Reporting season small cap outperformers
Reporting season small cap outperformers
About this video
Key points:
Small caps show promising outlook with expected earnings growth over 10% in two years
Financials sector sees stronger performance; resources sector faces downgrades
Mining services reveal potential cyclical earnings upside despite previous headwinds
Michael Steele from Yarra Capital Management discusses the performance of small caps during the reporting season. He notes that despite a challenging year with earnings declines, the outlook for small companies is positive, with expectations of over 10% earnings growth in the next two years.
Michael highlights that the financials sector performed better than expected, driven by cyclical headwinds subsiding and market share gains. Strong results were seen from Judo Bank (ASX: JDO) and Pinnacle Investment Management (ASX: PNI). Conversely, the resources sector faced earnings downgrades, particularly in commodities like lithium and iron ore.
Mining services, including companies like Imdex (ASX:IMD), presented a mixed outlook. While exploration spend reduced, forward indicators suggest potential cyclical earnings upside. Michael remains optimistic about small caps in Australia, anticipating a similar rotation towards small companies as seen in the US when interest rates begin to decrease.
Full unedited transcript:
0:11
Well, let's return to reporting season as it comes to an end. How the small caps performed, and particularly as far as the outlook is concerned, Michael Steele is joining us from Yarra Capital Management. Michael, good to catch up with you again. In fact we've just caught up with another small cap overall. What's your assessment of what you've seen and heard from this reporting season?
0:33
Andrew, good to be with you. In terms of the small companies reporting season, there was no doubt it was a challenging year in the last 12 months for financial year 2024 with earnings declining. But more importantly, when you look forward, reporting season did give us confidence that earnings growth would reaccelerate going forward over the next two years in terms of those outcomes for the 2024 financial year. We saw earnings decline was a continuation of the prior year, where we had macroeconomic headwinds with pressure on earnings from lower volumes, margin pressure and the high cost of debt. And that led to earnings declines. And in particular, that was evident in sectors such as industrials and property trusts that saw earnings decline.
1:19
But more importantly is that that outlook that we're focused on, and we expect earnings growth for small companies over the next two years to reaccelerate over 10%, which is really quite a positive outlook. If you maintain that broader outlook, can you break this down into performance of sectors at the moment? Perhaps which ones that have impressed, which ones have disappointed?
1:40
Two sectors of note during the reporting season were financials from a positive perspective and resources were quite negative. So in terms of financials, we saw a broad based better than expected earnings as we saw some of these cyclical headwinds moderate and actually turned to be supportive for earnings and also continued market share, which is a broad based trend in the small companies market. And two notable results in that financial sector were strong results from judo Bank and Pinnacle Investment Management.
2:12
In terms of resources, it was really quite negative with earnings downgrades. You had the negative impact of low commodity prices coming through, in particular lithium prices and iron ore. But a trend that we've seen over a number of reporting seasons is this continued downgrade of the more marginal producers where they downgrade their production. And that leads to large earnings downgrades for the resources companies.
2:37
So in a related sector, the mining services, how did you view that. Because I see you're looking at index.
2:46
Mining services overall actually was quite positive as well. You saw a number of companies report better than expected results or improvements in the outlook and index is one of those where we've got a positive view. Um, index is a company that provides technology and consumables to the mining industry, and they're a global leader with very much a global business, massive opportunity for index to gain market share going forward, selling their technologies such as directional drilling to new customers, but also is a large opportunity to sell their full product suite to existing customers, to a large market share opportunity there for them. Also, there's cyclical earnings upside for index. The result face challenges from exploration spend reducing by 24% in the market over the last 12 months. That's been a big headwind. But if you look forward, we think there's actually cyclical earnings upside. Uh, you've got supportive forward indicators such as high gold prices,
3:46
higher copper prices. And that's a lead indicator to exploration spend improving. It's also an attractive business in the sense that it's capital light. There's quite low levels of capital expenditure. We expect the business to move to a net cash position over the next 12 months. It's also attractive when you consider the technology assets they've got from a valuation perspective. It's back to a P multiple of only 20 times on cyclically depressed earnings and in very high quality earnings, because they expense the vast majority of their R&D and other costs.
4:18
So, Michael, overall, given what you've heard from the small caps this reporting season, how do you view that space going forward, given clearly the pressure the small caps have been under the past couple of years? We have seen the beginnings of some something of a rotation back into small caps. Do you think that is going to go momentum.
4:43
We remain very positive on the outlook for small companies going forward. There's a number of reasons to support that. Firstly, they've materially underperformed since the end of county 2022. They've now underperformed the ASX 100, with the largest 100 companies by close to 29%. Over that period, they've significantly underperformed. We believe from a macro perspective, when you start to see interest rate reductions, uh, you see small companies start to outperform around and after interest rate reductions. Another major factor to be positive on for small companies is the accelerating earnings growth outlook that I spoke to. And we expect that to really accelerate the next two years. And also valuation metrics are back to attractive levels for small companies with one year forward P of only 15 times on depressed earnings. Certainly, if we look at what's going on in the States and the small cap space, there is a lot of optimism there. Given, of course, the fed is about to start cutting
5:42
rates. However, a different story here with the prospect perhaps rates are going to remain on hold, albeit at a lower level than we've seen in the States. So
5:51
do you think perhaps it's going to be a little more delayed here, that we're going to get some, some movement behind the small caps?
5:59
That's a good point, Andrew. And, uh, we spoke last time about the positive lead indicator from the US small companies market where inflation's come down. The market's got confidence that interest rates are coming down in the short term. And that started to cause quite a dramatic rotation towards small companies in the US. And we believe that's a good lead indicator to what will happen in Australia. But to your question the issue is in Australia, interest rate reductions are going to lag the US. So you haven't started to see small companies in Australia outperform yet. They actually underperformed the largest 100 companies over the last month and a half, uh, because of some of these short term earnings challenges. But if you look forward and you're getting into next calendar year being calendar year 25, we actually start to see interest rate reductions in Australia. We we believe, will be a similar environment where small companies start to outperform, similar to that lead indicator in the US.