Strong US manufacturing data clouds the outlook for rate cuts
About this video
Charlie Callan from BondAdviser, shares his insights regarding the surprising strength displayed by US manufacturing data that nudged treasury yields and toned down expectations for a rate cut. He points out that the ISM manufacturing index expanded recently, indicating growth in manufacturing expectations within the economic landscape. Charlie mentions that Friday saw an upward yield movement in the US, while rate-cut expectations have been tapering off.
He discussed the potential implications of rate cuts being postponed, especially on fixed and floating rates. Charlie recommends exposure to fixed-rate investments as a long-term risk management strategy, suggesting that BondAdviser currently favours floating rate structures due to expected high returns. He discussed the possibility that if market expectations project no cuts until this year-end or next year, the returns on floating rate instruments are likely to remain high.
Comparing the yields of floating-rate bonds with those of the equity market, Charlie observes that investing in bonds currently yields a higher rate of return. Although AT1 Hybrid markets have substantial credit risks, he says that they exhibit lower volatility. Charlie then concludes by expressing his concern over the current high valuations in AT1 Hybrids, suggesting that they are relatively expensive compared to other bank capital structure parts. Consequently, he advises selling on secondary markets in AT1 hybrids.
Find the full unedited transcript of this interview below:
0:00
Now stronger than expected. US manufacturing data has propped up Treasury yields and tempered expectations of a rate cut. Let's get into the data and what it means for rates. Charlie Callan joining us from BondAdviser. Charlie good to catch up with you again. You're interesting to see. What are you making of that data. We've had it from the States. The PC deflator on Friday was a little lower than expected. But then, of course, we've got that strength we're seeing now in the manufacturing sector.
0:29
Yeah. Look, I think, um, uh, obviously the, the, the ism print surprised everyone. Um, and what that is in print is it's effectively just a manufacturing index in terms of, uh, expansion or contraction in manufacturing expectations, uh, within the economy. And it's it's actually expanded into what you call positive territory for the first time since 2022. So what's happened is, um, on Friday, there was a pretty, uh, adverse, uh, upward move in yields, uh, in the US to the tune of about ten basis points. Um, and we're now getting towards the kind of top end of the recent range that we've had in, in, you know, ten year trading, um, now at around the 4.3% mark. So, um, what also has happened at the front end is obviously there's been a real tapering of expectation of rate cuts in the future, similar to what your last, uh, speaker was talking about. So, um, a cut now in the US is only priced in at
1:29
a sort of 50% chance now, uh, at the kind of June point, um, and further out, you've only got 65 basis points worth of cuts priced into forward contracts, um, right up until the end of this year. So you've got an implied US cash rate of 4.65% at the end of the year versus 5.5% now. Um, and in the Australian context, um, our implied rate at the end of the year is about 3.9% versus, you know, the 4.35% where we are now. So yeah, look, it's it has been an upwards reaction in fixed income markets. I think, um, March was probably the first positive month for, for duration that we've had in a while. And um, um, we've kind of quickly crossed back to upwards pressures this morning in the Australian market.
2:16
So Charlie, then with the prospect perhaps of those rate cuts are being pushed further out, then let's just break it down into what we're likely to see, certainly in terms of fixed and floating rates and how investors should adjust as a result.
2:30
Yeah. Great question Andrew. So look, I think, um, just to highlight that there's two types of of main bond structures. So there's fixed where the coupon is set on issuance and it doesn't change. And there's floating where the coupon has a margin that's set on issuance. But the income actually reflects the margin plus a cash rate proxy. So the income is contingent on on interest rate levels. Now on the fixed side, um, we think investors should have some exposure if you don't already risk or return per unit of risk. Um, uh is is at longer term high. So that's yield per unit of duration. Um, and it's just a good recession proofing type strategy at the moment, especially at the sort of top end of the range that we're sitting at now. It's, um, also good for income proofing, locking in those rates over the longer term, 5 or 7, ten years, generally speaking, at the moment, uh, bond advisor, our preference is is still in the floating rate structures. And the reason why is
3:29
because if if there is now the market expectations and we kind of had these expectations a couple of months ago that that we weren't going to see cuts right until the end of this year and possibly into to next year. It means that the returns on floating rate instruments are going to stay really high. So you know what what that means is, is, um, um, effectively we think that the first half is going to be very much a risk on period, which makes fixed performance suffer under the presumption that rate cuts gets walked away and long term growth expectations pick up. So yeah, look, we're definitely, um, preface towards the floating rate side of things at the moment. Yeah. And inevitably Charlie, comparisons made between what
4:13
um, returns are getting from, um, those, those bonds at the moment, particularly in terms of floating compared with what we're seeing in the equity market.
4:24
Yeah, it's always it's always a key question you need to be asking yourself, you know, relative returns across asset classes. And, you know, we're very much dialed in on the fixed income side of things. But we do like to consider how, uh, the income compares on, on the equity side of things. So just to kind of walk you through some different parts of those floating rate, uh, securities that we're talking about, the kind of broad index which is the Osborne credit for an index, um, which takes in all the $8 investment grade, um, floating rate bonds that's currently yielding at about 4.7%. And that's an incredibly high, you know, triple A minus bank, standard type credit quality. If you're looking for something with a bit more risk, if you want to take subordinated risk at a at a big for bank, you're talking about an income yield of maybe 5.75% on a cash basis. So no franking there. Um, but if you want to push the barge out and you want to go, um, search for some, you know, aggressive floating rate structures, leverage loans in the US. Um, again,
5:24
very speculative credit, but but, uh, floating rate in nature that's yielding about 9.5%. So if we bring that back to dividend yields, if you're talking about the ASX 200, these dividend yields are on a franked basis as well. So not just cash but the franking portion. Um, ASX 200 is at about 4%. The big four bank dividend yields at about 7%. But these come with some serious volatility. As everyone knows now, something that doesn't come with as much volatility but still has serious credit risk is that AT1 hybrid market. And that's giving a sort of franked um distribution yield of about 6.2%. Um, and you know, so so you compare and contrast those different volatility versus return characteristics. And the Osborne Free Index has basically had no volatility whatsoever in the past three years because there's no credit risk and there's no interest rate risk. So if you're you're considering how you structure income portfolios um, it's an excellent time to be, you know, um, getting overweight fixed
6:24
income. Yeah. And you mentioned the hybrids there. Uh, Charlie, just just to finish off, then what are you making of those valuations there at the moment?
6:33
Um, short answer is, uh, yeah. We're selling um on secondary markets in AT1 hybrids. We think that valuations there are are expensive and that's expensive on an outright basis. So just looking at hybrids, um, but it's also expensive on a relative basis. So if you go to other parts of the bank capital structure for instance, and other fixed income products, um, um, so look that there, there has recently, you know, we've seen a lot of, um, deals in primary markets recently, um, in hybrids. And generally speaking, we sold all of them were issued with kind of concessions that we saw attractive. And they're all trading well now in secondary markets. And you know, we're always big fans of of that capital markets trade of taking that new issue concession and then selling into secondary. Um, but but no doubt about it, prices uh in secondary are rich. And just to give you some context around the numbers there, um, big four um, five year trading margins are at around 250 basis points. And that's a full
7:33
standard deviation, expensive on the average going back to 2014. And and to actually put that in a percentile basis, um, at one trading margins, uh, going back to that 2014 mark, are trading margins are wide and 90% of the time. So 90% of the time in this AT1 hybrid market, you're getting paid more to take on the the most junior credit or risk in the banking capital structure. Um, and for context for, for those percentiles in different parts of the bank capital structure. Um, the senior unsecured part, uh, margins, uh, trading, uh, are at levels where they trade wider 70% of the time. So, you know, there's a bit of a difference in that 20%. Um, it's clear that that, you know, one half, 24 risk on rallies compressing margins across the board. But we actually think there's much better value at the moment in the senior parts of the bank capital structure than those junior parts. So that's that's our call there.