“Simplicity over complexity”: Endowment investing strategy
“Simplicity over complexity”: Endowment investing strategy
About this video
Richard McDougall from Hamilton12 shares his views on a recent study into the role of endowments in generating market returns. Richard reveals that the research, carried out by respected scholar Richard Ennis, challenges the notion that university endowments, especially from leading institutions, stand above others in institutional asset management. The investigations found that contrary to the common perception, substantial endowments may not always result in increased investment performance. The project scrutinised if such endowments genuinely hold a competitive edge in obtaining above-average risk-adjusted returns over time.
For the study, 41 large U.S. endowments were examined over 15 fiscal periods from 2009 to 2023. The study's findings show that endowments considered traditionally superior, such as Duke, Harvard, and Yale, were not placed in the top quartile performance over this designated time frame. Instead, endowments from lesser-known institutions like the University of Missouri and Michigan State yielded better results. These institutions employ less complicated investment strategies, demonstrating that complexity does not necessarily equate to success in investment.
In interpreting this research, Richard suggests emphasising transparency, simplicity, and cost-effectiveness when making investment decisions. He also stresses the importance of a long-term perspective and discourages making hasty resolutions based on fleeting market fluctuations. Above all, he advocates viewing investment returns from an after-tax perspective as these are what carry the most weight for investors.
Below is the full unedited transcript of this interview:
0:00
Do endowments influence market returns? Let's get into the results of a study for some insights on how endowment performance complained to investment strategies. With Richard McDougall from Hamilton12. Hi Richard, good to see you. Just tell us what we can be doing in this space. Julia. Good morning. Um, look, as an investment manager that focuses our decisions on, um, evidence based research and data, from time to time, we come across a piece of research that we think is worth sharing with investors in this particular piece of research, uh, by Richard Ennis, who is a well-regarded researcher in terms of investment performance, um, was motivated by the common belief that university endowments, particularly those of leading institutions, um, are superior in the realm of institutional investing. So when we think of endowment, we typically think that, you know, they're quite sophisticated in terms of having access to investment opportunities that the ordinary investor might not have access to. Uh, they have pricing power. And all of these competitive advantages, advantages really should lead
0:59
to, um, an outperformance of investment returns relative to the average investor. So this particular study examined whether those endowments truly hold a competitive advantage in achieving above market risk adjusted returns over time. And when you see some of the main findings from this report, you studied 41 large US endowments. What were some of the their findings? And I guess what prompted this research to return? Yeah. So so you're right. Uh, 41 large US endowments over 15 fiscal years or in our term, um, calendar years. These are US fiscal years from 2009 to 2023. And it found that the annualized excess return of the endowments was, uh, -0.9%. So really, that indicated an underperformance relative to the benchmark that was used. And we'll talk about that, uh, in 12 of the 15 years examined. So really, it's suggested that the endowment is a
1:59
group generally failed to justify the higher costs associated with their active management strategies. And so naturally, that leads to the question, well, what was the benchmark that was used here? And was one of the things that we had a deep dive on to really understand whether it was a fair and rigorous comparison. So Richard, who did the research, um, use three main broad based indices. So he did have a look at all of the endowments and really to gain an understanding of what investments were sitting in their portfolios and then basically put together what he termed a statistically fitted, broad market, um, uh, benchmark that was fair and rigorous in terms of his comparison. So he had 61% of his benchmark in the Russell 3000. And that's an index that measures the performance of the largest, uh, 3000 US companies, which represents approximately 96% of the investable US equity market. He had 22% in the MSCI all country world index. So
2:59
effectively, uh, an index that captures large and mid-cap stocks across 23 or 22, rather of the 23 developed markets, so excluded the US and 24 emerging market countries. So that index has about 2200 constituents, covers approximately 85% of the global equity opportunity set outside of the US. And then finally, 17% of Richard's benchmark was in the Bloomberg US AG index. And that's a broad based, uh, I guess, flagship benchmark that measures the investment grade of US dollar denominated, uh, fixed rate, uh, fixed rate, taxable bond markets. So there was some really surprising results that came out of this study that really investors can take away. But the study revealed that the endowments traditionally considered elite, like those of Duke, uh, Harvard and Yale, didn't actually rank in the top quartile performance over the past 15 years. And conversely, those endowments from institutions like the University of
3:58
Missouri and Michigan State, which tend to adopt less complex investment strategies, and I guess less noted for their investment prowess, they performed relatively better when compared to the, uh, the more established and well known endowments. Um, Richard, I'm just curious is how investors can apply the insights from this study into their own strategy. I was looking at some of the considerations. The simplicity over complexity theme looks quite interesting.
4:28
Yeah. Look, the natural question we always ask when looking at a piece of research is so what? And particularly so what for the Australian investor. We've tried to break this research down. We've had a deep dive in and broken it down into six key, uh, components or themes, but really the simplicity over complexity. So the study indicated that the most complex, actively managed strategies didn't actually consistently outperform the more simpler, more transparent investments. So really, as an investor, um, investors should be considering that when selecting. Investment products now on a pre-tax basis. Um, index funds or broadly diversified portfolios often provide, uh, competitive returns with lower fees compared to actively managed funds. We see that every six months in the reports that show, you know, whether it be 1 in 10 managers over, say, 15 to 20 years or 1 in 5 managers over over ten years, um, outperform the market. The rest really struggle. Those reports are on a pre-tax basis
5:27
now in Australia. We know that on an after tax basis, the percentage of investment strategies that outperform the market over the medium to longer term, particularly those that focus on imputation or franking credits, those strategies tend to outperform at a much higher rate than those strategies that don't. And really that's due to the research that indicates the benefit of franking credits and not priced into share prices of ordinary shares on average. So investors are essentially receiving the benefits of franking credits or imputation for free, which is leading to an outperformance relative to the broader market. Um, there's a couple of other points that we've summarised there. Um, certainly on fees and returns. Um, really important to make sure that you're concentrating or focusing on, um, uh, fee because they really can arrive returns over time. Um, just because a manager or a strategy has higher fees certainly doesn't mean that it's going to equate to higher returns. So, Richard,
6:27
what kind of advice then would you give based on, on the findings and what you've seen in this report to. Yeah, look, long term perspective is really important. So this research spanned over 15 years. It demonstrated the importance of evaluating investments over longer periods. Um, investors really should maintain a long term perspective and avoid making impulsive decisions based on short term market fluctuations. Incredibly relevant at the moment. You know, only a few months ago we were talking about interest rates coming down. We're now talking about interest rates staying where they are for longer. It's leading to a fair bit of volatility in the market. Um, markets don't move in straight lines. There is a fair bit of volatility. So it's really important to take a longer term perspective. But really summarizing um, the research, you know, prioritize transparency, uh, simplicity and cost efficiency in any investment choice. And look at investment returns from an after tax perspective, remembering it's the after tax returns that truly matter.
7:28
Um, and and really that's what investors should be focusing on.