South Australia, the place to be!
About this video
Key topics:
Overall Economic Performance of Australia
State-wise detailed economic performance and future prospects
Overall Housing Market and prediction
Craig James, chief economist at CommSec, elaborates on the economic health of Australia, highlighting benefits such as a trade surplus, a current account surplus, a budget surplus and the job market at full employment. Still, Craig stresses, there is concern around inflation trends. He claims that economic slowdown is evident, particularly in retail with consumers curtailing discretionary spending and a slowdown in housing finance. Craig concludes this would naturally occur with rising interest rates to slow the economy and rebalance supply and demand.
To South Australia's performance, Craig praises it for consistent factors that have propelled it to its steady ranking. Noting that even its small economy size doesn't detract from achieving a high ranking, as it has held its place through unemployment and economic growth factors, and especially in dwelling starts. Craig observes momentum gaining from states like Western Australia and Queensland who significantly improved their standings bolstered by factors such as stronger population growth and economic performance.
Craig discusses the housing market and its cyclical nature. He predicts a softening in housing activity later in the year before a rejuvenation taking place through migration. Recognising how housing price growth is led by population growth with Queensland and Western Australia leading in these metrics. Lastly, Craig weighs in on the inflation measure, stating that levels at 0.6 or 0.7 are viewed positively with potential for interest rate cuts but admits it is close at the margin.
Below is the full unedited transcript of this interview:
0:00
Homesick has released its state of the state's report showing which state and territory in Australia's other economic leaders in the quarter. Let's get across some of the detail, CommSec chief economist Craig James joining us now, Craig. Very good to have you back on us because thanks for joining us. Or overall. But before we get into the specifics, how is the Australian economy performing more broadly? When I guess you look at what's going on on the jobs market also, that strong population growth.
0:27
The Australian economy is performing very well. When you look at the situation, we've got a trade surplus, we've got a broader current account surplus, we've got a budget surplus, we've got a job market which effectively you could say is that full employment. Uh, the the only thing that we can't give a tick to at the moment is inflation. And inflation is on its way down. We've just got to work out how long it's going, going to take to get back to the Reserve Bank's target zone. But overall Australia stacks up very well on a global scale. Okay. But when you look at obviously the pressure that households are under, how is that pull back from consumers affecting the broader economy.
1:04
You know the economy is slowing and that's very, very clear. When you look at retail spending, people are looking at their discretionary or non-essential spending and making the most of the cuts, you know, where where they need to. So overall retail spending, a slowdown in housing finance in terms of dwelling activity as well. And that's what's supposed to happen when interest rates rise, slow down the economy, rebalance between supply and demand and the economy. And hopefully that will mean yes, inflation gets down. And of course, we've got the all important inflation figures coming out on Wednesday. Indeed, Craig, we talk about the labor market has showed incredible resilience, really did tick up slightly in the last three. Nonetheless in terms of the jobless rate, what are you seeing there for unemployment.
1:48
Well right the way across the land we've got the unemployment rate either in the late threes or the early fours. Um, and um, that if you go back, you know, sort of a few years ago, you would have considered that pretty much full employment. And I think we are very much, you know, sort of full employment. We've got a little bit of slippage in terms of the jobless rate. Um, but it's just creeping a little bit instead of higher, but it's generally around about that 4%. It would be a great concern if what we saw as the strength of the labor market forcing wages substantially higher and, uh, therefore, you know, preventing the inflation from, from coming down. But that doesn't seem to be the situation at the moment. Modest easing in terms of the job market. Unemployment's probably going to trend a little bit yesterday higher. But the reserve Bank jealously guards the the fact that it's made substantial progress in getting that unemployment rate down and effectively pretty much close to full employment. Now, of
2:48
course, what we're seeing in the labor market, heavily influenced by those that high level of immigration we've seen, um, how has that broken down just in terms of the population mix at the moment across Australia?
2:58
Well, if you look at yesterday, the the population growth in Western Australia is head and shoulders above all the other states and territories in terms of population growth. Um, you've got up there, you know, sort of places like Victoria, Queensland, New South Wales not doing so well as um, uh, Tasmania and also the Northern Territory. And we do know that population is is power to the economy. If you've got a faster population growth, there's more people around, more consumer spending, more people to be, uh, need to build roads and schools and sort of like an infrastructure. So it has knock on benefits to the broader economy. And that's why we believe that Western Australia has probably got the greatest chance to be able to get its way up to the top of the leaderboard next time, uh, ahead of South Australia, which is losing a bit, a bit of momentum in terms of slower population growth. All right. Well, you've you've gone there just in terms of uh, which states and territories are winning and losing, uh, effectively at the moment across, uh, your
3:58
metrics that you've used. So you've said South Australia on top at the moment, what ranked first on four indicators.
4:06
Yeah. And um, so that shows you the consistency of the, the performance of the South Australian economy. So some would say, well, this is a relatively small economy yesterday. How could it been yesterday number one. And they've said that before in the past about Tasmania when it's number one. But if you look at those four indicators we look at the latest observation, compare it with the decade average, get a sense of how the economy is performing and then compare that against all the states and territories in South Australia in terms of economic growth. And yes, the number one unemployment, number one construction work done, and also in terms of dwelling starts. So there's a lot of consistency there. Um, it deserves its place at the top of the leaderboard. But whether it holds on to that position uh, is very much under question. All right. So which which states and territories do you see as being on the move positively at the moment? Well, Western Australia's certainly yesterday picked up seven points in the last survey. So it's
5:06
amongst the USA the gainers uh Act Queensland improved. So Queensland certainly has the potential yesterday as well. Um but when you think about the states and territories you could throw a blanket over most of them, you know, in terms of economic performance. So, uh, where the momentum lies and we get that by looking at the annual growth rate for some of the, the key indicators, uh, and get a sense of that. Yes. And West Australia is clearly got. Yes. The momentum on its side, um, stronger population growth. It's improving yesterday across all the categories. Uh, so certainly yesterday um, we are seeing the resource sector driving West Australia, more people going in there. And that has a knock on of benefit across the broader economy. Now, Craig, you touched on this before. Dwelling starts now we know the housing crisis. Um, that uh, it continues at the moment. Of course, there is that push on in terms of the need to build more homes.
6:06
However, it appears to be going in the wrong direction.
6:09
Yeah. So what we've got is a timing difficulty. Yes. At the moment we do know that there's a lot of homes being built at the moment, not far off the record number that have occurred just last year, in the September quarter last year, when we had a record number of homes under construction, we've only dipped a little bit further than that. So bit a bit out of kilter at the moment. Dwelling approvals that continue to fall. And that's suggesting that we are going to see softer housing activity later this year and early early next year. But if migration continues to remain firm, what we could have is, you know, sort of a false dawn yesterday that we could have that yesterday of lower activity. Then it starts to pick up, you know, sort of very, very quickly. So, um, at the moment, um, what we would say is that the housing market is relatively healthy. It is going to heading towards a softer patch, um, in the latter part of the, the year. Um, but um, um, the question of migration and if
7:09
that provides the second win for, for housing, uh, in 2025. Well, in fact, you know, we have seen house prices appreciated across the country. And perhaps no surprise, a lot of that driven by that population growth. You mentioned there wa leading on that metric. And as a result, we have seen home prices lift cost substantially over their.
7:31
This is very much the case. You look across the nation yesterday, it's basically Queensland, Western Australia leading the way in terms of home price growth. So um, certainly, you know, sort of
7:45
the home, uh, owners and those people paying off loans shouldn't get too complacent with this though. When you've got a super strong growth in terms of home prices, they eventually come back down to a more sustainable level of growth. And that's probably something like five, six, 7% year over a year rather than 15, 16, 17% that we're seeing across economies like Western Australia and also Queensland. Now, Craig, looking ahead on data wise, we do have the key uh March quarter CPI read coming to us on Wednesday. What are the expectations. The expectations is 0.7%. Growth is expected in terms of headline measure of inflation and 0.8% in terms of underlying. Now, if you've got those figures and you multiply them by for quick and dirty, yes, analysis should be heading towards the 2 to 3% use of target zones. Um, uh, that's interesting though. You can only just slip by, you know, just a small amount.
8:45
And, uh, the markets will react badly. So anything like 0.8 or 0.9, you know, sort of, um, tend to be, you know, sort of viewed quite negatively in terms of the potential for cutting interest rates. Something like a 0.6 or a 0.7 is considered quite positive. So it's very, very close at the margin. But that's the games that we're playing at the moment. Um, we wanted to get inflation yesterday back into that 2 to 3% targets and or at least giving the reserve Bank confidence that we're on their way back into that target band before we can start cutting rates. And we think the economy is going to continue to soften, inflation is going to come down. And the September of this year that we can be starting some interest rate cuts.