James' deep value copper play
About this video
James Whelan from Barclay Pearce Capital provides his insights about the surprising rise of copper in the market in recent months and how the future looks for this commodity. James makes clear that the copper boom started around February, something he says he had long predicted. He highlights that fund managers are increasingly getting behind commodities, particularly copper, according to recent Bank of America surveys. James refers to insights from Rob Rennie, Westpac’s chief head of commodity strategy, pointing to the futures market which indicate long-term gains for copper.
Referencing Jeff Curry of Goldman Sachs and now with Carlyle Group, James explains the importance of concentrate charges as a marker of market tightness and shortage. He dramatises the situation in South Korea where these charges went negative, implying a severe lack of concentrate. The indication from this, according to James, is a forthcoming shortage at the mine, which will eventually impact the end-use consumer.
He adds a deep value suggestion for a company called Alma Metals (ALM), offering substantial amounts of lower-grade copper. James debates the overall moves in markets and the prospects for this bull run to continue. He suggests that the market needs a breather but that in the long run there are further gains to be made, underpinned by strength in commodities and a probable weakening US dollar, and potential moves by the Federal Reserve.
Below is the full unedited transcript of this interview:
0:00
Well, one thing that has really stood out in markets over the last few months has been this tear that copper has been on. James Whelan Barclay Capital, MD, joins me now in studio. I mean, ballistic in your words. Did I say ballistic? So I did. Yeah, that sounds close enough. It's always good to be here with you too, Juliet. It's fantastic. Okay, so tell us that the moves that we've been seeing here, hasn't it been a bit funny? And it all sort of kicked off around this February area. Now, I'd like to say that, yeah, I picked the February move perfectly, but that is also coming into the fact that I've said by copper pretty much every single chance that I've had to say for the last seven years. Yeah. So finally I managed to get it. Finally I managed to get it correct, which is. Which is great. Um, let's just start with this, okay? First off, the fund manager survey did kick off, uh, or, you know, the monthly thing that comes out from the Bank of America showed that fund managers were the most overweight commodities since April 23rd. Not that far back, not that far long ago. But you can sort of see that if they really want to get bullish, they really can get far more overweight. So there is more there
1:00
is more capacity. There's a lot more bullets in the chamber for them to, um, for them to fire. And I think that there's a lot more moves we're seeing, generally speaking, in commodities and specifically in copper as well. We're seeing the futures market is pointing to to more extended gains over the long term. But also we're seeing shorts are being unwound as well and getting it through that. The big one for me that that that really sort of like I was looking for a way to summarize everything that was here. It's actually Rob Rennie, Westpac chief head of commodity strategy over there, one of the smartest guys I know in commodity, in fact, the smartest guy I know in commodities who he said, Jimmy, have a look at this thing. Um, that's really great. From your old shop, the the Bloomberg Odd Locks podcast. Um, that that that do great. Joe and Tracy. Joe and Tracy. G'day. If you're watching I know that they are. They're big fans of mine. Um, I once got Tracy to almost eat an ibis anyway when she was out here. Long story. Great story. Anyway, back to. We'll keep on it. Okay, so it was Jeff Curry who was formerly of Goldman Sachs, um, commodity strategy at Goldman Sachs. He's now with Carlyle Group. And he was talking about the TC chatter. So the concentrate charges, there's always a good way to pick exactly what's
1:59
going on. Now concentrate charges. It's a bit of an education thing there. The fees that mining companies pay smelters to have their semi processed or concentrate turned into the metal. The best, easiest rule that you can have. Write this down. Here's your CPD points, is that the tighter the spot supply then the that you'll see a drop in TCS. So there's concentrate charges that will drop. So if it's a tight market you see a drop in it. He saw. And I'm not going to quote the whole thing. But he saw that in South Korea um where there was not enough concentrate to go around to be able to smelt into something that was more useful. The concentration right now, everybody's they actually went negative. So this is where he was seeing that, that when the concentrate charges went negative, which is telling you the shortage. And this is why I'm telling you this because it's going to say that it's actually further down the the path that we're seeing. We're going to see more increases
2:49
telling you the shortages at the mine in that concentrate not at the end use consumer yet. It's going to work its way down there. The fact that you have zero or negative TC charges right now is an indication that you have shortages at the mine, which says eventually it's going to work its way downstream, which is we look out further, particularly towards the end of the year, we'd expect those shortages to work its way downstream more towards the consumer and away from the mine. All right. So how do we play this? Because I think you're the third person in two days that told me about the ETF wire. Yeah.
3:19
It's a copper mine is ETF. It's listed here. It's my globally. It's fantastic. This is why it's it's I was saying I didn't I mean I could talk about copper but I'm not going to be the first person to be on here this week talking about copper. Oh no. But I mean it's getting a lot of we had global ETF on yesterday. Did a great job. I had um Mark Gardner as well. So why are the ETF that's listed here. But you also like copper on the list. So Copa has been has always been my preferred direct method of getting into the copper market. Amazingly some fund managers that that I talked to don't know that of its existence. It's effectively just a straight way to be. It's a leave it to the copper price. Um, and it's, it's, it's listed in the LSC. So I think there's one in the LSC that's in pounds and there's one in the LSC that's in USD. So you've got to talk about what sort of currency position you want to take on that. But that's up to you. Buying copper in USD probably doesn't sound like the best thing to do. You probably want to buy it in pounds, but then you've got Rishi Sunak over there. Whatever he's doing is changing everything around to whatever, so that's the best way of getting access to it locally. Here, you've got to look at these copper stocks and try and figure out the wheat from the chaff.
4:19
I think that there's a deep value and I'm here for the ideas. There's a deep a deep value play called Alma Além that's listed here, um, that has a fairly substantial amount of lower grade copper, but it's really close to a port in Gladstone. Um, that's for me. And it hasn't really moved. So it's not even $0.01 this stock. Oh, she's deep value. Don't worry about that. Yeah. Wow. Yeah. And but it hasn't really moved even with this copper price. It's gone and it hasn't really moved. And I think it's one of those ones that it just needs a little bit of a momentum behind it to get it done. I know that it is funded um, for for long enough to be relevant. So I'm happy for aam to sort of go on the table and go you know what. I'm happy with that. But if you want access to it. Wire is a great way to get access to it. That's locally listed through from the global side, um, and Copa over in London as well. Let's talk about the overall moves in markets. Is this bull market. Is it going to keep running. Is it running towards this red flag or is there no red flag. Well I mean maybe with copper. The fact that everyone's been on here talking about copper this week probably might be not the best
5:19
strategy. It's a copper. It's it's for a short term maybe. I think that there could be a sell off. And amazingly, it's it's always just before I come on out of Thursday. It's not 5% overnight, so it's going to be I'm the guy who's going to come in and say, yeah, now's the time to pick it up on big dips. Yes, copper on big dips. Always the market market usually go up be be pretty bullish. Again back to the fund managers survey. We saw that cash balances were quite low. That's usually a tell for me that the market needs to have a bit of a breather long term though we've got further to go, so the stats are always good from the casting group. Um,
5:49
is is coming out talking about how far we've got in any bear market currently. If you look from the lows, the bull market lows. So effectively sorry, the bear market bottom, which for us was in October 22nd for two years later, the average amount that you usually are looking at is about 58% increase. So from the bear market bottom to two years later, point to point 58% is usually the increase that you've got. We're currently at 48%. It's May I know you're trying to figure it out from that chart, everyone. That's fantastic. Anyway, this is why I'm here talking about it. So we're at 48%. We're in May, so we've got five months to go until we hit that two year mark. So we've got about theoretically on average although past does not represent the future. We've got about 1,010% more increase to go to get us up to that 58% area. I see no reason why commodities won't be the reason that that happens, especially with the amount of bullish conditioning that's happening now in that commodity space. We need the US dollar to come off a touch more. And I think that with that disinflationary data, that's probably going to
6:49
come through more dovish fed signaling or less hawkish fed signaling, which seems to be the the the the modus operandi for the next couple of months. We're probably going to see that happen. Although I wouldn't charge in. I'll tell you what. You know, it was funny though. The old sell in May and go away situation. What are we currently at the end of May. Yeah it happened in April didn't it. It was a 5%. Yeah that happened in April. We were pre pre gaming. The moment changed. Everything's moving forward. Everything a quick word on BHP I mean it looks like it's still going to continue. Yeah. The government of the government on the week of. Yeah yeah. They gave another week to have a look at it. Won't say it won't take no for an answer. Well what's funny what's funny on this one is that if you want to sort of go back to the, to the copper market, I've got a sneaky feeling that yes, it will work. However, it won't fix it. It won't fix everything in that. In that regard, the what's funny is that it is far easier. And this is funny that a lot of the fund managers to say it was far easier for someone like BHP to make the biggest mining deal in history or whatever it's going to be, as opposed to it going back. You know, you can't go back in time, but going in and digging more holes in the
7:49
ground and digging out more copper and and making more copper far easier. It is for the for the biggest copper producer in the world, one of the second biggest. Yeah. In the world to go and just buy another one at that amount than it is to actually just go and dig more out of the ground, phenomenal sort of situation that's going on there. I think it'll go through M&A won't solve the copper problem, though. It won't dig more copper out of the ground.