Sign inJoin free

Watch / Investment strategy

Let the volatility play out...

6 Aug 20248:01

Let the volatility play out...

General information only. ausbiz videos are general information only, produced by Ausbiz TV Pty Ltd, a media business that doesn’t give financial advice. They don’t take into account your objectives, financial situation or needs. Consider whether it’s right for you and read the PDS and TMD before acting on anything you watch.

About this video

In the light of the market's recent volatility, Jason Teh of Vertium Asset Management highlights the role of the Bank of Japan's rate hike and large cap stocks. He refers to the surprising amount of impact the Bank's rate rise made on a globally interconnected market. According to Jason, large caps, particularly tech stocks in the U.S. and banks in Australia, have been ruling the market, but their inherent instability could lead to significant reversals.

Jason brings focus on Commonwealth Bank of Australia (ASX:CBA), stating that it's been performing like a tech stock without corresponding earnings. He compares this scenario to the Nifty50 bubble in the U.S. during the 1970s; where high quality companies, such as McDonald's (NYSE: MCD), witnessed a share price rollercoaster ride and took more than ten years to recover. He warns that high valuation risks are often overlooked amidst low earning risks.

Jason's current view is that smaller caps have been lagging behind large caps for months. He suggests that this could be a hint towards market instability. His advice at this stage of the market cycle is to be patient and wait for the volatility to play out. He recognises that although some valuations have pulled back in recent days, they are far from cheap. Stocks' movements, he says, will rely on upgrades and downgrades amidst various external influences, such as the unwind of the Japanese carry trade.

Full unedited transcript below:

0:00

Let's say, get into the markets with some stock specifics. At the same time, given the volatility we're seeing, Jason Tay is joining us from Viridian Asset Management Jason a very good Tuesday morning to you as we all take a breath given what we saw yesterday also overnight on global markets of course. How are you seeing this at the moment with this extreme volatility. And you know the question for investors is of course what's next.

0:28

Yeah. So look I mean I think the straw that broke the camel's back was when the Bank of Japan, uh, raised rates and it was just a little bit. I mean, you you would think a small, uh, shift, uh, upwards in rates, um, wouldn't normally do anything, but, uh, but like I said, it was a straw that broke the camel's back. Um, the, you know, you think the think about the consensus trade, uh, over the last, uh, you know, a quite a few months now has been I and also the perceived safety associated with large caps. So, um, you know, those big cap stocks basically, um, unwound when, when, um, when, you know, I guess a small butterfly event that happened in Japan, uh, has affected and has permeated to the rest of the world. Right. So, um, with, uh, you know, with increased volatility, uh, which is this is what you expect when when you get the foundations of the market on, uh, on shaky grounds.

1:27

Yeah. We're talking about the foundation of the market then and only I mean, you need to look at the Australian market, but also evidence of this, of course, on Wall Street as well, with that very narrow leadership of large stocks, plainly to see with the Magnificent Seven, of course, but locally, I guess, and you're making this point that you look at some of those bank stocks in particular CBA.

1:49

Yeah. So, you know, I mean, look, the concentration of these leaders leading the market, I mean, the US, uh, it's obviously tech related. But then in Australia, um, you know, you we have a boom in banking share prices, uh, without a boom in profits. So, so their valuations have reached sky high multiples. I mean, CBI is the poster child in that space, is trading on 2223 times multiples, the highest ever in 20 years. Um,

2:21

and, you know, I mean, and in fact, these stocks are propping up the market because, uh, not many other stocks are performing like Ciba. Um, and of course, when, you know, when the tide, uh, turns and, and, you know, CPI share prices reverses, it just takes down the market with it.

2:40

So are you calling that a bubble? Because I see you're actually drawing some parallels from history here, particularly what we saw with McDonald's back in the 70s. Yeah, yeah. So look, um, in terms of bubbles, typically, you know, most investors are sort of aware of the dotcom, um, bubble or and even the pandemic bubble, which wasn't that long ago. And, and around that time it was pretty much the non-profitable companies. Um, you know, that's been aggressively bid. But in terms of high quality companies and the bubbles associated with it's actually quite rare. And you have to sort of go back into the early 1970s. And uh, back then in the US, it was called the Nifty50 bubble. Right. And and McDonald's was, um, you know, the, the poster child of, of that bubble where its share price rocketed to 60 times PE. Right. And, you know, if you look at its earnings profile over that decade plus, it was just resilient. It was a very high quality business uh, every year continuing to

3:40

grow. Um, but the share price wasn't. So when its share price peaked in late uh, 1972. Um, you know, investors who had investments in McDonald's back then probably lost 50% of their capital right from a share price perspective. And it took more than a decade for the share price to recover to its previous peak. So, so, um, chasing these types of companies on the perceived notion of low earnings risk, um, I think investors can sometimes confuse that with replacing it with high valuation risk. And I think CBA, despite the fact that it is the best run bank in Australia. Right. Um, uh, it is also the most expensive, right. So, so here's the chart of CBA share price. It's pretty much, uh, sort of alluded to earlier, had its share price has performed like I stocks without the I earnings. Yeah. It's earnings has been pretty flat. So uh it has record multiples. Yeah. Which of course took it to uh,

4:40

over eclipsing BHP to become the most valuable company on the local exchange. So Jason, having said all that then where do you want to be right now?

4:51

All right. So look at this stage of where the market cycle is. Um, you know, I think initially for quite a few months we've seen small caps lagging large caps. Right. So basically the analogy I like to say, especially for the stock market generally, for a healthy market, you like to see the generals, which is uh, the leading stocks, uh, you know, marching with the soldiers, the rest of the market. Right. So,

5:18

um, and if the soldiers aren't following the general, something's wrong. Right. So everybody's gravitating towards these large companies, and if there will be a point in time when the generals fall over and and that's the time where markets are taken down with the generals. So at this point in time, I think you just got to wait for the volatility to play out, right. No point trying to be a hero and trying to pick the market bottom and just wait for this volatility to subside. Right. So because um, when you look at valuations today like yes, despite the fact that they have pulled back a little bit over the last few years. Uh, sorry, a few days. Um, they're not cheap. I mean, CBS pulled back a little bit, you know, it's still trading north of 20 times multiple and historically trades on 15. So, uh, there's a long way to go for, uh, for some of these valuations to unwind. Is this going to change your approach, if you like, the way the prism you look through in terms of local earnings season?

6:18

Um, not necessarily. I think, uh, look, stocks will move, uh, based on, you know, upgrades and downgrades. Um, you know, obviously like and obviously the, the, um, the stock you highlighted earlier ordinate, uh, obviously, uh, lower their outlook. And obviously that's a big downgrade. And obviously stocks will move accordingly, uh, like that. Um, so I think this reporting season will be very similar to other reporting seasons, um, where the market will look for some sort of guidance, especially associated with the guidance outlook. Um, um, but also be aware there are other, you know, moving forces that's happening right now. Like I said, this, uh, the the unwind of, uh, the Japanese carry trade, uh, is is the biggest influence, uh, that's affecting, um, you know, everything right now.

7:11

What? Just in terms of, uh, you mentioning ordinate there? Um, why do you think it has chosen today of all days to, uh, to give that that warning ahead of its main earnings results later in the month, do you think? Uh, look, I think they're just trying to come clean. I think, uh, uh, you know, if, uh, there's a material change in the outlook or material material change in its current earnings, uh, I think companies have to come clean. I think wasn't that long ago when Domino's had to come clean before their results. I think it was two results ago. And, and um, you know, it got, uh, severely hit off the back of the changing outlook. Um, and, um, yeah, this is no different. So I guess we're pretty much on the cusp of reporting season start starting. So so I don't think there'll be many other stocks coming out, uh, trying to sort of create a clean slate.

More like this

We value your privacy

We use essential cookies to make the site work. Non-essential cookies help us improve the experience. You can accept or reject non-essential cookies. Privacy policy