NextDC trading beyond the Covid bubble?
About this video
Jason Teh from Vertium Asset Management discusses the current condition of the stock market with focus on AI driven stocks and certain banks. He observes that geopolitical risks are taking a backseat, while AI stocks and the strength of the US economy are fuelling the rise in bond yields. He mentions that despite major geopolitical events such as the Iranian attack on Israeli airspace, the market is more influenced by factors like retail sales figures and bond yields increase.
Delving deeper, Jason focuses on the future prospects of tech stocks like NextDC (NXT), which is capitalising on the AI boom despite high valuations. Jason underscores that while the business has seen growth and is benefitting from the AI boom, the stock is trading beyond its Covid bubble valuation, hinting that share price returns may be dismal over the next few years. He also touches upon Goodman Group, noting that while it also taps into the data centre sphere, it offers a little more safety given its less exorbitant valuation in comparison to NextDC.
Finally, Jason focuses on Commonwealth Bank of Australia (CBA), citing that its stock price increase defies belief given its earnings remain stagnant compared to the previous years. It’s highlighted that the bank is currently trading on pure sentiment and it may not sustain high stock prices without substantial growth in earnings. He acknowledges that CBA is the best option among Aussie banks, given its substantial market share in Australia and its high operating leverage. However, Jason warns that the entire banking industry has seen reduced profitability over time, thus it is essential for the market to witness significant increment in earnings.
Below is the full unedited transcript of this interview:
0:00
Let's now take a look at, uh, specific stock wise, at least with AI driven stocks. Jason Teh joining us from Vertium Asset Management for a deep dive, particularly on, well, what has been a beneficiary with the AI next week. And also taking a look at some of the banks as well. Jason, good to catch up with you again. Um of course. Well, actually, might start with a broader look from your perspective on what we're seeing on the market at the moment. What are your observations? Uh, look, I mean, obviously I just, uh, overheard your conversation in regards to geopolitical risk. I think that's taking a sideshow in regards to, um, what's going on with bond yields. Right. Because I guess from from geopolitics, this is the most well telegraphed Iranian attack on, on on the Israeli airspace. Right. So they had plenty of time to prepare for it, uh, and shoot down those drones. So, um, you know, and that's, that's why it's sort of not playing out as what people would expect. But but in terms
0:59
of, uh, stronger retail sales, look, that just feeds on, uh, you know, the strength of the US economy and obviously the rise in bond yields and, and the rise in bond yields has an impact on, you know, valuations, um, as you would expect. And I suspect that's why the market is our market. And the US market has been um, you know, I guess um, permitted a little bit, um, you know, in the last few sessions. Yeah. Which is continuing today obviously as well, given it is down, uh, over 1%. Jason, let's get stock specific. And as I was alluding to at the beginning of the year, um, going to focus on a couple of stocks, the first one being certainly a beneficiary of what we've seen in AI next week and in fact, looking to expand given the demand it's seeing at the moment with the recent capital raise, how do you view that stock? Uh, look, I mean, I always sort of look at valuations in context of, uh, the Covid bubble. You know, the Covid
1:59
bubble, uh, was in 2021 when, um, you know, valuations got very stretched. So, so Nick Stacy was trading on pretty rich multiples around that time. And, you know, everybody thought it was a safe haven and, you know rushed towards it. And now obviously it's it's a beneficiary of the AI boom. Um so look earnings have grown. So there's nothing wrong with the business. And you know, in terms of, you know, capitalizing on the, uh, growth in that data center space. And obviously AI is going to help. But the valuation is so rich. You know, it's in fact, it's trading, um, beyond its Covid bubble valuation. And obviously they're taking advantage of the very high share price, uh, for that future growth opportunity. But, um, um, you know, I, you know, despite that, earnings would benefit from the AI boom. I don't think, uh, the share price would continue to rewrite. Um, and I reckon you're going to see, uh, some pretty poor returns from a share price perspective in the next couple of years.
2:57
Would that apply? I don't know when you've taken a look at Goodman Group. It's also trying to get into the data centers as well. Um, do you have a particular view on Goodman? Yeah. So so Goodman Group, um, has also benefited from, um, the rewrites as well from, you know, the data center, uh, focus that they're targeting the business towards. Um, but it is nowhere near as expensive as, um, as Nick's DC. I mean, Nick's DC, like, it's multiple of, like, 50 times enterprise value to EBITDA, like Goodman Group is nowhere near that. And also compare it to history. Goodman Group is not actually trading, uh, beyond its 2021, uh, peak. So, so, you know, so so there is a little bit of margin of safety, uh, with Goodman Group, um, although both sort of play in a similar space. Um, but, uh, you know, next is, is definitely more expensive than Goodman Group.
3:54
So let's switch now to the financials and
3:59
many myths as to how far they've run. Recently you've got to focus in particular on CBA, which I mean just how expensive is it at the moment. Do you feel? Yeah. So look, at least when we talk about Knicks DC or Goodman Group, you know, um, you know, at least they have a thematic, you know, uh, in terms of earnings growth, the AI boom, the AI boom will definitely, uh, lead to earnings growth next year. And Goodman Group. But for CBA like, you know Australia's biggest uh stock right. It's just defies belief. Like where is the look. And it's totally understandable. During the Covid lockdowns there was a housing boom. So you know CBA rerated but where is the housing boom uh, on the horizon for for the Aussie banks. Right. So, um, you know, competition is still very high in the space. You know, Nim you know, look, it's probably going to stabilize at this current rate, but like, it is not going to, you know, expand going
4:58
forward, uh, because of competition. But um, but you know, this, this chart highlights like, you know, CBA has the same forecast earnings as it did back in 2014, 2015. Right. But the share price is 40% higher. So basically the PE is a lot higher than where it is today. Right then that like over the last 20 years is 21 times P is is the cream like can it go higher. Like who knows? I mean it's just pure sentiment that is trading on at the moment. Um, so um, it is record, uh, you know, it's even more expensive than DC at least next DC uh, for, you know, you know, for the next few years you can grow earnings, uh, into its extreme valuation. But CBA like we'll do we ever think it's only going to be 40% higher over the next five years. Right. It's it's just defies belief. So what you say purely trading on sentiment is that almost like a proxy for the broader market then. Pretty much. Right. So so like
5:58
the banks in itself like have about 20%, uh, share of the market in terms of market cap. So, um, we haven't seen an uptick in earnings for bank. So and because of that large heavyweight in terms of the Aussie market, the market has rerated quite a lot over the last six months, but without, uh, an increase in the corresponding earnings. Yes. At the underlying level, there's some stocks that have grown earnings, but like the banks haven't grown earnings right with a massive PE rerating. So um, you know they have actually dragged the market up with it right. And without earnings. Right. Um you know share prices do. Correct. Right. So so uh, we need to see earnings pick up for especially big segments of the market. Otherwise the market is prone for correction.
6:48
How do you look at the broader financials there? CBA comparison with particularly the other big four Westpac, ANZ and eBay.
6:57
Yeah. So so the other four sorry. The other three, uh, you know obviously, you know, it would have a similar dynamics, you know, um, you know, tepid industry loan growth, competition still very high. Um, so again, from an earnings perspective, I can't see how, um, you know, all of them could have a huge recovery in earnings. Uh, look, by the way, like CBA is is the best out of the lot, right. So CBA has you know, um, is the biggest, uh, you know, bank in Australia. And hence because of that it has operating leverage, um, good operating leverage if there is a recovery, uh, it has is the highest ROE versus all the other banks. That's why it's the best of the lot. But the lot isn't great, you know, um, you know, I said CBA has the highest ROE versus the other peers, but it's ROE 13% like it is. It's not it's not like a CSL, like 13% is what you consider a very,
7:55
um, moderate boring company. Right? It is, it is uh, it's not the CBA that we used to know prior to the GFC. Right. So prior to the GFC, CBA used to have a 20% Roe. Uh, today is 13%. So,
8:09
um, it's not the same CBA, but it's just, you know, the whole banking industry is just being eroded, uh, you know, over time. And the profitability has, has, has been reduced.