Super switching sparks debate | the advisory
Super switching sparks debate | the advisory
About this video
Key Points:
Platform users characterised as higher income, older and more financially sophisticated
Switching to platforms often linked to super account consolidation
Shield and First Guardian failures seen as catalyst for stronger due diligence
Briggs supports targeted reforms but warns against curbs on switching and choice
Blake Briggs from the Financial Services Council outlines data challenges research from the Super Members Council about Australians moving from default superannuation funds to for‑profit investment platforms. Briggs states that platform users are typically higher income, more mature and financially sophisticated, with an average balance of around $350,000 and an average age of 59. Even among younger cohorts, he says switchers tend to have triple the average balance of their peers, suggesting more complex financial needs and a desire for control over superannuation
Briggs argues that platform switching is often part of sensible account consolidation, with FSC research indicating around 25% of those moving to platforms use the opportunity to bring multiple super accounts together. He warns that portraying this behaviour as risky is, in his view, a deliberate attempt to influence policymaking and protect commercial interests tied to default funds.
Reflecting on the Shield and First Guardian failures, Briggs points to what he sees as stronger product due diligence across platforms and highlights the decisions by Netwealth (ASX:NWL) and Macquarie Group (ASX:MQG) to compensate affected investors as evidence that capital‑backed platforms can support consumer outcomes. He supports tighter regulation of dubious lead generation, while cautioning against reforms that restrict consumer choice and engagement with superannuation.