Should investors just buy the index?
Should investors just buy the index?
About this video
Richard McDougall from Hamilton12 joins us to share his views on the Spiva Australia year-end 2022 results, emphasizing important aspects for investors to keep in mind. Richard explains that Spiva reports, which compare actively managed funds to their index benchmarks globally, serve as the unofficial scorekeeper in the active versus passive debate. Richard highlights the key takeaways, pointing out the difficulties Australian equity general funds faced during the second half of 2022, resulting in a full-year underperformance rate of 57.6%. He also brings attention to the high underperformance rates for international equity general funds and observes that most active managers typically underperform most of the time. Moreover, Richard addresses the headwinds faced by active managers, including market efficiency, the professionalization of listed markets, return skewness, and costs.
However, he asserts that active management can still have a place in a portfolio when mixed with systematic investing, a rules-based approach backed by academic research. Using the Hamilton12 Australian Diversified Yield Index as an example, Richard demonstrates how an evidence-based, proven systematic strategy can outperform a pure index over the medium to long term. He encourages investors to explore such strategies alongside traditional approaches for an improved mix of performance outcomes.