, data centers. I got to say, this is the gift that keeps on giving, isn't it? Next DC. They raised $1.3 billion five months ago, and they've raised another $750 million today. That's 2 billion in size. Five months to build data centers. Um, no wonder brokers love it. The fees are fantastic and everyone's got a much higher price target on it. And it's obviously a growing area. I've talked before on USBs about some of the peripheral companies. The Southern Cross Engineering SCS is an