The Influence of Franking Credits
About this video
Richard McDougall from Hamilton12 joins us for a detailed discussion about the effects of franking credits on equity income funds, and emphasises the impact they have on portfolio returns. He explains how the performance of active managers assessed by S&P Indices versus Active (SPIVA) reports shows most of them are underperforming most of the time. Furthermore, the underperformance tends to increase with extended observation periods.
Richard stresses the importance of investigations into the performance of active managers with an overlay of funds that focus on imputation benefits. Richard mentions that when these dividends are fully or partially franked, the company collects 30%.
Richard underscores the importance of maximising exposure to companies that pay franked dividends for investors. He demonstrates that ordinary shares paying high frank dividends are not any more expensive than stocks paying unfranked or zero dividends. Therefore, investors essentially receive the franking credits for free. Furthermore, investing in high-yield stocks over the long term, particularly those that maximise exposure to frank dividends, can generate significantly better returns for investors in entities with low tax rates.
Find the full unedited transcript of this interview below:
0:00
An abundance of dividend paying stocks here in Australia. What are the effects of franking credits on equity income funds and can they contribute to portfolio returns? Richard McDougall from Hamilton12, joins me now to get into some interesting research on this phenomenon. So what are the effects of franking franking credits. Excuse me on equity income funds.
0:21
Juliet. Good morning. Yeah. Look a great place to start actually, as it relates to this research is just by way of reminder around the Spiva reports. And so Spiva is an acronym for Standard and Poor's Index versus active. And those are a series of reports that Standard and Poor's produce every six months that show or measure the performance of active managers relative to the appropriate benchmark. And they do that across a number of geographic locations and listed asset classes. Typically, those reports will show in the first year, somewhere between 50 and 70% of managers are underperforming the relevant benchmark. Then, as you go out to sort of 3 to 5 and ten years, somewhere between 70 and 90% of managers are underperforming the relevant benchmark. So those reports are showing most active managers are underperforming most of the time. More managers will typically underperform as that observation period lengthens. And when good performance does occur, it tends not to persist. Now, there are a
1:21
number of conceptual and mathematical reasons as to why that occurs time and time again. And we won't go in that today. But what I thought we would do is have a deep dive into the data that S&P sourced from Morningstar as it relates to the performance of active managers, and then run that with an overlay of funds that are focusing on the benefit of imputation and what that means for investors. All right. So just tell us what that does mean. We've got a little bit of a chart up there about some of the percentage of Australian funds. Just talk us through what that chart means. And of course what it means for investors. Yeah. So so so S&P are collating this data from Morningstar across a number of different managed funds and ETFs for the relevant reporting period. And that performance reporting to Morningstar is calculated on a total returns basis after fees. So what that means is they're including the price movement and the reinvestment of distributions. Now, what it doesn't include are the
2:21
benefits from the refund of excess franking credits. So just by way of reminder, and the best way to think about how franking credits work is think that when a company pays a dividend, the company's already pre collected the tax that's applicable at the investor's personal tax rate. So when the investor receives the dividends from profits derived in Australia, those dividends become fully or partially franked. And so the companies already collected that 30%. And in some instances that's either too much or not enough. So for example, if you're a superannuation investor in pension phase or not profit, or a charity that enjoys a 0% tax environment, you actually receive that 30% back as a cash payment when you lodge your tax return with the ATO at the end of the year. Similarly, if you're a superannuation phase in accumulation, a superannuation fund in accumulation phase income's taxed at 15%, the company's already collected 30.
3:20
Thanks very much, ATO. You'll receive a 15% cash back in the form of imputation credits when you lodge your tax return. Now, something interesting is going on here that warrants further investigation. That graphic that was up a moment ago. We compiled the returns for Australian Equity General Funds, whose strategy is to focus on the benefits of franking credits and compare those returns to the appropriate S&P ASX 200 benchmark. So what I mean by the appropriate benchmark is also the benchmark that includes the benefit of excess franking credits and typically funds that are focusing on excess franking credits or Australian equity income funds who are somewhat focusing on after tax returns. Now, the green bars in that chart show you the results from the Spiva reports, which are typically what I mentioned earlier, 50 to 70% in the first year and then sort of 70 to 90 in years three, five and ten. When you include the performance of funds that are focusing on the
4:20
imputation credits, fewer funds were actually beaten by the equivalent benchmark. Or in other words, more funds outperformed the equivalent S&P ASX 200. And in fact, when you go to ten years, there weren't any funds that were beaten by the relevant benchmark. So it's quite interesting to see what's actually happening from an after tax perspective. Well, Richard, just talk about the importance then of maximizing exposure then to companies that do pay frank dividends.
4:50
Yeah. And so investors need to consider this. There's a couple of things happening, which is why we think these funds are outperforming the equivalent benchmark the first. Reason is there's there's recent empirical, peer reviewed research that shows ordinary shares paying high frank dividends and no more expensive than stocks paying an franked or zero dividend. So essentially, investors are receiving the franking credits for free because the benefit is not built into the share price. Important to point out that's with ordinary shares and not within hybrid securities. If you've got a manager, an investment manager that has a strategy that takes advantage of that tailwind or that free kick, the data shows, as we've just seen, that it's likely they're going to outperform the market on an after tax basis. The second reason that suggests why this might be the case is because, again, research has shown that over the longer term, holding a portfolio of high yield
5:49
stocks generated an annual return of 11.9%. And when you compare that to the broader market, it returned 9.6%. So that's a premium or represents of about 2.3% return over the broader market. Now, imputation credits matter in this instance that 2.3%, the tax benefit of imputation credits
6:12
contributed more than half about 1.2% of the 2.3% outperformance, and the remaining 1% was attributed to a pure yield premium. So. So in light of this information, investors should seriously consider and obviously seek advice where required. But while staying appropriately diversified, investors should consider maximizing exposure to companies paying frank dividends when they're investing in entities with low tax rates that benefit from the excess franking credits or the imputation. So that includes super funds either in accumulation or pension phase foundations, charities not for profits, and perhaps some trust structures that would benefit. However again, seek advice. What that will do it increases the likelihood that investors will receive returns better than the market and better than most active Australian equity general managers. As we've just seen from the data that was shown on the screen earlier.