"The devil's in the details..."
About this video
Jeff Yew, CEO of Monochrome Asset Management, explains the crucial differences between direct and indirect Bitcoin ETFs (Exchange-Traded Funds) and their implications for investors. Jeff states there are three Bitcoin ETFs currently listed in Australia, one of which falls under the retail crypto asset license and aims to hold Bitcoin directly. He compares this with physical gold-backed ETFs. However, he also highlights the existence of indirect Bitcoin ETFs, which do not hold Bitcoin directly, rather having shares in other financial instruments exposed to Bitcoin.
Sharing his perspective, Jeff underscores that investors need to understand these distinctions. A direct ETF, similar to those seen in the US, involves Bitcoin held directly under a licensing framework established after robust interaction between regulators and industry. In contrast, indirect ETFs marketed like crypto asset ETFs do not undergo the same process, leading to a potential misalignment between regulatory positions and market representations.
Jeff cautions that investors not choosing the correct structure could wake up to costly mistakes. He believes investors have a right to clarity on the types of Bitcoin ETFs available. He advises that investors should carefully read product disclosure statements and check the issuer's license on the ASIC portal. He also anticipates future regulatory changes and suggests that Australia should align with global practices on transparency and investor protection in Bitcoin ETFs.
Full unedited transcript below:
0:00
Let's turn to digital assets and dig a little deeper into some of these Bitcoin ETFs. I'm not sure if you sort of have given it a lot of thought. What's the difference between direct and indirect and how do you make, you know, informed decisions if that's what you're looking to add to your portfolio? Well, Jeff Hue, CEO of Monochrome Asset Management, joins me now in studio to discuss. Hey, welcome. Nice to see you in person. Thanks for coming in. Sure. Nice to meet you too. Okay. So, um, I don't know if a lot of people would know the difference between direct and indirect Bitcoin ETFs. Maybe we can start with just setting the scene. What's a direct Bitcoin ETF. Yeah. So Australia has a crypto asset retail licensing framework called Crypto Assets that was introduced in October of 2021. Um so far there's like there's three Bitcoin ETFs listed in the country. Only one of those ETFs are licensed under that retail crypto asset license. But what does it mean
0:59
for investors. Is that a ETF that intends to hold Bitcoin directly. It means the ETF holds Bitcoin needs to apply for the license or the license cover's very critical investor protection mechanism around custody benchmarking experience and digital assets. And these are standards that are set by the regulator in 2021 through a six months consultation prior to that. Okay. So just to pause for a second so you can think of this. We often talk about physical gold back ETF. So this is the equivalent in Bitcoin. Yes. Actual Bitcoin holding. Yeah. That's right. So um and also in opposite side of things there are also Bitcoin ETFs that are structured through an interposed structure. What does it mean is that the ETF does not hold Bitcoin directly. It holds shares in another financial instruments that has exposure to bitcoin. So that's what we call the indirect bitcoin ETFs. So only one Bitcoin ETF in Australia that's currently listed is directly held in that. In that definition where
1:59
it's licensed under this crypto asset retail licensing. That is the monochrome Bitcoin ETF which is under the ticker Ibtc. Okay. So we're talking your book a little bit but that's okay. So what is what's the benefit of of being invested in a direct Bitcoin ETF. Sure. That's a very good question. And it's an important one for investors to make a distinction. A direct ETF is like the ones in the US where you've seen the ETF holds. It holds the Bitcoin directly under a licensing framework that was established through robust, um, participation of, you know, the regulators and the industry. Indirect ETF in Australia do not need to go through a process. It's categorized as a managed fund. Some of them manage funds offshore equities product. But they are marketed like a crypto asset ETF. So the regulatory position is not correct from what they're actually marketing themselves is that's where the retail investors need to worry about. Because if you don't if you're not investing in the right kind of structure, retail investors might wake up one day and realize a very costly
2:59
mistakes where, you know, the devil's in the details of this PDS in these structures. Yeah. Because, um, what you're saying is it's not so easy to just follow the price of Bitcoin and think, oh, my ETF is going to go along with the price of Bitcoin because you'll have those other exposures in that indirect ETF, correct? Yes. The indirect ETFs they are there's nothing wrong with indirect ETFs from a product perspective. Right. They are feeder funds that are very established in a traditional space for a long time. But when a issuer intentionally bypasses a regulation that's in place for the ETF directly to build an integral structure, you might ask yourself, why are they doing that? Why are they not following a rule that was set by the regulator that's set by Australia? It puts us in a very awkward position, where Australia is the only outlier country where all the Bitcoin ETFs listed in the country are structured differently. It's very confusing as an investor to try to dissect these products. Whereas if you look in the US, look in Canada, look in Hong Kong, all
3:58
the Bitcoin ETFs hold Bitcoin directly. And it's very easy for investors to go and compare the products, compare the prices compared to custodians. But Australian investors still has some way to go to get that clarity. Why is that? Why? Why do we have a different system? Why aren't they all regulated, you know, and and take place under an AFL etc.? Well, the distinction really comes down to what their regulatory position they are pushing through to the regulator and what their position is when they're pushing it to the market. From the regulated, regulated side, you get away from direct holding by using an internal structure, a wholesale retail feeder or a retail offshore feeder, for example. And these are from a regulator's point of view. Their argument is that is, is it an equity product? This is not a crypto asset product. So it's a much lighter pathway to market to get to market for these products. It's cheaper products to operate and more oftenly, you know, it's it's putting investors at risk by not properly disclosing these things up
4:58
front in marketing is. So hidden. It's all there in the PDFs. But retail investors needs the right to know. These are the different types of Bitcoin ETF ETFs out there in the market right now okay. Do you anticipate that there will be big regulatory changes coming. Or is this the regime that we've got here in Australia. And it's likely to stay that way. I think it's likely to remain for as is for now, just because of the awkward position where we're sitting in the election cycle. Um, there are there are possibilities that these things may change down the line. And that's something that investors need to worry about because you're, you're you're investing in a product that might have regulatory restructuring in the future because it's offered under a, you know, for lack of a better word, a loophole. Loopholes get closed eventually. It's not a matter of it's not a matter of if. It's a matter of when when these products get closed. I think Australia needs to step up to the rest of the world when it comes to clarity of Bitcoin ETFs and offering a market. If there's a rule, everyone should follow it because it protects
5:58
investors and it safeguards investors from this, from the unique risks of crypto asset investments. Yeah. Okay. So, um, what should I do if I'm an investor to, I guess, navigate this landscape that's changing or could possibly change, like what to do? There's two simple ways an investor can get clarity on these products. One is through reading the product disclosure statements, which are the offer documents for these products. It's very important for investors to look into the details of how these products are structured behind the scenes of versus what they are marketing in on the surface. The second way is to go to the ASIC portal to look into the issuers license to see whether they are authorised under this category, called crypto assets. If they are not, most likely it's a feeder fund, it's an indirect Bitcoin ETF and it should be marketed that way.