The implications of companies taking a political stand
About this video
Australian workplaces have seen two large-scale political issues, each carrying significant emotional implications for many employees play out in recent weeks being the Voice referendum and the Israel-Hamas war. With many employers wanting to take a stand on these issues, Joydeep Hor from People and Culture Strategies discusses the implications of corporates weighing into political issues.
He highlights the obstacles business leaders encounter when navigating political controversies and identifies two key topics having profound emotional effects on staff members: voice referendums and the conflict between Israel and Hamas. He says there are repercussions of social media activities of potential employees, such as job offers being rescinded. Joydeep notes a change in the climate, reflecting how workers now expect their companies to voice their opinions on societal, financial, and global political topics. He warns that this rising trend is not solely driven by employers but also stems from evolving workforce expectations and social standards. Additionally, Joydeep suggests employers remain vigilant against heightened disengagement and potential contention within their teams. He underscores the necessity of upholding impartiality while warning companies of potential legal and divisive outcomes that can disrupt their work environments.
Below is an unedited transcript of the interview:
All right. Now Australian workplaces, they've seen two large scale political issues recently. It's carrying significant emotional implications for many employees play out in recent weeks with the voice referendum, of course. And more immediately the Israel-hamas war. Well, with many employers wanting to take a stand on these issues, Joydeep Hor from People and Culture Strategies joined us to discuss the implications of corporates weighing in to political issues, the very big challenge for society and an even bigger challenge, some might say, for employers. And as it's playing out in in workplaces, this particular issue in terms of the conflict in the Middle East at the moment, while it's not something that is, is new in some senses, but but certainly the level of discussion, debate, the polarization of people's views, the strength of opinions and emotion held by people on a global scale is really proving to be quite
0:59
problematic and challenging for employers. I mean, I've just come back from speaking at a conference in, in the US, where there have been some extraordinary cases reported in the last few weeks where candidates for roles, in particular firms have had offers withdrawn because their prospective employers have been made aware of particular posts that have been shared by particular individuals. Those candidates who had received offers a very high profile example of a law firm who withdrew an offer to to someone who had posted a pro-Palestinian post on her social, one of her social media pages, and had her offer of employment withdrawn as a result of that. This is just one example of the tensions and challenges that employers are having to deal with now, in an Australian context, of course, we're seeing this play out, perhaps not so much as it might be in other countries, but but certainly it's live here. But we've had our own issue, as you say, in relation to the voice, where
1:58
it was, it was challenging. There were a lot of executives in organisations, a lot of organisations as a whole who came out there and were very open about supporting a position in relation to something like this. Now, whether that might be a popularly held view within their organisation or not, I think it's fairly safe to assume that not everyone in your organisation is going to align on all issues of geopolitical or social or economic significance in your country at any point in time. Chris Uhlmann, Is it fair to say employers, corporations are more involved in political issues now? Of course, more recently, with the referendum on the Voice, many corporates taking a stand on that particular issue. Previous to that, of course, the issue of same sex marriage.
2:47
Absolutely. And I think what's interesting, and something that was discussed in this conference at some length, was, is that something that employers are just choosing to do, or is that something that is actually now expected of employers? Because employees and certainly the new generation of employees, without necessarily putting a label on on which generation it might be. But but certainly those who may be entering the workforce in the last 5 to 10 years have a different expectation of what the employment relationship is about. They have different expectations of what their employers will stand for, if they sense that their employers are not standing for anything or are not taking a stance on a particular issue, then there's plenty of literature and plenty of anecdotal data that says that employees will disengage from that employer more quickly than might otherwise be the case. So
3:47
this is something that I don't think is driven actually by employers wanting to do this. This is something that I see being almost imposed on employers as a result of changing expectations that employees have. And if you play this out, and if we're already at this point and social media is no doubt played a part in it, but as have as has the pandemic and as has shifting expectations on a whole range of fronts, this is going to get worse. This this challenge for employers is not going to get any easier. And there are arguably going to be more and more situations and circumstances where an employer is expected to have a position, articulate a position and then is going to be judged by its workforce, potentially, as to whether it's true to that position in terms of its actions. Well, not just judged by the workforce. I mean, there are the employees to consider, but also for many corporates, customers and shareholders, it's unlikely that all are going to agree.
4:44
That's exactly right. And these are, of course, if these were issues about which there was there were no controversies or there were no differences of opinion, and it's not a problem for an employer to adopt a position. I mean, arguably that would be something that would be mandated for the employer. Or or a no brainer, to use the vernacular. But we're talking about issues that, by definition, are controversial in a US context. You know, they've dealt with Black Lives Matter. They've dealt with the the recent issue of of abortion and the Supreme Court rulings here. We've had the voice. There's globally the the Middle East challenge. There's going to be more and more things. There's there's carbon emissions. There's all sorts of things. And employers are now having to resource up in terms of how they brand themselves in relation to these particular areas over and above, just trying to pay their power bills, no doubt in terms of challenging economic times. Jordan, there has been criticism of those corporates that certainly
5:44
got involved in the voice debate.
5:48
Is it your expectation, perhaps, that some of those corporates will now pull back and become apolitical, if you like? Look, I understand why employers feel that that is the right thing to do. And I think they are being somewhat opportunistic in some respects to to try to garner more favour from segments of their workforce by doing exactly what a number of corporations did. Look, my my personal view in relation to this matter is that employers should ideally steer clear of stating a position in relation to issues that are divisive,
6:24
unless that particular issue goes to the core of what that employer does operationally. Now, if it's an issue that might be of social and political relevance, but really has nothing to do with the core operating premise or functions of an employer, then I would really challenge that employer as to why are you going there now if you do so, and ultimately it's their business and their calls to make, then you need to understand that there will be consequences, there will be legal consequences, and there will certainly be polarising consequences within your workforce. And you will see conflict and you will see greater claims of bullying and harassment and vilification that will be made. And you, as an employer, will lose your ability to say that we have maintained neutrality and impartiality and we've been able to investigate these matters, and we are actually true to our beliefs about genuine inclusion and diversity and the respect of everyone's opinions. Without an employee having to feel, well,
7:23
I can't say or feel this way because my employer has come out there with a very strong statement to the contrary. This is the kind of question that I would be posing for employers, and I'd be asking them to think very carefully about whether they, some of them do what they've done over the last few weeks and months.