S&P's SPIVA Scorecard: 55% of equity general funds underperform to benchmark indices
About this video
Richard McDougall of Hamilton12 explains the outcomes of equity general funds as per the S&P's SPIVA Scorecard.
According to the scorecard, half of 2023 saw an underperformance of these funds in comparison to the benchmark index. Richard discusses statistical elements such as return skewness, and presents an example that explains how an understanding of market skewness can affect a fund's outcomes. He underscores that markets skewed in a positive direction often interfere with the performance of concentrated active managers.
In addition to this, Richard says that diversification plays a vital role in the potency of investments, even when dealing with markets with a positive skew. Based on this, Richard recommends a diversification strategy for investors to hold stocks that supersede market performance.
Find the full unedited transcript of this interview below:
0:00
Well. SNP's Spiva scorecard shows that 55% of equity general funds underperformed the benchmark index in the first half of 2023. Let's get some context on that now from Richard McDougall from Hamilton12, who joins us to discuss the potential reasons for this underperformance. So what are the reasons and what does it mean for investors?
0:23
Yeah. Juliette good morning. So just by way of reminder, the SPV reports are a series of reports that Standard and Poor's produce every six months. And Spiva is an acronym for Standard and Poor's Index versus active. So these reports measure the performance of active managers relative to their appropriate benchmarks over a number of periods of time, certainly across geographic locations and a number of listed listed asset classes. The producer reports every six rows. So the mid-year 2023 results have just been released. And as you mentioned, the results are fairly consistent every six months when these reports come out. Most active managers again are underperforming most of the time. And as that observation period lengthens, the higher portion of active managers tend to underperform. So in the most recent results, again depending on
1:23
the type of listed asset class, again these are Australian results. Anywhere from 45 to 90% underperformed their appropriate benchmarks year to date, and unsurprisingly and fairly consistently across periods. If you go out five, ten and 15 years, anywhere from 80 to 90% of active managers are underperforming relative to their respective benchmarks.
1:46
All right. So when you look at some of the I guess, the concepts as well in terms of this return skewness, I note that you're looking at some of the returns from 2002 to 2022. That's a very wide range. What have you actually seen in some of the S&P 500 returns? Yeah. So so there are a number of conceptual and mathematical reasons as to why active managers find outperformance so challenging. The concept of return skewness was actually something that S&P mentioned in their most recent report for the Australian market. By way of example, though, if we look at the S&P 500 returns for the last 20 years, and really this is just showing the number of constituents in the S&P 500 on a percentage basis. And what they returned over that over that 20 year period.
2:33
In this particular example here, you can see that that that any of the names or the constituents that were to the right of the average marker, which is about 1 in 5 of the S&P 500 constituents over that period, they're the names that actually outperformed the market average over that period. The concept of return skewness. If you think about stocks, they're not the stock returns aren't normally distributed. A stock can only go down by 100%, but it can obviously go up by much more than that. So a simple indicator of positive skewness, as you can see here over the last 20 years, is when the average return is greater than the median return for the S&P 500. That's happened 27 times of the last 32 years. Now, when you look at this on a on a less extreme basis, if you take single years into account, this returns skewness can be positive or negative. So again if you've got positive
3:32
skewness fewer than half of the constituents in let's use the ASX 200in this example
3:40
outperform the broader market. If you have negative skewness, more than half outperform the broader market. So S&P touched on this in in their most recent report. And generally
3:52
a positively skewed distribution of equity returns. It's been a key hindrance for for more concentrated active managers globally as outperformance tends to be driven by a few winners, as I've just explained. And Australia is certainly no exception to that for the S&P ASX 200. Market returns were positively skewed in five out of the past ten years and certainly through the first half of 2023. So what that should tell you is that active managers have a better than fair chance of owning stocks that should outperform the market, but we're just not seeing that. And perhaps and perhaps it's not coincidental. Two out of the three years when most Australian equity general funds outperformed, they were during years when market returns were negatively skewed again, meaning more than half of the stocks in the ASX 200. Excuse me, better than the market average.
4:49
I sneeze then? Sorry, I thought my mic was down, but I don't think it was sorry. Okay, now I've caught. I've caught the cold there from Wall Street. As they like to say. That old joke you're talking there about some of the big returns, of course. But what about when it comes to the negative skewness and how that's coincided with the majority outperformance over the last couple of years? Yeah, so that's what you'd expect to see. You would expect to see if there's a negatively skewed market, you're going to see more than half of the constituents across the market. In this case, the ASX 200
5:20
have outperformed the market average. So that actually plays into the the active managers favour. They should be outperforming the market when the market is negatively skewed. Now you know, what does that mean. Essentially for an investor most active portfolios are relatively concentrated. So when you couple that with skewness, a higher concentration will imply that the majority of assets are likely to underperform. So if performance is driven by a small number of stocks, the more concentrated a portfolio is, the less likely it is to to own the big winners. So for investors, when you when you build an investment portfolio, it's normal to lean towards investing in in what you know best. You might have a few tech names, or you might like a few familiar stocks from from your home market. But while that might give you a portfolio that feels comfortable, it's far from bulletproof because it lacks one key element, which is diversification. The more stocks you hold in
6:20
your portfolio, the greater chance, even in positively skewed markets, that you're going to own some names that have outperformed the market. The beauty of diversification is that it's possible to reduce risk while maintaining or improving returns of the portfolio.