Sign inJoin free

Watch / the global view

Momentum Trading vs Greater Fool Theory

the global view4 June 202412:28

Momentum Trading vs Greater Fool Theory

General information only. ausbiz videos are general information only, produced by Ausbiz TV Pty Ltd, a media business that doesn’t give financial advice. They don’t take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Consider whether it’s right for you and read the PDS and TMD before acting on anything you watch.

About this video

Steve Sosnick, from Interactive Brokers, presents his views on the current market behaviour. He questions the market's reaction to the start of a new month, and how this may have affected certain buying decisions. Steve notes that economic reports have been disappointing and consumers are starting to push back against unfettered price hikes by consumer goods companies. He also shares his concerns about the pause in Federal Reserve action and contemplates whether the inflation picture could trigger change.

Steve also analyses the bond market's response to the new month and its impact on equity markets. He discused the pivotal role of big companies like Nvidia (NASDAQ: NVDA), projecting that the market's response to their influence could disclose further insight. The potential sale of Nvidia offers an strong perspective, as it is likely to be codependent on its trade x ten for one split decision. Steve counters that stocks typically rally after major splits but, due to the easy access of fractional shares, the market's reaction could be unpredictable.

Speaking on momentum trading, Steve likens it to Isaac Newton's first law of motion, that an object in motion tends to stay in motion unless acted upon by an external force. He differentiates a healthy uptrend from just a ramp by using Nvidia as an example of a favourable trend due to its continuous raise and beating of estimates. However, he also warns of the greater fool theory, stating that buying a stock based solely on the anticipation of selling it for a higher price later is risky business.

Below is an unedited transcript of the interview:

This was really the the challenge that the market had today, and I was a bit surprised by how aggressively the bond market reacted to it. I do think there's some, uh, start of the month factors in there, you know, some some new calendar month buying that kind of thing. Uh, but this is the this is what we're really having to wrestle with right now. Um, and that is the economic reports are are lackluster at best. Um, prices paid has not been too much of a problem, but it's not they're not low enough. And this is sort of a minor prices paid measure. So it's not really enough to move the needle. I think where people are where people are getting a bit nervous is we're starting to see some pushback and consumer spending. Uh, we there was a lot of talk over the last couple of weeks about consumer goods companies, which had been able to raise prices more or less unfettered, um, starting to find the need to do, like, you know, doorbuster sales and price promotions here and there. So I do think there's this malaise creeping in, but not necessarily bad enough yet to get the

0:59

fed off the sidelines. Or is the inflation picture good enough to get them off the sidelines? We'll learn more about the jobs picture, uh, later this week, and we'll learn more about what they're thinking about. Um, the whole package, uh, when the FOMC meets next week, we also get, uh, later this week, the ISM services rating as well. Uh, how where is the market going to be of that.

1:22

What's going to be another one because, you know, I think everybody's kind of. I thought everybody, let me say, had come to grips with the idea that, um, manufacturing and goods and services were seeing some challenges, but services had been very strong. Let's see how the market reacts to that. It's not an easy number to predict. The consensus is usually not generally that correct, but it's more about direction. Um, and that's one of those that that I think after today's, uh, you know, manufacturing report, we're going to start we're going to have to pay close attention to the services report when it when it comes out later.

1:56

Steve. Beginning of a new month and interesting to see what happened in May. Selling may go away. Hasn't really played out, has it?

2:06

We don't know that yet. You don't really. You know, this would literally be the first day you could decide to sell in May. Worked out. Obviously. So far it hasn't. You don't know if selling May works until June at the earliest. Um, certainly sell in April. Didn't work. Certainly sell in early May. Didn't work because we rallied. We rallied later in the month. But you know, as we get into the summer doldrums here, um, you know, that's typically a lackluster period. You hear the term summer rally. Yeah. There's always a summer rally because there's always there's always, you know, some rally and some decline. Markets move in both directions. But, um, I think there's, you know, some fear creeping back in. Not in a major way. Uh, but we're starting to see volatility measures pick up a little bit. They're creeping a little higher. Um, you know, let's see if let's see what happens. Certainly if you manage to sell at the highs in May, um, you know, you'll know soon enough whether this was a good result. And we'll know sort of if, you know, even if you sold sort of to the lower end, um, this will all resolve itself over the summer

3:06

and over the coming months. So, Steve, what is determining your investment strategy at the moment?

3:13

Right now, I'm still concerned about the what I would call the imbalance between fear and greed or or the general levels of complacency that I see. You and I have talked about this before, and, you know, we've sort of been treading water, uh, to some extent. But, you know, Friday's Friday's rally was, you know, pure and end of month markup. It was one of the most egregious end of the month markups that I'd seen because we were down pretty much all day Friday. And then we started to creep back a little bit. And then lo and behold, with, you know, 15 minutes left to go, we start climbing and then we, you know, we end up closing up almost a full percent that that's kind of phony. Um, we saw some pullback today after the ISM numbers came out. Um, we clawed back there. I will say some of it was again because of the the new month, you know, the marking up the new month. But I also do think that the bond market, you know, as it continued to steadily, uh, decline, you know, as yields are steadily declined, I think that was enough of a spur

4:12

for the for the equity markets. A lot revolves around, you know, can these big names keep delivering? Because I think we're getting increasingly more dependent on a smaller cadre of mega-cap tech stocks. And Nvidia is the one, of course, that that's the linchpin of it all. And today if you you know, you showed the chart earlier, you'll notice that that it just sort of ramped right into the close. This is what we're seeing a lot of closing ramps. Um, and another thing to keep in mind with Nvidia is next week it trades x ten for one split. We will know then if it's a buy the rumor, sell that, buy the rumor, sell the news event regarding their split. Stocks do tend to rally when you get major stock splits. It's not clear that in an era where there's no distinction about odd lot versus round lot trading, or where fractional shares are widely available, um, to individual investors, it's not clear the idea of, um, you know, that this makes it more affordable for ordinary investors. But, you know, the perception perception trumps reality much of

5:12

the time. And the perception is that it's helpful. Let's see. Let's see if there's a bit of a pullback when you've seen other major stocks, um, have stock splits. In some cases it has acted as a bit of a sell the news event. I don't know that the market can handle a major sell the news event in Nvidia right now. Will another stock in focus, for better or for worse, is GameStop. Those meme stocks? You can't shake them, can you? Steve, I was interested to to read your take on this, where you're comparing momentum trading with the greater fool theory. Just talk us through this.

5:51

Yeah, there is a bit of a distinction and it's it's sort of like a they they're operating almost on a continuum momentum trading, which is a very time tested and valid approach toward, toward trading, is basically saying the trend is your friend. Markets that are in motion do tend to stay in motion until acted upon by an outside force. You know, that's sort of my way of paraphrasing Isaac Newton. Uh, but basically, you know, we all we all kind of know that that, you know, it's a little bit easier to hop onto a trend, uh, than it is to fight that trend, um, or to find turning points. It's most of the money is made during uptrends, but at some point that you have to sort of separate. Is it a healthy uptrend or is it just or is it just a ramp? And that's really the difference. You know, uh, let's contrast in video which, which I, I can't help but talking about either for better or worse, that is that is one of the most monstrous mega trends that I can recall. But the rationale behind it is they make

6:51

money, they keep raising estimates, they keep beating the raised estimates and then raising them again. That's phenomenal. That's a trend you don't want to fight. At some point, inevitably the stock will get overdone. It always happens. But if you're going to tell me that your trend following in Nvidia okay, I get it. You're you're you're you're getting out ahead of a company with good earnings if you're doing it in some very speculative stock. And we've seen besides GameStop, besides AMC, we've seen a huge amount of activity and very very small cap stocks. And, you know, FFI was one that went from like $0.15 to $4, then back to $0.50. These kind of trades, if you're doing it there simply because you think that someone will pay you more for it, not because there's any necessarily good reason for someone to pay you more for it. Um, that's where it becomes greater fool theory. In the case of, let's say again, an Nvidia or, you know, or Microsoft or something of that nature, if you're buying it because you think someone will pay you more for it later on because

7:51

the company will be worth more because it has earnings and cash flows and all those nice things. Sure. That's investing. And especially it's helpful if there's a trend, if you just buy some random some random stock because it's moving and you don't know what it does and it doesn't make any money, um, and you're just hoping that you can turn it around fast enough because someone else will buy it from you. That is the greater fool theory, and that's really what you have to consider if you're if you're trading in very, very fast moving, highly volatile, highly momentum driven stocks, and I've seen a lot of, uh, greater fool theory, I think to some extent creeping into at least some of the more speculative names.

More like this

We value your privacy

We use essential cookies to make the site work. Non-essential cookies help us improve the experience. You can accept or reject non-essential cookies. Privacy policy