Private credit risks might be overdone
Private credit risks might be overdone
About this video
Key points:
Rising redemptions and fund gating seen as highlighting manager-specific weaknesses rather than market-wide failure
Software concentrations up to 50% in some private credit portfolios viewed as a major risk and sign of poor diversification
Geopolitical shocks, including the Middle East conflict, seen as potential tests of weakened lending standards
Manager selection, strict covenants and diversified sector exposure emphasised as critical for private credit investors
Joe Unwin from Apostle Funds sets out a cautious but constructive view on private credit, pointing to rising redemptions and media scrutiny as reflections of manager-specific issues rather than systemic deterioration. Unwin notes that some large private credit managers are seeing tens of millions of dollars of redemptions from retail vehicles, often alongside gating mechanisms that restrict withdrawals. He links recent concerns to earlier high-profile corporate defaults and comments from JPMorgan’s Jamie Dimon about “cockroaches”, which, in his view, have heightened fears of hidden risks.
Unwin highlights significant dispersion between managers. He cites research indicating average software exposure of around 28% in listed private credit portfolios, with some as high as 50%, and argues that such concentration in a single sector signals weak risk management and poor diversification. By contrast, he points to other portfolios with software exposure near 2% and broad industry diversification as examples of more disciplined approaches.
Geopolitical risk, including the Middle East conflict, is described as a potential systemic shock that could expose managers who have loosened lending standards, reduced covenants and increased leverage. Unwin stresses that manager selection, consistent underwriting standards, strong covenants, sector diversification and a focus on the US core middle market remain central to managing private credit risk.