Sign inJoin free

Watch / Funds Management

Navigating private credit's grey areas

25 Oct 20237:36

Navigating private credit's grey areas

General information only. ausbiz videos are general information only, produced by Ausbiz TV Pty Ltd, a media business that doesn’t give financial advice. They don’t take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Consider whether it’s right for you and read the PDS and TMD before acting on anything you watch.

About this video

Patrick William from Rixon Capital joins us to draw attention to the potential conflicts of interest that may arise in private credit funds. He explains how these conflicts often arise when the managers of a credit fund also operate an equity fund or raise money for their private investments. Patrick describes this grey area, where loans from the credit fund may be dubious upon review, but are approved nonetheless to serve the equity fund's interest. He emphasizes that the prime motivation for these practices often lies in the appealing fee structure of equity funds. Furthermore, Patrick remarks that this pattern predominantly manifests in loans under $30 million. Finally, he advises that the allure of such funds does not ensure optimal utilization of your investment, urging investors to fully comprehend these dynamics prior to deploying their capital.

Find the full unedited transcript of this interview below:

0:00

Now we are turning to private credit funds. And Patrick William from Rixon Capital joins us to discuss the potential conflicts of interest that can arise. Patrick, thank you so much for joining us in the studio. Thank you for having me. Just before we get there, though, because I guess it'd be remiss not to ask you, do you think that we're going to have a higher print and we're going to have a not so ho ho Christmas with a November rate hike from the RBA? I hope I'm wrong, but I think, yeah, we're probably going to have a rough few months ahead of us. Yeah. Okay. That's interesting. Just because inflation is a little bit sticky. Yeah. Yeah. And unemployment still really low. Yeah. Well those immigration levels continue to run really high. Nevertheless we've gone off course. So let's get back on course. So really interesting points that you've brought to office today about how some private credit funds that lend to businesses also have an equity stake in these companies. Can you sort of flesh this out a little bit for our viewers so they

0:59

understand what potentially might happen? Yeah. So the two specific well two general examples. One is where the investment manager has a credit fund and an equity fund, and the other where the manager has a credit fund that raises capital for the managers private investment projects. That tends to be property development. So the conflict arises where if you're the equity fund and you require a loan, you heat up the credit fund. The loan might pass muster, but it could be marginal. And this is where the gray area occurs. It's marginal. So if you're a pure play private credit fund, you probably say, look, marginal is not good enough. But if you got the equity fund with the high fee structure, you've got to ask yourself the loan does take the boxes. Do we do the loan and generate alpha on the equity fund and large fees, or do we not do the loan and have our equity fund? The asset goes sideways for a few years.

1:55

Intuitively, that just sounds so wrong. Yes. I mean, just a really basic premise that seems like the most massive conflict of interest because it's very hard to strike a win win situation for both funds, as you've just alluded to. Absolutely, absolutely. And the challenge there is funds can defend it by saying, look, we've got a trustee and it's an arm it sounds like, but they tend to be their own trustee. So I put on my credit fund hat and say, this is a good loan. Then I take that hat off, move to that chair, put on my equity fund it and go, yeah, that's a good loan as well.

2:30

And then sign off. It's the same signature on both pieces of paper. Okay, it probably sounds like a silly question, and it seems quite obvious to me why they do this, but nevertheless, why do they do this?

2:43

Because the fee structure is, well, two key reasons. One is the key. One is fee structures. And equity funds are far more attractive because you can make an equity fund can generate alpha real outperformance and the performance fee can be substantial. Whereas the credit fund it tends to be a management fee with a very marginal performance fee. So the equity, the returns in the equity fund pay the bills really or pay the bonuses, whereas the credit fund pays the bills. Okay. And

3:14

I suppose it's worth just highlighting again is where are I suppose at the end of the day,

3:22

you talk about how the trustees and they change the hats, but, you know, where are the major areas of concerns for the investors? I mean, one would think it's in the equity fund rather than in the credit fund, but maybe you can explain that the risks are across both funds. Yeah. The risk really is in the credit fund because the equity fund is getting you know, equity has got no downside. Protection is all upside. So if someone will give me capital at a high price or low price, but it's debt capital that allows me to grow, I'm a winner because I'm just banking on the blue sky upside. Whereas if you're a credit fund investor, you're assuming your money is being deployed in the best possible way. Yeah, but there's a chance it's not always in the best possible way because the manager has, let's not call it a conflict is under pressure to help the other fund. And to my earlier point, the loan ticks all the boxes. It just marginal. So you probably wouldn't do it,

4:22

but you're under pressure to do it because you've got the equity fund and you probably will because, you know, at the end of the day, you've got to generate your fees to pay the bills. Yeah. So you're saying the credit fund would take the greater hit rather than the equity fund, even though wouldn't the credit fund have some recourse to the assets and the equity fund? That's assuming it's an asset backed loan. Right. Okay. These these transactions tend to be cash flow lend. So you secured over the equity right. So the equity goes to zero. You've got to claim over zero. Yeah. But the net position the equity would also lose completely would it not. They would. But they shouldn't have gotten the debt in the first place. Right okay. What's interesting is. Is there any particular sectors where this tends to be more dominant than other sectors? This type of conflict, you know, where you have the equity fund and the credit fund. Generally in the SME space, the sub $30 million loan space. So the KKR is the world. There's a lot more oversight there. Retail investors and institutional investors. I think it's a bit harder for

5:22

them to do it. But in that SME space, definitely and definitely the property space. Okay, so maybe it's worth asking the question if you are interested in going into this private credit space or private equity space, what would be some of the questions that investors would need to ask and need to understand to see that you don't have this this cross? Well, it's not cross ownership, but I'm inferring there's a crossover between the two asset classes. Yeah. The easiest one is to read the documents. The documents will disclose it all 500 pages. Yeah. Or five. Yeah. That's right on page 45. Footnote somewhere it's there.

6:05

And to speak to the fund manager and asked them, you know, generally quite open, but they say, yeah, we may do loans and we may do cross investment. It's all for the greater good. Yeah. But you've got to understand people have conflicts and people have incentives. Yeah. So you can disclose it. It doesn't mean the decision is always the right one. Okay. And I'm assuming your fund doesn't do that. We're a pure play private credit fund okay. The view we take is our investors or any fund investor pays you a fee to act in their best interests and in no one else's interests. So we we chose to stay within our lane, and that's all we do. And that's all we write. And how have the fund flows been recently? You still saying good demand for private credit? Very strong demand. We're seeing a lot more capital going into the property space at the moment. Oh interesting. Yeah. Because Australian investors love anything that's got the word property on it because the view is you can never lose money on property. Yeah. Yeah. So we do a bit of investor education and go

7:05

property is a really good asset class in this country. But you've got to ask what type of property. Yeah. Because you're getting a 13% return on a first ranking mortgage at a 50% LVR. That sounds too good to be true. And it probably is a little bit good. And and it'll be a property that's 400km west of Geelong. Yeah. There hasn't been a sale in three years, but you secured against it. So there's a default. You own a farmhouse, you don't get your money back. Okay. But investors don't see that. They see LVR property backed big yield. And I'll get this big return in 12 months.

More like this

We value your privacy

We use essential cookies to make the site work. Non-essential cookies help us improve the experience. You can accept or reject non-essential cookies. Privacy policy