The appeal of Aussie bonds
About this video
Charlie Callan from BondAdviser expresses views on US rate cuts, stating that a series of 25 basis point reductions are likely, with rates possibly not falling below 3.5% due to persistent inflation. Charlie also shares that the Australian market may not see rate cuts this year with current data not favouring such a move.
In discussing credit quality, Charlie highlights that Australian bonds offer appealing returns relative to the US and Europe, due to the country's more creditor-friendly insolvency laws and lower market volatility. Maintaining a quality bias in portfolios is crucial, he says.
On the topic of mortgage arrears, Charlie notes an increase in both prime and subprime delinquencies, particularly those exceeding 90 days. He warns that non-bank lenders may pose higher risks, whereas Australian banks remain well-equipped to manage potential losses.
Full unedited transcript below:
0:00
Let's take a top down view. Talk rate cuts. As always, what will we see before the end of 2024? Charlie Callan joins us from bond advisor Charlie. A long time between drinks. I hope you're well. Okay, so shall we talk about the US first? Um, do you think there's another 50 basis point cut coming? Will be at a consecutive 25 basis points to take us to the end of the year?
0:30
Today, Nadine, good to see and talk to you too. Yeah. That is our opinion now. So the inflationary data that we saw last week is certainly suggestive of that. And if you think about what markets are pricing in now through till next year, about this time next year, you're talking about six cuts in the US. Uh, a 25 basis point cuts. That is so yeah. Look we we kind of we broadly agree with that consensus. I would say I think that if you think about longer term US rates and where they can come down to that they should come down from where they are? Uh, but once you're talking about what's the what's the kind of neutral rate in the US
1:11
in our view? Uh, we don't really think it can come down much further than 3.5%, uh, at this, this stage, given where some of the sticky inflation that we're seeing is at. So,
1:25
um, what that means higher for longer environment, um, means that you're going to continue to suffer, suffocate the economy. Um, and it'll just be a little bit less vigorously than it would be otherwise, uh, if rates were at 5%,
1:39
uh, 5.5%, that is, in Australia. We have been saying now for the past 3 or 4 months that we don't think that the RBA would be in a position to cut rates this year. We still think that that's the case. Um, we're a little bit out of consensus with that opinion initially. Uh, you know, a few months ago
1:58
markets were pricing in 100% chance of a cut in December. Now they're pricing in a 40% chance. So they've kind of come along to our side a little bit. There is still a significant degree of uncertainty there. And in terms of the Australian cycle and when we start to cut rates.
2:16
And the reason the big risk to that is that the gap between December and February, you know, that's that's a long time between RBA meetings. And there's still a lot of data under the bridge, uh, between now and February. So that's the risk to our call. But look, the data that we're seeing, generally speaking, is is not giving the RBA the ammo that it needs to to cut rates at this point in the cycle. You know, we were we were we were, uh, late to the party and we didn't we didn't increase rates, uh, by as much. And it's going to be the reverse on the way down. You know, we're going to be last to leave. Um, and we're going to do so, uh, with, with less intensity than other central banks. So just to come back to the key thing here is we think that the the narrative of high for longer is actually something that everyone should be getting positioned for. Um, and from our perspective, if we're thinking about floating rate notes in Australia or three months back in Australia of
3:15
circa 3.5%, you're still going to earn a really good income on your, uh, floating rate notes. Um, but also what it means is 3.5% rates. You're still suffocating the economy, right? Just just a little bit less vigorously. So we need to keep a quality bias in our portfolios. And that's really important to us. Okay. So explain that a little bit Charlie. What what is quality.
3:41
Yeah. So credit quality if you think about credit risk um, we're talking about uh effectively that the likelihood of a company defaulting. Right. So when people talk about quality bias and credit, they're often referring to credit ratings. So from Moody's and S&P and Fitch and and uh moving up in rating quality. Uh and yes that is absolutely an element that we take into consideration. But there's actually quite a lot you can do in terms of geographies as well. And countries have different insolvency frameworks. Uh, but they also have different trading dynamics. And perhaps viewers would be less aware of that. Australia from a credit trading perspective, is extremely low beta. Uh, so our spreads don't move extremely like they do in the US and, and, and in Europe. You don't have that volatility in price to the same extent. And that's actually a really good defensive, uh, characteristic when you're talking about improving the credit quality of portfolios. So one of the positions that we've held for for most of this
4:41
year and expect to continue to hold into next year is a quality bias, but also in Australia, bias. Okay. And so
4:52
so does that mean that you're willing to sacrifice some returns for that quality, for that less risky profile? Great question. So you would think so, right. Um, these things are normally correlated risk and return. But at the moment we're not actually not seeing that. And that's actually making for a really attractive, uh, opportunity. And uh, we, we think that on a like for like ratings perspective, credit ratings perspective, Australia is actually really attractive relative to the US and Europe. And and that doesn't make sense. Fundamentally our default data is is far more benign compared to the US and compared to Europe, both on a business and personal insolvencies basis, but also our our creditor insolvency laws are far more creditor friendly than they are in somewhere like the US. Um, but yet we're being paid more here at the moment to take on default risk in the Australian market. So Australian credit spreads are close to ten
5:52
year averages. Um, and you know, what does that mean? It's sort of 70 basis points over on the index, um, for those in the know, but for those that just want a more all in figure, you're talking about a yield of about 5% on a single, a, uh, credit rating, uh, type index at the moment. Uh, and that's looking at particularly attractive now when you're thinking about today's and the rates coming down there, uh, yields are still, uh, elevated in the bond market. Yeah. Interesting. All right. Um, what is happening in terms of insolvencies, in terms of arrears, particularly when it comes to the into the rmbs market?
6:32
Yeah. So
6:34
when we think about, uh rmbs. What are they? They're mortgages. Right. Residential mortgages. And you can split them up into prime borrowers and non-prime or subprime and both subprime and prime areas are increasing. Um, and that's been led by. It's mainly been led by the 90 plus delinquency, uh, data cohort. So what does that mean? Um, it means that arrears are going up, um, and they're going up because people aren't paying their loans for a significant period of time. It's not just a timing error where someone's just missed a payment and they made it up. Uh, later. We're talking about a cash flow problem. When you talk about 90 day arrears and, um, talking, you know, earlier we're talking about this suffocation of the economy in higher rates. Um, this is the sternum of that, you know, this is where, uh, the, the constricting is happening the most to those with mortgages. And, um, particularly if you think about subprime, um, where the borrower
7:33
is, is perhaps a little bit less creditworthy, their arrears that are around 4.5%. And that's actually the highest it's been since 2015. Um, and primaries have also ticked up materially in the past few months. Um, and there is rights that are at and around 1.7%, and that is close to a two decade high of 1.8%, which was in 2011.
7:58
Well, it sounds really dynamic. So when I mean, we've talked so much about potential weakness coming through in these Aussie property market, it's never really come to the fore. So, um, are there any sort of best performing loans, better performing loans, like where the arrears coming from? What's the sort of makeup of that cohort?
8:19
Yeah. So, um, we've made some charts into this recently and, and one of the things that we've done over the past couple of years, we like to split out loans by vintage so that the cohort of, of the year that they were made. Um, CBA also does this um, and uh, you can have a look at CBA's book. This is the Moody's book, effectively. So a broader picture of the Australian market.
8:42
Um, when we do this, there's very clear winners and losers. You look at that chart there and there's a lot going on. But if you if we look at the next chart, um, will illustrate the, the best performing loans. Right. So what are the winners. Where are the arrears. The lowest at the moment. And those are actually currently being seen in 2020, which is that orange line there at the bottom of the screen. So these these 2020 loans were struck at low rates. Um, and they've performed a lot better than the prior 20 years worth of data in terms of, uh, arrears performance. Now the worst performing loans where, where arrears the worst, who's who's struggling the most and the called call those the losers. Um, these are the loans that were struck in 2020. Uh, sorry, 2022, 2021. And more recently we've actually seen significant weakness in the 2018 vintage. So in this chart here, what we've plotted for you is, uh, on the green dots. That's the 20 decade average of
9:42
how, uh, arrears tick up as an rmbs product matures or seasons. Um, it's natural that arrears tick up through time. Um, but we're seeing that for these borrowers are in the blues, uh, and in the red there as well. Um, the performance there has been weakened. And the dotted red line there is showing the performance of these arrears vintages between 2005 and 2007. So the vintages that were struck just before the GFC, um, uh, these, these were the ones that had the weakest performance in the local market. Notably, none of them took on losses in the prime market. Um, realized losses, that is. But you can see that the, the 2022, the 2021 and now the 2018 uh, vintages are actually on the wrong side of that data. So, um, there's certainly a bit of cause for concern with those borrower cohorts. Um, but broadly
10:42
speaking, if we come back to kind of the big picture here. Um, there are obviously winners and losers to changes in interest rates and, and, um, this data shows that even amongst mortgages, there's different winners and losers about, you know, when the interest rates are struck, um, fixed versus floating etc., and what your serviceability buffer was as well. Um, but I just, I don't want to be I don't want to be the doomsday guy. I just want to reiterate the fact that there is a continued, uh, a continued excellent amount of prudence from our banks. And if you look at the macroeconomic overlay provisions that that kept in their balance sheets,
11:21
um, we think that even though loan the the losses in the loan book and arrears may continue to trend higher over the coming years, our banking system fundamentally is in a really good space to manage that. And the risk is actually in the non-bank lenders at the moment. And that's the kind of point that we'd look to, to ram home, which is we're trying to take risk out of that space, but we're very comfortable with the banks.