Sign inJoin free

Watch / Economy

"New CEOs but same old mistakes...."

3 Oct 20245:54

"New CEOs but same old mistakes...."

General information only. ausbiz videos are general information only, produced by Ausbiz TV Pty Ltd, a media business that doesn’t give financial advice. They don’t take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Consider whether it’s right for you and read the PDS and TMD before acting on anything you watch.

About this video

Roger Montgomery from Montgomery Investment Management discusses the Australian consumer watchdog accusing Coles (ASX:COL) and Woolworths (ASX:WOW) of misleading shoppers about discounts. Roger notes the presence of new female CEOs at these supermarket chains and suggests their approach may differ, potentially offering a more sensitive and nuanced response.

Roger observes that Coles is defending accusations, while Woolworths adopts a more measured approach, which he views as beneficial for long-term brand value. Drawing parallels with past incidents like Qantas (ASX:QAN) and Exxon (NYSE:XOM) , Roger highlights the need for effective crisis management and suggests that transparency in pricing practices could enhance consumer trust.

Roger discussed that companies recognising and changing past practices could win market share. He suggests that while this issue might fade over time, the supermarket that enacts transparent change could significantly benefit. Roger hopes for a proactive approach from the supermarkets to improve customer perception.

Full unedited transcript below:

0:00

Australia's consumer watchdog, accusing the country's two largest supermarket chains of misleading shoppers about discounts on hundreds of products, tightening pressure on the sector amid the cost of living crisis. Roger Montgomery from Montgomery Investment Management joins me now for more. And I guess this also comes down to who's at the helm here. Roger.

0:19

Yeah. Look, um, the reality is that we have two new CEOs or relatively new CEOs, um, arguably with a very different mindset because fantastic news. You know, we've got two females, uh, two women heading our supermarkets. Their customers are typically women as well. And so you would think that the response to the axe accusations might be a little bit more nuanced, a bit more sensitive, uh, to what we've seen from past CEOs. Uh, I hope that will be the case, but that remains to be seen. Coles initially came out saying they're going to defend uh, the accusations will defend the company against the accusations. Uh, Woolworths took a more measured approach, saying that they'll consider, uh, the accusations and then consider their response. That gives them a better platform to respond in a more sensitive way such that they, um, they can take

1:19

into consideration their brand value, their long term brand value. I think both companies at the moment, and this is being reflected in their share prices. Both companies at the moment are doing a very, very poor job of crisis management. Um, if you go back all the way to let's put Qantas to one side where, you know, it was clear that short term profits, uh, were being prioritized over long term brand value. You can go all the way back to, um, a classic case study, uh, the 1989 spilling of 11,000, 11 million gallons of oil by the Exxon Valdez in, um, under Prince William Sound in Alaska. Uh, what were the two things? The company. And I'm only saying this because, by the way, this is a this is a case study that is, you know, has been given in business schools to business school marketing and branding classes since it happened. Um, they did two things wrong. Number one, the chairman at the

2:19

time didn't go to the site to visibly demonstrate taking control of the situation. And I think you've seen, uh, Coles not do that either, but you have seen Woolworths out at all the stores, Woolworths CEO going and visiting stores. Um, the second thing that Exxon did incorrectly was a lot of the public statements that they made, um, just didn't gel or weren't consistent with what was happening on the ground and what was being reported as happening on the ground. So that showed that there was a disinterest, uh, in, in this particular event. And that damaged not only the company, I mean long term, the company was fine, and the company is generating vastly more revenue today than it was generating back in 1989. But it really messed up approvals for offshore drilling, uh, in and around that area in the Arctic. Um, it was it was a huge problem for the entire industry because they did such a poor job of crisis

3:18

management. And at the moment I see Coles and Woolies, um, failing in their crisis management as well. What would be really great to see is, uh, rather than defending a practice that might be seen to be legal, um, uh, defending that practice, which by the consumers remember, this was all brought on by, by and by consumers pointing out these issues, uh, in Reddit posts and on Facebook, um, and so on. Um, so consumers perception is that the, the culture in these organisations, um, may be rotten that the pricing practices are Machiavellian. Uh, they're secretive and that needs to change. So defending oneself against the CQC really is just saying, you know what? What we're doing is legal and you might not like it, but we're going to continue doing it. Um, and I don't think that's great for the long term brand value, the supermarket that comes out first and

4:18

says, I stand before you today saying that the practices of the past, uh, aren't aren't fantastic. And we're going to change those practices. We're going to do things differently. We're going to do things that are more transparent. And and the first company to do that, uh, is, is going to win market share and is going to maintain that market share for a long time because the community and the media will be behind them. So that's what I'm hoping we'll see whether we see it or not. It's another thing, of course. Well, uh. Go ahead. I was just going to say, I mean, you touched on Qantas there, but I guess some of the lessons that we've learned from past instances like this and Exxon globally as well.

5:01

Yeah. Look, the the you know, the Qantas example is, is a recent one. And I'm sure that will be in the, you know, the minds of both CEOs as they think about how they go about, um, how they go about defending this. And as you can see in the share prices, you know, the the companies will survive, the companies will, um, will do well irrespective of this, this this will pass. This will be a storm in a teacup. And we'll all forget about it in five years time. But the company that responds differently, I firmly believe, uh, the company that responds, showing that the practices of the past are going to be changed, they will win a lot more market share, and they will do even better than they would have done otherwise. Uh, and that's the opportunity that is missed. If they don't actually, um, admit to the practices of the past being perhaps less desirable than what they're going to do in the future.

More like this

We value your privacy

We use essential cookies to make the site work. Non-essential cookies help us improve the experience. You can accept or reject non-essential cookies. Privacy policy