Key stock performances this reporting season
About this video
Harry Watt, from Shaw and Partners, gives his post-reporting season analysis. According to Harry, almost a third of the companies missed their targets, while a similar number were inline or exceeded expectations. Key performances to note include Ramsay Healthcare, which Harry admits came in a bit light on numbers but was buoyed by the stock's rise. He also touches on BHP, which saw a significant decline in the past few weeks. Discussion further delves into other notable companies such as Harvey Norman and Star Entertainment. Regarding Harvey Norman, despite an unimpressive topline halfway through, Harry commends its strong control on costs which he attributes to the 10% beat on profit before tax. As for Star Entertainment, Harry admits that while earnings are satisfactory, regulatory issues loom as a major concern for investors. He maintains the company has value, but unlocking it proves to be a challenge. In assessing Xero's recent investor update, Harry highlights the company's focus on Artificial Intelligence (AI), a current hot topic in the business world. He hails Xero's high-quality offering particularly in Australia and New Zealand, while also acknowledging its struggle in the US market. Harry finalises his commentary saying it's essential for Xero to grow its margins to fully realise its longer-term value for shareholders.
Below is the full unedited transcript of this interview:
0:00
Let's get more on reporting season, which is officially wrapping up. Ramsay Healthcare, Harvey Norman among those coming through with numbers, let's discuss with Harry Watt from Shaw and Partners. Harry, I just wanted to start with how you think corporate Australia has fared. I was just looking at that FN arena, um, poll of how they've looked at things, and I think something like 30% of companies were a bit.
0:23
Yeah, it looks about a third of third or third. So third way to third in line and a third missed. Uh, this reporting period, there was a lot of risk around this reporting period. From our point of view, your market was trading pretty much at all time highs at the start of the month, at the start of February, when we started to see some numbers coming through. And it's still up there at the moment. And, uh, that comes despite some dividends coming out as well through the period. So overall, um, I think this is a really good reporting season. There was a lot of bullish expectations maybe built in more to the pricing side of things. So equities are trading at probably the top end of their valuation ranges heading into it. Uh and they're still holding up there as we come out of that as well. And that all sort of comes despite, you know, BHP being down pretty significantly through the last few weeks as well. So overall, uh, broadly speaking, I think this is a pretty solid reporting period for the ASX. We saw a pretty solid reporting period for the US market as well. And I think that's a big tick for where equity markets are at the moment. And what do you think about Ramsey's numbers out today, Harry?
1:22
Little bit light on from Ramsey if I'm honest. But the stock's up today. And I think that's a reflection of where that stock was trading in particular heading into this result. It's not a stock that's beaten often over the last few years. Uh recent history suggests it's a pretty poor performer on reporting day and it's, uh, done poorly. Uh, today's result small miss. Uh, if you look through the numbers. So they sold Sime Darby their stake in time. Darby through the periods of that little, uh, bit of accounting, makes the numbers a little bit hard to read through. But if you spin that out and you take that out of the numbers, it's probably a small mis overall that Mis was driven by, uh, costs more. So on the Australian side of the business from what we've seen, uh, but the UK business did really well. That mental health, uh, uh, company or offering over there has done really well. The, uh, European business was held up maybe by a few government grants coming through there as well. The Australian business is probably their, uh, crown jewel. And what we want to see doing well is probably a little bit underperformer there. But it was priced for mis. Uh, market wasn't expecting much out of Ramsay. They've
2:22
delivered a small miss. I suspect that, um, if they get the usual first half, second half skew that we've seen from this company over the last few years, it's probably in line with consensus on the full year track. So overall pretty reasonable set of numbers on a stock that was sort of, uh, you know, not not priced for perfect resolve heading into this one. Harry, when we look at Harvey Norman, obviously it saw some really good trading during the Covid pandemic when we were stuck at home loving our homes. Had some extra cash. Not as good this half though.
2:54
No, not a great half from Harvey Norman on topline numbers at all. But, uh, in terms of expectations, it's been again on the market. So once again, retailers are really priced for misses heading into this period. Uh, and we've seen JB Hi-Fi shoot the lights out. That's trading at all time highs. Harvey Norman had a massive short head position heading into this result, and it's come in slightly better than expected. I'd call that a 10% beat on profit before tax for Harvey Norman. That's a big tick. So sales coming off the ball a lot of this, uh, beat was driven by better margins. So better cost control for Harvey Norman. We didn't see massive property revaluation, which is one thing Jerry likes to do to sort of bump up his half year numbers in this period. So that's another big tick as well. So it's not as messy, uh, as not as fudgy as, uh, you know, Harvey Norman reports in the past, uh, like I said, massive short position heading into this result. And it's come in better than expected. We see the stock pop above $5 a share today, January sales as well so that their outlook statements were pretty reasonable. So we've seen a
3:54
bit of an uplift in sales in January tracking a bit better than 1%. Uh, up on this time last year uh, for the Australian franchise business there. So overall big tech for Harvey Norman today. Retailers are probably one area I call out that's done a lot better than expected in this, uh, in this half year reporting period. Harry, we're also looking at Star Entertainment always at one to watch. And obviously this was delayed too due to the regulatory concerns. What did you read into this one?
4:27
Are the results? Sort of. It's okay. It's not too bad from star. They sort of said at the AGM that they were looking to do about 20 million EBITDA a month. Uh, and they've come in a little bit below that, but not, uh, significantly. So, uh, so I call that a tick. Generally they said it was tracking sort of towards that number as well. So overall you know earnings side of things. Earnings for star uh is doing okay. Obviously that's probably not the focus for investors at the moment. These regulatory issues are just continuing. Uh on for the company. They haven't quite got this New South Wales license, uh bedded down in their issues in New South Wales, bedded down. Uh, and that will be a concern for investors moving forward. Um, we saw the review the last time the review came out. I said they weren't, uh, they shouldn't be holding a licence, basically. And they've come back to the market basically to say that they haven't quite ticked all the boxes that that review found. Um, moving forward, there's a lot of value in this company. It's exceptionally cheap where it's trading. Um, but they do have to unlock that
5:27
value for shareholders. The market will price them where the stock's trading, and unlocking that value for shareholders is probably a bit of an arm wrestle. You have a look at the hotel side of the business which is you know, their property side of the business is, um, you know, there's a lot of value there that they can unlock. And hotel bookings numbers are down marginally. They're not down significantly. So they've seen a little bit of, uh, you know, roll off in terms of their restaurant business and their and their bar business as well, but not majorly so as well. So there is some value there that maybe it'd be better off in a different entity or better off in someone else's hands. So overall star once again price for a miss came in May, more or less in line with expectations. Today, uh, we're seeing the stock rally on the back of that
6:11
and just having a quick look at zero. I mean, it doesn't look like investors like its investor update, which is interesting because they've talked about AI, which is sort of the hot topic at the moment.
6:22
It is the hot topic. I think maybe maybe it's been, uh, you know, used a bit at the moment. II is sort of everyone's sort of coming out and putting an eye tag on, on one part of their business or another. Um, zero they've got a really high quality offering for, uh, you know, particularly in the Australia and New Zealand market. But the area of the market that I've really struggled to grow is the US. They have signed a deal with today's Investor Day update that gives them access to about 470,000 small businesses over there in the US. And in terms of building payments, uh, a partnership there. And I think that's a tick. Um, I think they do have to focus continually focus on that us that, uh, US growth market, but also not forgetting the Australian and New Zealand, uh, area that they're so solid in. Um, and I think that is sort of what the Investor Day is trying to explain is that they'll continue to get incremental growth out of that US business. They continue to focus on that Australia, New Zealand business as a core. Um, and then, you know, plugging into May to make a little bit better from a
7:22
user experience side. Um, I think I it's a bit of a hot topic at the moment. And just saying, coming out and saying they're going to do it is one thing. Uh, and coming out with improving experience for customers is another thing. So still, I think it's a pretty high level, uh, update from zero today. Um, it's a company that that I think should do a little bit better, given there's, uh, been some takeouts of Australian, uh, tech names lately. Altium there, that that money might find its way into Xero. So there might be a bit of a technical trade going on there. Uh, but the business, uh, you know, it needs to grow. It needs to grow its margins moving forward, uh, to really realise longer term value for shareholders. And I think that's not really been explained properly in today's Investor Day.