Shift in equty outlook amid potential Fed cuts
Shift in equty outlook amid potential Fed cuts
About this video
Vishnu Varathan, a representative from Mizuho Bank, shares his perspective on the shifting market trends in the states. He observes that markets have gone from criticising the Federal Reserve (Fed) for too many cuts towards suggesting that too few may be priced in, primarily due to the uncertain distribution of voters regarding the number of cuts. Furthermore, Vishnu posits that the Fed could cut rates more, especially if disinflation is better than expected and given the mixed jobs data.
On a broader scale, Vishnu sees efforts to understand policy legs amidst an evolving environment. He expresses concern that the strength and resilience of consumers might be overestimated, hinting at a potential slowdown faster than the Fed expects. In contrast to the US, Vishnu notes that China is struggling with weak demand and a lack of consumer confidence, largely due to unresolved property issues, which suggests ongoing struggles with inflation.
Regarding the People's Bank of China (PBoC), Vishnu foresees difficulty in supporting both the economy and the currency, particularly due to the potential for large capital outflows. He also anticipates that the PBoC will prioritise the Renminbi's stability over excessive stimulus. Lastly, he expresses concern about the strained trade relationships between China, the U.S and the EU, noting the potential impact on global aggregate demand.
Below is an unedited version of the transcript:
0:00
Let's return now to what we're seeing out of the states. With hawkish plot shifting from three cuts to just one this year. Vishnu Varathan joining us from Mizuho Bank to discuss the outlook. Vishnu. Good to catch up with you again. So in fact, we just heard from the latest Fed speaker overnight reiterating that expecting just one rate cut this year. What how does that play out on markets.
0:27
Well I think markets are probably taking a pretty, uh, balanced view of it, which I think it's, uh, really the way to go about it. So markets have now flipped from, you know, calling out the fed earlier, uh, saying that there's too many cuts priced in. Now I think markets are tipping towards saying see too few cuts may be priced in. And that's primarily because if you look at the the the distribution of the voters, uh, is fairly more evenly split between 1 and 2 cuts. So and even those who decided is just the one cut and not two have not removed the possibility of, uh, two cuts, uh, from from the table. Uh, I think the in concert, what it really means is that the fed is increasingly, uh, in a position where they're saying, look, we need to see disinflation and trenching and inflation coming lower before we cut, but really, they don't have to see that much, given that the economic projections that they put out
1:27
says they just require Copsey to get down to 2.8%, uh, for that one cut and we're already there. Uh, so if disinflation is better than expected, uh, the fed might be more comfortable to cut, especially with the mixed jobs data that suggests that, uh, you know, not everything is hunky dory despite the US exceptionalism narrative being maintained.
1:51
Yet, is it, um, uh, denial or just pushback we're seeing from the market at the moment? Um, essentially pricing in more than just one rate cut.
2:04
Yeah. I mean, and there's reason to really because, um, I think what really obfuscates the picture here is the politics around it, because markets now are in a position to say, uh, look, we just have got, uh, you know, two more meetings left for Q3 and two more left for Q4. We can comfortably put in two cuts. But the question is, will the fed want to move, uh, around the election? That's to say the September cut, the November cut, how do they look at it getting into the US presidential elections? And that could shorten the runway. So if you believe in a much more shortened runway and uncertainty around how quickly inflation comes down, you're more inclined to take the view. Yeah, maybe it's just the one cut. Whereas if you think the fed is just going to focus on its job, then the incoming data suggests that there are signs that the US economy is softening around the edges, even if it's not headed for a recession, which then suggests that, you know, with real
3:04
rates pretty high, uh, two cuts is certainly not excessive. If anything, it continues to be restrictive. Uh, so it depends which camp you land on. And I and I think, you know, no one is in a fixated camp depending on the data that are coming through. Uh, but meanwhile, the the election makes it harder to call this time around. So what are you seeing then more broadly in the US economy, that data what's it telling you about where the US economy is tracking? I guess how that actually informs those decisions in regards to monetary policy.
3:37
I think there's a huge struggle to figure out policy legs in particular. Um, you know, given that we're in a post-pandemic world where if Taylor Swift comes down to your economy, you just need to go for that concert, things like that. Such a, you know, our translating into the, the, the facade, if not illusion of, uh, a consumer that's unfettered, uh, by higher rates. And so there is a, there is a sense that and there's a risk of overestimating consumer resilience and strength, whereas if you take a closer look at consumer cash flows, and if you look at leading jobs, market indications such as quit rates, uh, the suggestion really is, you know, the consumer might be softening a little bit more than the data are suggesting, and the incoming data might, in fact, be consistent with the fed needing to cut a little bit more than they are suggesting right now. So even if you don't get into a proper recession, uh, consumer slowdown, that's going to come in a
4:37
little faster than the fed expects. Certainly, I think makes the case for the fed to cut more, which is perhaps why markets are, uh, are not fully buying the one and done for 2024 story, uh, especially if they track it a little further out in the context of evolving, uh, data. Another point to be made is to say even in the, uh, in the instance of very strong data such as the US ism, the the things such as, uh, you know, the, the new orders components suggest that pipeline demand is not as strong as coincident demand. And so it's a highly evolving environment. Meanwhile, a very different story in China, of course, a major trading partner of the US where look, I mean, essentially it was trying to deal with deflation. Um, how is that panning out now? Uh, in terms of, I guess, that weak demand we're seeing in China.
5:35
I mean, to put it simply, it seems fairly chronic. Uh, especially if you were to pass the numbers to look at the underlying confidence. Uh, or rather, the absence of confidence. Uh, whilst, you know, the latest retail sales numbers that came out slightly surprised on the upside, there are two things about it. One is that, you know, it's still at 4%. It is not holding up the economy. Uh, the economy is held up by, you know, the manufacturing engine and exports and so on and so forth. And the other point around it is that the consumption patterns are also consistent with smaller cash outlays for relief, rather than the big cash outlays based on confidence. So auto sales are languishing. And this suggests that as long as the property problem is not resolved, uh, the confidence of uh consumers remains undermined in an economy that perhaps isn't creating as many jobs or new graduates. And these things have an impact on the psyche. Uh, and, and I think the, you know, the fact of the matter
6:35
is, even if inflation were to pick up, it cannot be conflated with, uh, consumer confidence on, on a broad based, uh, ment just yet. It is premature to conclude that. And so China is not, you know, isolated from the rest of the world that is struggling to get inflation down, but rather, uh, it's a, it's really a byproduct of, of that, that vacuum created by the property market where, you know, demand continues to languish. So, Vishnu, how do you see the PBoC balancing, uh, that equation between supporting the economy and supporting the currency?
7:15
With huge difficulty would be the short answer. Yeah. I mean, uh, I mean, one of the problems with that is, you know, we are trying to track, uh, on the run kind of PBoC impetus to hold up the renminbi. And they are now leaning against the pressures on the renminbi with the intensity that's equivalent to what we saw in 2015, 2016, if not greater than that. So on a weekly basis, they are leaning against anywhere between 8 to 10%. Um, in terms of flagging that, you know, that maybe needs to be held up. That suggests that they are very concerned about huge capital outflows. And if they were to be excessively stimulative and leading to further see, you know, renminbi pressures, they could end up losing another trillion dollars just to defend the renminbi. And this is, you know, patently unacceptable from a policy standpoint, which is why a lot of the stimulus measures would have to rope in either the policy banks to support property or central
8:15
government spending, and not so much by way of headline, uh, rate cuts or liquidity driven stimulus, which is why the credit data also remains somewhat mixed rather than overtly stimulating, uh, stimulative for the economy. This is a trade off that the PBoC will find no easy solution to. And my guess is, uh, renminbi stabilities will still take quite a bit of priority, which means we are not to expect, you know, a huge cutting spree by the the PBoC. Instead, what might be par for the course is measured triple R cuts, uh, and very targeted credit and liquidity provision uh, complemented by central government stimulus. And Vishnu just to round off. How close are you watching those trade relationship between China and well, certainly the US as we head into the um November election there, but also the EU in
9:14
particular, with both targeting Chinese EVs with massive tariffs, the Chinese appearing to retaliate, certainly in the form of pork at least we're hearing how how are you watching that?
9:27
Uh, with some concern. Uh, but, you know, this was, uh, this was really a move that we saw coming. Uh, the European automakers have been under a lot of pressure, uh, you know, in the midst of, of of, uh, the Chinese EV story and really, the US just set the backdrop for Europe to normalize some degree of sanctions, and we cannot expect, uh, China not to retaliate. Uh, and the question, really, for the rest of us is what it means for global aggregate demand. I mean, we we we should fully expect that the evolving and medium term story would be one of hedging out of China, trans shipping, setting up bases elsewhere, not just for, uh, other producers, but for Chinese themselves. But in the very near term, it's going to have a fairly, uh, you know, uh, deleterious impact on, on the the nascent recovery we are seeing in global manufacturing as a whole.