Slowing spending & a soft landing
Slowing spending & a soft landing
About this video
Stephen Halmarick, cheif economist at the Commonwealth Bank, expects the RBA will manage to engineer a soft-landing. Upcoming wages and inflation data will be key, however, he says signs of slowing in the economy, inflation retreating and spending easing are proof 400bp of interest rate hikes are having the desired impact.
His comments come as the CommBank Household Spending Insights (HSI) index for September 2023 rose by 0.5%/mth in seasonally adjusted terms, to 137.4. This was the same monthly increase as the revised outcome for August.
The monthly increase in the HSI index has stabilised at 0.5%‑0.6% since June, which is up from an average increase of 0.2%/mth from Feb‑May 2023. Recent household spending data has been more resilient than expected. CBA says part of this is price driven, but part of this is still a preference to spend given strong household income growth and previously accumulated savings.
Find the full unedited transcript of this interview below:
But spending household spending here in Australia is just such an important piece of the puzzle when it comes to, well, where interest rates will head here. Look, let's get it. Data. Data. Let's find out what the data is telling us. And for that, really pleased to welcome chief economist of Commonwealth Bank, Stephen Halmarick, here with us in studio with the Household Spending Index results. Stephen, welcome. Thanks. You've got all of this information from your consumer base and you've got a whole heap of consumers across all demographics. So there's been a lot of talk about how older Australians and people with money, let's put it that way, haven't had to slow down their spending at all. Is that true? So what we can see from our data is, yeah, there has been that demographic change. So and that really mostly relates to whether people already own their own home or they've got a mortgage or they're renting. So there's some
0:59
home ownership dynamics as well as age group dynamics there. And it does show that, you know, older Australians and I use that word advisedly, 55 and above, so which puts me in that camp, but
1:12
have had more of the savings and have kept their spending a bit stronger than some of the younger demographics. Okay. Are we seeing significant slowing in spending by younger demographics? Well, overall spending was up 0.5% in September, but certainly younger demographics have been finding it much more difficult than perhaps the older Australians. Yeah, but spending in September up 0.5% on last year, no. So that was 0.5% on the month. So September up a half a percent compared to August. And what is it on the year then? On the year? September this year is 1.8% above September last year. So that's in nominal dollars. So when we think about inflation's running around about 5% for the month of September or year to September, I should say, and population growth is over 2.5%. So in real and per capita terms, that means spending is weakening. Now, if we think about when the Reserve Bank started raising interest rates in May last
2:11
year, the annual rate of growth for our HSR index was 8.3% and in September it's 1.8%. So that pretty clearly shows the slowdown in the consumer as the higher interest rates have work their way through the system. Okay. So what is your view on how much more those higher interest rates or how much more slowing we'll see as a result of what we've seen already in terms of rates? Yeah. So if you look at well, Chris Kane from the Reserve Bank speech yesterday said something like 75% of the rate hikes are now being felt by the consumer. So there's a bit more to go, you know, assuming there's no more rate hikes. So our base case is no more rate hikes for an extended period into May next year. But but certainly the risk for both the November and the December board meetings this year would be perhaps one more rate rise depending on the inflation numbers and the wages numbers coming up. So it's really going to be until early 2024 before the full effect of the rate hikes are being felt by households. And so we think that
3:11
consumer spending is likely to continue to soften into early next year. But but we can see from our data that we're spending more money on. Sometimes we're spending more money on things just because the prices have risen. Maybe things we don't like spending more money on. Petrol is a good example. So transport spending was up quite strongly in September as it was in August. There's more spending on education, but a large amount of that is foreign students coming into Australia paying the university fees but also higher prices. But we do we are taking some time or money to spend on things like well, in in August it was ticketing agency, so FIFA Women's World Cup and in September definitely both hospitality and food and beverage spending was stronger, which you think was related to the football grand final series. Also, the weather. I mean, I'm not a footy fan, but, you know, holidays. Yeah, but Victoria was the strongest state in September, so that kind of lends itself to the view that it was holidays and grand finals. So we are
4:11
finding some money to spend on those hospitality recreation items over the last few months. But we're really cutting back on our spending on things like household goods, household services, kind of the basics, and then we'll be talking, well, October, I can't think of anything big. We'll be talking about Black Friday sales come November and Christmas. Yeah, come December. So we've got inflation that you referenced. I think that's on the 25th. That could be wrong. We've got wages as well, which in your view is more important. Well, when it comes to the RBA. Well, so for the November board meeting, it's really the inflation number that's that's critical.
4:46
July inflation was 4.9, August it was 5.2. So we get the September number somewhere around five. But we'll want to see that continued deceleration of the annual rate and then on the 15th of November. Which then would mean for the December board meeting is when we get the third quarter wages numbers. So they are going to include the national wage case increases, some of these public sector pay rises that have been more like 4% other enterprise award agreements. So both of those data points are really critical for the next two board meetings. Are you concerned that if the RBA does not hike November, December, that inflation will just sort of get out of control, just become too entrenched? No, I wouldn't say that. So. Inflation peaked at 7.8% in December quarter last year, 7% in the March quarter, 6% in the June quarter. We think it will be about 5% in the September quarter. So it's clearly decelerating and some of that is
5:45
global. You can see that everybody you just referenced the US CPI and that the annual rates decelerating as well. But of course recent events have increased volatility, particularly in oil, oil markets, so that that would be a concern. So we see the inflation rate continuing to decelerate through 2024 and actually being back in the target range, the top end of the target range, but back in the 2 to 3% target range before the end of next year where the Reserve Bank has got it in back in the target range in 2025. So we think actually we'll get inflation back into the target range sooner than the RBA's current forecast. So you're talking soft landing? Yes. So I think the chances are good that we'll see the economy slow, inflation return to Target without too much damage to the labor market, which would be a really good outcome.