Surprising earnings season surprises
About this video
Jason Hall from Hamilton12 explains the divergence in earnings surprises post-earnings season. Short-term forecasts often mislead investors. Focusing on longer period data yields more reliable insights into earnings surprises, highlighting the importance of protective strategies against downside risks.
Jason details an extensive analysis of 1600 companies, divided into quintiles by earnings surprise. Results show stark variations, with bottom 20% facing average downside of 11% and top 20% seeing about 2% upside. Mining companies like Pilbara Minerals (ASX: PLS), Igo (ASX: IGO), and Mineral Resources (ASX: MIN) significantly underperform, with earnings far below initial expectations.
Conversely, retailers like Super Retail (ASX: SUL) and JB Hi-Fi (ASX: JBH) defy pessimistic forecasts with better-than-expected performances, showcasing consumer resilience. Electricity companies, including AGL Energy, benefit from inflation and rebates, enjoying positive earnings surprises. Jason underscores the importance of balanced outlooks.
Full unedited transcript below:
0:11
Let's get into the earnings surprises, though, though, as the earnings season in the rearview mirror. What is a surprising surprise? What's the normal surprise range? Jason Hall from Hamilton 12. Joining me now to explain. Hi, Jason. What is this surprising surprise?
0:28
We just had
0:30
fiscal year earnings come through and everyone is naturally very focused on short term earnings. Surprise. Comparing what analysts were forecasting last week compared to when earnings came out this week, which is really just a very short term outlook because you're really just looking at sort of six months of new information coming through. And I sort of think when you're an investor, you have to decide about the things that you care about and the things that you don't care about. Um, and one of the things that I care about more than short term earnings surprise, is what happens over a longer period of time. And so I think about earnings surprise in terms of if we look a year ago at what analysts were expecting from earnings relative to share prices, and then what happened over the course of an entire year as new information came through. How much upside or downside surprise you get in a typical year? And what's the range of upside and downside surprise?
1:25
Um, in any given year, the typical earnings surprise on the downside relative to share price is 0.6% on the downside, and analysts in general are at the start of a financial year overly optimistic. So in 29 out of the 30 previous years, there has been a walk down of earnings because analysts initially begin with inflated expectations.
1:49
But there is a huge amount of variation of that earnings surprise amongst companies of different levels. And this is where investors have to think carefully about their portfolio and about protecting themselves on the downside.
2:04
So what we did was take a sample of 1600 companies. We looked at their earnings surprise over the course of an entire year. And we broke them into five different quintiles, and we looked at the top 20% of companies by earnings surprise each year and the bottom 20%. And what you see is that there is a massive skewness in the data towards that bottom 20% in terms of earnings surprise. Um, for example, on average, when you look at that downside, you're looking at downside of about 11% relative to share price in that bottom 20%. So that is the orange bars that you can see on the screen. And on the upside, in the top 20%, that number is consistently around about 2%. It barely moves over the time series. Um, um, you can see back in the the recession of 2002 and 2009, that massive downside surprise in that bottom 20%. And that's where is that investor. You have to think very carefully. Is my portfolio
3:04
potentially concentrated amongst stocks where there are inflated expectations in their industry or for the company? Um, mhm. I'm making a very big bet. Uh they could potentially surprise on the downside. Yeah. Jason, tell us about what you saw, though, when you looked at the data here as well, because mining companies in the low surprise group.
3:28
Uh, well, let's take the most recent financial year as an example, 2024. Um, so just as an example of where we had upside surprise and downside surprise. If you look at those mining companies, these are the companies that were in the bottom 20% in terms of downside surprise. And we selected some of the bigger companies, right. Because they're more representative of a typical portfolio. You've got Pilbara minerals, Igo and mineral Resources all had downside surprise of between 6 and 10% of share price. So analysts were initially expecting these companies to trade on earnings yield, that is, earnings related to share price of between 7 and 12%. So you look at those companies, you think well that's a really low PE ratio. That's PE in the single digits. But when the results actually come through a years later um, we've got actual yields of only about 2 or 3%. And all those companies were exposed to significant falls polls in lithium and nickel prices. Right. These metals and minerals associated with
4:27
transitioning towards electric vehicles. So what you see is a concentration of, you know, very high expectations for a new industry. And often when you've got these very high expectations, um, things are never as great as you initially thought they were going to be. Yeah, it's very true. And you make another really interesting point about how the retailers had upside surprise. I mean, I think everybody I've spoken to in the wake of reporting season was surprised at the resilience of the consumer and how well some of these companies did.
4:59
Well, exactly. So this is the opposite end of the spectrum. Um, a year ago, uh, the market was talking about we're going to have increases in interest rates to tame inflation. Consumer spending is going to be crimped. We're going to have, um, these these retailers trade on a fairly low forecast yields of eight and 9%. But it turns out that the consumer is more resilient than people give them credit for. Now inflation was somewhat more persistent than we initially expected and we continued to observe during the year interest rate increases, but those interest rate increases only affect between one third and one half of consumers. There is a bit half and two thirds of consumers that don't care at all about interest rate rises, right? They don't have mortgage payments going up. They might benefit from increased interest in their bank accounts. The consumer is more resilient than you might expect. So it's just another example of where you've got sort of increasing pessimism in one particular industry. Things are never quite as bad as
5:59
you think they're going to be, and things are never quite as good as you initially think they're going to be. Those examples super Retail and JB Hi-Fi, they actually had declining earnings per share over the course of the year, but the decline was nowhere near as great as analysts were initially expecting. Yeah. What about the electricity companies? We spoke to AGL energy. Um, people starting to get their energy rebates. But of course these companies have done very well out of the inflationary piece.
6:28
Well, they've done well because we've had increases in inflation which flows through to their regulated rate of return. And we've seen increases in wholesale energy prices. So they benefit, um, from higher energy prices. They're benefiting from rebates. Um, so this is a positive upside. Surprise. Analysts thought these companies were going to be under some pressure. They've had this positive, somewhat clawback of low wholesale energy prices for the two prior years. And that surprised on the upside. So again another example we never too pessimistic or too optimistic. We just had an example about potentially constraints on the US consumer spending. Um I'm from the US, a US citizen now, originally from Australia. Never doubt the US consumer's ability to continue to spend even when savings rates decline. So we will see we have seen decreased spending. Uh, we have seen decreased spending on entertainment, restaurants, consumption and so on. But again, it's a market where there is a huge proportion of the economy
7:28
which is ambivalent towards interest rate increases. Interest rate increases have done, their job spending has come down, but that only affects a subset of the economy and an even smaller subset compared to Australia.