Risky business: why consistency matters in managing your portfolio | the advisory
Risky business: why consistency matters in managing your portfolio | the advisory
About this video
Stephen Gulbrandson, from Morgans, highlights the essence of consistency and process in managing portfolio risk. Stressing the importance of consistent management of portfolio theory, Stephen underscores that one can only mitigate three risks - investment risk, market risk and timing risk. In terms of the investment risk, Stephen clarifies the decision-making in choosing investments like BHP (ASX:BHP) or ANZ (ASX:ANZ) leans heavily on extensive research from their analyst team, Morningstar and Lonsdale. This ensures their recommended companies within the Australian share component have a high chance of outperforming the market.
Queried on risk monitoring and control, Stephen explains that they can somewhat eliminate market risk via diversification of about 20 odd shares in a specific market, most of which are in Australian share management. The secondary risk of timing risk is managed by strong capital management, where scrupulous decisions on whether to trim, buy, add or hold a share are made, especially if a share performs poorly over time. He affirms, over time, all stocks owned should be winners within a portfolio, given its diversified foundation.
Responding to concerns over excessive industry regulation, Stephen draws a distinction between compliance-driven regulation and that which makes the industry better. He lauds changes focusing on client goals and Socially Responsible Investing (SRI) quality. However, he notes some regulatory obligations, like fee disclosures, add unproductive work. Stephen suggests a disclosure on risk taken for a certain return should be introduced. He identifies the biggest idiosyncrasy in the industry being the same balance fund having different meanings in different places.
Full unedited transcript below:
0:00
Well, let's move into financial planning and discuss the value of consistency and process in managing portfolio risk. Joining me now is Stephen Gould Brunson from Morgans. You're looking here about consistency and process. Just start with consistency and how important it is Stephen.
0:17
Well every time you make a decision you're basically taking risk with someone's money. So whenever we're looking at, well, how do we invest money? How do we make it all all work? We're basically looking on portfolio theory, which has been around since 1962. So there's nothing we're really doing to to differently. It's just about how do you consistently manage that that approach. So effectively, there are only really three risks that we can do too much about. There's portfolio risks in terms of investment risk market risk and timing risk. Now we can't pretend that we we know more than the market if we go down the premise that the market is efficient, then we got to understand that the information that we're receiving within that market is, is creating that efficiency. So what we can do is try and minimize, minimize some of the risk that people are taking unnecessarily. And a lot of that time is not having a process that can be replicated. And in addition to that, it's
1:17
the timing of the changes that people make is generally irrational or counterproductive to long term performance. So if we go back to the three risks that we really as financial advisors and stockbrokers we work on, it comes down to investment. Risk is primarily the one that I'll focus on initially, and investment risk is whether or not I'm recommending a BHP or an ANZ. And what foundation do we have to to rely on that information. So we have an analyst team and we use Morningstar research. We use Lonsdale research. We use our own in order to make sure that the companies that we're recommending within, say, an Australian share component, I have a higher chance of outperforming the market and providing alpha to to our clients. Realistically, if we get investment risk wrong and you invest in too many things that can theoretically or through probability, go to zero. That's where you're taking
2:17
unnecessary risk in that, that that part of the portfolio. And I try and avoid that. So about consistency it's not necessarily trying to manage a portfolio to make someone 24 if they're trying. Well, if they need to get 10% in order to meet all their goals of, uh, of meeting living standards. And they're like, so again, it's about creating the framework within the portfolio that allows them to meet their goals rather than get a, uh, a risk return, which is unnecessary for, for them.
2:51
Um, Stephen, if I can just interrupt, how do you sort of monitor and control some of these portfolio risks?
2:57
Well, again, with within portfolio risk if we have. So we can eliminate market risk to some extent by up to about 20 odd shares within a specific market. So that's one way diversification through through different investments. So we specialize in Australian share management. And most of my portfolio will have between 15 and 25 stocks within the Australian share component. So we manage the risk around those specific investments which comes to the secondary risk of timing risk by good strong capital management. So if a share has performed poorly over a period of time, it doesn't necessarily mean that we need to to change it, but it does prompt the decision to do capital management. So do we trim it? Do we buy it. We add it. Do we hold it? So again, if you get the capital management right, and then you take the premise that over a period of time, all stocks that you should generally own will be winners within a
3:57
portfolio. Since the time duration that will change capital management will allow you to basically get through business cycles and ensure that the portfolio return of that investment doesn't diminish from the overall. Mhm.
4:11
Um, Stephen, there's been a lot of focus on regulation in the space and some saying too much regulation. What do you think um is a positive change from all the reviews. And what do you think could still be done?
4:24
Yeah. So there's two different kinds of regulations, I guess. So the one that I think would make us better, and one that is a purely compliance driven tool. So we've got to understand that there have been changes within the industry that have lasted probably since 2012, when they initially started getting proposed, all the way up until till today. So a lot of the changes in terms of social SWA quality, focus on client goals, these are made us better. I can't say that they've made us any, any, any worse. So in terms of the story of which an SEO should deliver to a client in terms of why they came to see you versus what you're recommending to meet those goals. They're all very, very powerful things. So I think they improved the industry as a as a general as a whole. Then you've got another part of the compliance obligations, which is more about fee disclosures, for example. And I'm a big believer that people should go into a relationship knowing everything about it, and they should be reminded what that arrangement is for
5:24
some of the the necessities, in order to opt in every year in the two stages. To do that, both through our office and through platform providers, for example, create additional work that I don't think makes a client any better, better off. Then there's ones which I think should be brought into to the industry, and that's the disclosure on how much risk that someone is taking for their general return. And one of the biggest, I guess, idiosyncrasies within an industry is that balance funds mean two different things in two different places. Yeah. Our balance fund might be 5050 or 6040 with a growth bias down the road, it could be 8020.